• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Trek's magical sensors

JarodRussell

Vice Admiral
Admiral
How do they manage to notice that a ship a lightyear away is doing something in real time? Or that a ship is moving away from them or moving towards them at warp speed? Or that a ship is following them while they are themselves moving at warp? Can anybody offer a technobabble explanation?

Are they passively scanning tachyons that move a lot faster than light? Do subspace scanners enable them to scan anything at any distance in real time?
 
I'd say starships are easy. They have warp engines, after all - and those supposedly expend fantastic energies to produce FTL effects. It only stands to reason that they leak FTL radiation in all directions, radiation that can be easily and virtually immediately be picked up by passive sensors lightyears away.

Even starships that aren't moving at warp might emit FTL radiation from their idled engines. Their navigational deflectors might also glow like beacons, and they'd likewise employ FTL emissions to reach ahead of the ship. Most of the combat systems are likely to glow as well. And cloaks can only do so much to contain the glowing.

Now, observing realtime events on a distant planet is probably more difficult, because most planets don't have warp engines. Then again, our heroes very seldom do observe realtime events on distant planets - they merely observe things that might well be several decades out of date (and thus observable at lightspeed), such as the planet's climate, atmospheric chemistry, state of industrialization and whatnot.

Probably some sort of a FTL radar could also exist, though. It would send FTL energies outward and listen to the echoes or secondary emissions or whatnot. And while realspace is vast and distant targets thus impossibly small, subspace might be a different matter.

Timo Saloniemi
 
If you take notice in several episodes, ships that travel through subspace corridors travel far faster than warp speed. Slipstream travel seems to be achieved by entering the realm of subspace.

Warp drive however just manipulates subspace rather than has the ship enter it so it stands to reason IMO that sensors actually travel within the realm of subspace and therefore travel at higher speeds than maximum warp.

Chances are the speed of sensors within subspace are mind bogglingly fast.
 
If you take notice in several episodes, ships that travel through subspace corridors travel far faster than warp speed. Slipstream travel seems to be achieved by entering the realm of subspace.

Warp drive however just manipulates subspace rather than has the ship enter it so it stands to reason IMO that sensors actually travel within the realm of subspace and therefore travel at higher speeds than maximum warp.

Chances are the speed of sensors within subspace are mind bogglingly fast.

Well, speed of sensors is maybe a bit of a weird term to describe it. There are two possible types of sensors: active and passive. Active sends out a signal (for instance the infamous sonar ping, or a radar signal, or a laser beam) that is reflected by an object. Passive just waits for signals to come in (like our eyes, or passive sonar).
 
I'd go with the sensors emitting a type of energy that travels faster than light, a type of super radar. That would explain how the sensors pick up objects in real time in solar systems light years away.

Now if someone could explain to me how the JJprise can beam people from Saturn's moon Titan halfway across the solar system to the Narada in orbit around Earth without the people ending up inside of a wall or in space?
 
Last edited:
Why not? If they can take "photographs" of starbases from across dozens of lightyears, as they did with the Argus Array in TNG "Parallels", and see details like individual portholes on them, then they probably have enough resolution to comb Nero's nose hair with the transporter across a mere interplanetary distance.

Timo Saloniemi
 
I'd go with the sensors emitting a type of energy that travels faster than light, a type of super radar. That would explain how the sensors pick up objects in real time in solar systems light years away.

Now if someone could explain to me how the JJprise can beam people from Saturn's moon Titan halfway across the solar system to the Narada in orbit around Earth without the people ending up inside of a wall or in space?

And that instantly, too. At the speed of light, you'd need 75 minutes to get from Titan to Earth.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top