• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Trek comic crossover wish list

Laura Cynthia Chambers

Vice Admiral
Admiral
Which shows/comics/movies, etc would you like to see Trek comics crossover with? I thought a Person of Interest crossover might be neat. (Borg and Samaritan, or NuTrek Khan captured by Samaritan - I wrote a one-shot fanfic regarding this idea)
 
Last edited:
A runing trek series where you bump into different genres, building up to a final episode with all kinds of characters from all over.
Trek is the perfect background.
 
In the 90s I liked to think Seaquest DSV took place in the Star Trek universe. I would read that comic crossover.
I did the same thing with seaQuest DSV--particularly in its first season, when it was easy to envision the UEO as part of the ST past, though later seasons made the two worlds less compatible.

Having said that, those differences are no more difficult to gloss over than the other franchises Star Trek has crossed over with lately...and how hard could it possibly be to get the seaQuest tie-in licence?
 
I did the same thing with seaQuest DSV--particularly in its first season, when it was easy to envision the UEO as part of the ST past, though later seasons made the two worlds less compatible.

Having said that, those differences are no more difficult to gloss over than the other franchises Star Trek has crossed over with lately...and how hard could it possibly be to get the seaQuest tie-in licence?

I've not watched the show in years so I'm just going off hazy memories but the first two seasons were the good ones, and the second season ended on a cliffhanger. Without getting into story idea territory, I can imagine a Trek/seaQuest crossover that ignores the later seasons and picks up where season 2 left off. The more I think about this the more I like the idea.
 
Though there was never a comic book based on it (and only a single novelization), I would love a crossover between Star Trek and the 1980s War of the Worlds television series. To be frank, I wished at the time it was on the air that Paramount had done a crossover episode between TNG and WotW.
 
Though there was never a comic book based on it (and only a single novelization), I would love a crossover between Star Trek and the 1980s War of the Worlds television series. To be frank, I wished at the time it was on the air that Paramount had done a crossover episode between TNG and WotW.

I'm just as glad they didn't. I kinda liked the first season at the time it aired, more for the cast than anything else, but when I revisited it a few years ago, I realized it was awful. It had incredibly stupid writing most of the time and incredibly cheap production values -- sometimes it looked and sounded like it was shot in somebody's basement. And the second season was even more horrible in different ways. It would've been an embarrassment to have Star Trek tied to such a train wreck.

Besides, I'm not sure how reconcilable the idea of a global alien invasion in 1953 -- and a renewed alien infiltration in 1988 -- could've been with Trek history. This is why crossovers between different SF series rarely seem feasible to me. It's easy enough to cross over things set in the "real" world, like, say, Murder, She Wrote and Magnum, P.I. or Law & Order and Homicide, but different SF shows almost always have incompatible future histories, cosmologies, and even laws of physics. Their distinctive worldbuilding is integral to their identities as franchises. So the only ways to do crossovers between them are either to do an "alternate universes" crossover or to do an imaginary story that just pretends they're in a compatible reality. The latter isn't desirable to me because I don't like how much it has to gloss over, and I'm not a fan of the former either, because alternate timelines should still have the same overall cosmology and physical laws, which is often not the case in different SF universes. (For instance, there would've been no sane way to cross Star Trek, which is based on a somewhat accurate understanding of astronomy and the speed of light, with the original Battlestar Galactica, which depicted a fleet somehow traveling between multiple galaxies in a single year while never going faster than lightspeed.)
 
Plus, there's the whole problem where the characters of the non-Trek element know Trek to be a show and franchise in their universe.

Would also be kind of funny when you have characters played by Trek actors in the series. Such as Fringe. (Nimoy) The "relative on my mother's side" thing might be reaching its limit.
 
Last edited:
Plus, there's the whole problem where the characters of the non-Trek element know Trek to be a show and franchise in their universe.

Yeah, that's another problem. It's problematical to have, say, a Star Trek/X-Men crossover when several of the X-Men and other Marvel superheroes are Star Trek fans. Ditto with Star Trek and Doctor Who, since a number of characters in modern Who have made Trek references (like Rose Tyler comparing the Doctor to Spock). And in The Wounded Sky, Uhura and Lt. Freeman were upconverting old Doctor Who episodes to holovid. (Or maybe creating their own Fourth Doctor fanvids, because the scene depicted in the novel doesn't exist in the real series.)

Then, of course, there are the '60s Batman and Green Hornet shows. Each show depicted characters watching the other show on TV, so they were mutually fictional in each other's universes, but that didn't stop Batman from having the Green Hornet and Kato appear as real people twice -- first in a cameo where Batman and Robin were well aware that they were heroes only pretending to be gangsters, then in an episode where B&R believed them to be real gangsters. Continuity? Who needs it?
 
The latter isn't desirable to me because I don't like how much it has to gloss over, and I'm not a fan of the former either, because alternate timelines should still have the same overall cosmology and physical laws, which is often not the case in different SF universes. (For instance, there would've been no sane way to cross Star Trek, which is based on a somewhat accurate understanding of astronomy and the speed of light, with the original Battlestar Galactica, which depicted a fleet somehow traveling between multiple galaxies in a single year while never going faster than lightspeed.)
What did you think of the crossover with Planet of the Apes? I thought the way it was approached worked well enough, and there wasn't a clash of physical laws.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top