Toughest Crew

[StarryEyed]

If we're talking about a situation where the crews battle all at once, I think the Voyager crew wins. Data and Odo would keep each other occupied in what I think would be a stale-mate. This leaves...

Why does everyone assume this is a one on one only match and not a royal rumble of sorts? As in, Data and/or Odo alone take on more than one person with EASE.

I don't know who would win ultimately, DS9 (the Odo factor) or TNG (the Data factor) but there is no chance any other group can come close.

And the way Worf handles the Jem'Hadar, it's not like Data would be alone.

The OP did not specify the format. If it's one crew against one other crew and one of the crews includes Data or Odo and the other crew does not, the outcome is obvious. I already gave my opinion on the outcome of a Royal Rumble. Boy, would it be a blast!

Worf is definitely a badass but I think Seven, Tuvok or the EMH would destroy him.

 

[Sector 7]

The TOS crew wishes to protest a point of order. Do we HAVE to include a redshirt?

I shall always vote for TOS crew in a fight. Logic be damned, we are talking about the Enterprise, no bloody A, B, C or D! Just remember what we did on K-7! [I feel very proud of myself... I didn't even have to go to Memory Alpha for that one!]

 

[StarryEyed]

The TOS crew wishes to protest a point of order. Do we HAVE to include a redshirt?

I shall always vote for TOS crew in a fight. Logic be damned, we are talking about the Enterprise, no bloody A, B, C or D! Just remember what we did on K-7! [I feel very proud of myself... I didn't even have to go to Memory Alpha for that one!]

Maybe you could include the android Norman from I Mudd who was briefly a member of the crew. That would definitely help level the playing field.

On the other hand, Data or Seven could probably deactivate him with an inverse, resonant tetryon burst.

 

[Sector 7]

The TOS crew wishes to protest a point of order. Do we HAVE to include a redshirt?

I shall always vote for TOS crew in a fight. Logic be damned, we are talking about the Enterprise, no bloody A, B, C or D! Just remember what we did on K-7! [I feel very proud of myself... I didn't even have to go to Memory Alpha for that one!]

Maybe you could include the android Norman from I Mudd who was briefly a member of the crew. That would definitely help level the playing field.

On the other hand, Data or Seven could probably deactivate him with an inverse, resonant tetryon burst.

No fair using technobabble! It didn't exist in the TOS era. That's my story and I'm stickin' to it!

 

[StarryEyed]

The TOS crew wishes to protest a point of order. Do we HAVE to include a redshirt?

I shall always vote for TOS crew in a fight. Logic be damned, we are talking about the Enterprise, no bloody A, B, C or D! Just remember what we did on K-7! [I feel very proud of myself... I didn't even have to go to Memory Alpha for that one!]

Maybe you could include the android Norman from I Mudd who was briefly a member of the crew. That would definitely help level the playing field.

On the other hand, Data or Seven could probably deactivate him with an inverse, resonant tetryon burst.

No fair using technobabble! It didn't exist in the TOS era. That's my story and I'm stickin' to it!

Well that's just another of the disadvantages TOS crew would face. They are hopelessly out of date. They probably wouldn't even recognize some of the more dangerous opponents for what they are. I can just imagine Spock trying to nerve-pinch Data, Sulu karate chopping Odo and Kirk trying to seduce Seven of Nine. Not pretty.

 

[Sector 7]

Leave it to a 'Niner' to ruin all my fun.

 

[kes7]

Well that's just another of the disadvantages TOS crew would face. They are hopelessly out of date. They probably wouldn't even recognize some of the more dangerous opponents for what they are. I can just imagine Spock trying to nerve-pinch Data, Sulu karate chopping Odo and Kirk trying to seduce Seven of Nine. Not pretty.

 

[EnsignRicky]

DS9, seasons four through six.