• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Trapped in a Past era...

Somebody with more knowledge of biology and medicine could hopefully tell... would we be more susceptible to certain diseases that existed in prior centuries because of having never been exposed to them in modern times?

Kor
 
Somebody with more knowledge of biology and medicine could hopefully tell... would we be more susceptible to certain diseases that existed in prior centuries because of having never been exposed to them in modern times?

Kor
Also, we could be introducing diseases and microbes. What if we accidentally transported a bacteria/fungi that can break down cellulose, millions of years before they were supposed to exist, just as the plants started to colonize land. Boom...a world without coal and oil.
 
Is the only truly ethical move, if one is irrevocably lost in the past, to try and incinerate oneself as quickly as possible?
That’s exactly what happened to a guy from the 27th century when he found himself in 15th century Earth. The smoke from his incineration caused the storms in the 16th century that sank the Spanish Armada, and that is why we don’t all speak Spanish today.

Forget it, kid; it’s time travel.
 
Is the only truly ethical move, if one is irrevocably lost in the past, to try and incinerate oneself as quickly as possible?
I just did a rewatch of Sactuary. At one point Amanda Tapping time-travels to 1888 chasing a villain, and finds that she has no way to go back to the present. Her first impulse is to kill herself for the sake of not changing history. Fortunately her character is immortal on the show, so she decides instead to just sit out the next 114 years in a Tibetan monastery. Then a couple of episodes later she just walks into the office a few days after she left as if nothing happened. :lol:
 
In FC, when it looked like they would be stuck in the past, Picard's orders to his crew were to "stay out of history's way." That might be easier said than done. Considering the butterfly effect, any seemingly innocuous interaction with any people or even the environment could have far-reaching unanticipated consequences. Settle down in a remote place and quietly raise a family, and maybe your descendants end up playing some huge role that had no equivalent in the original timeline. Or, swat a mosquito and it somehow sets off a chain of events leading to the future being a dystopian nightmare where your annoying neighbor rules the world. :shifty:

Kor
 
If I was stuck in the past, all bets would be off about what I would divulge and what skills I would use to improve the situation I was in. My presence there would affect the timeline eventually unless I phasered myself out of existence immediately.
 
There was an episode of The Orville like this. Malloy was inadvertently sent back in time on Earth and after waiting a few years for rescue, proceeded to make a life for himself - working in a related field and marrying and having children. When the crew was finally able to "rescue" him, he didn't want to leave his family and new life.
 
In FC, when it looked like they would be stuck in the past, Picard's orders to his crew were to "stay out of history's way." That might be easier said than done. Considering the butterfly effect, any seemingly innocuous interaction with any people or even the environment could have far-reaching unanticipated consequences. Settle down in a remote place and quietly raise a family, and maybe your descendants end up playing some huge role that had no equivalent in the original timeline. Or, swat a mosquito and it somehow sets off a chain of events leading to the future being a dystopian nightmare where your annoying neighbor rules the world. :shifty:

Kor

Of course, relocating to a non-existing island (Gravett Island) might help considerably in avoiding those undesirable interactions, although perhaps not entirely elimating them.
 
It'd be tough coming from 24th century Star Trek to pre-WWIII Earth. Your instinct would be to be able to trust everyone.
 
Of course, we could be so out of place that we end up like Captain Braxton in the 1990s.

Kor

Just had Toni Braxton's "Unbreak My Heart" playing when I read that - and now I'm picturing her in a Captain's uniform. :)
 
Why? History tells you that the people are primarily out for themselves.

There’s reading history and there’s experiencing it. On 24th century Earth, if you get a message advertising you herbal supplements, you can be pretty certain they’re damn effective supplements.
 
Not necessarily, we know there are 24th century con artists out there.

Not lurking behind every corner on Earth, trying to rob you 200 times a day. Sure, maybe people who lived on DS9 would adjust more easily.

I’m sure there exist conmen on Earth, but in general, if you get a friend request from a hot woman, there is an actual hot woman out there who wants to be your friend.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top