• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TOS Problem Solving

Kirk's examination of her motivations later on in the episode was astonishing. Did you make Spock forget to put his visor on? Wow. Man screws up. Other men blame the woman in the room.
It was a justified accusation, since Miranda's jealousy of Spock's telepathic abilities / interest in communicating with Kollos, and her possessive behavior regarding Kollos had been established. The plot had nothing to do with some implied attack on her gender. In fact, jealousy is the running issue with Miranda and Larry Marvick in relation to Kollos, for different reasons.
 
It was a justified accusation, since Miranda's jealousy of Spock's telepathic abilities / interest in communicating with Kollos, and her possessive behavior regarding Kollos had been established. The plot had nothing to do with some implied attack on her gender. In fact, jealousy is the running issue with Miranda and Larry Marvick in relation to Kollos, for different reasons.
It was a what now?

Spock being able to mind meld with Kodos more easily was a bit of an insult. She was effectively passed over for promotion for some dude who rocked up at the last minute, so who wouldn't be annoyed? It also knocked her confidence in her abilities. She worked for months and along comes a Mary Sue who does it at the drop of a hat.

I find it insulting in the extreme to suggest there was one iota of truth in Kirk's accusations. I would give him some kudos for using reverse psychology to rile her up and get her to have more faith in herself but when he talks to McCoy, he sounds like he believes his wild accusation that she deliberately tricked Spock. Utterly astonishing. Maybe, just maybe, Spock ain't all that after all, guys.
 
Which category is "beaming all the tribbles onto the Klingon ship" in?

Actually, that one's kind of a crime-solving episode.

Wolf In the Fold is kind of crime-solving too.

Then there are the courtroom episodes. "New evidence saves the day."
 
Which category is "beaming all the tribbles onto the Klingon ship" in?

Actually, that one's kind of a crime-solving episode.

Wolf In the Fold is kind of crime-solving too.

Then there are the courtroom episodes. "New evidence saves the day."
The transporter fixes everything becomes more of a trope later on. They do use it to deactivate weapons, beam evil alien energy and crazy robots into space.

They really need a secure security console in its own little room, shielded from transporters, with its own power source and air recycling, whose job it is to beam intruders into the brig as soon as an alarm sounds. It would make sense for the brig to have its own transporter pad so they could materialise and process intruders one at a time.
 
are there any others where "do nothing and leave while philosophizing" is the ending, like with "let that be your last battlefield"? i can't think of any off the cuff.

though i'll admit that one started with attempts as diplomacy, with the two Cheronians just rejecting all the efforts.
 
It was a what now?
Trek_God_1 isn't wrong. The entire arc for the guest stars was jealousy.

Marvick was jealous over Miranda choosing Kollos over him. It wound up making him take actions that drove him mad and killed him.

Miranda was jealous of Spock being able to mind link with Kollos

MIRANDA: What is it he sees when he looks at you? I must know!

It is compounded by her feelings of inadequacy since Spock was the first choice for the escort job and was chosen to host Kollos because of his familiarity with the Enterprise. Not to mention Kollos itself painfully insisting to her that she step aside and let Spock handle getting them out of WeirdSpace.

So yeah, there was TONS of resentment of Spock there.

I find it insulting in the extreme to suggest there was one iota of truth in Kirk's accusations. I would give him some kudos for using reverse psychology to rile her up and get her to have more faith in herself but when he talks to McCoy, he sounds like he believes his wild accusation that she deliberately tricked Spock. Utterly astonishing.
Because he has every reason to suspect her.

KIRK: The smell of hatred, the stench of jealousy permeates you.

The illustration of this was right there on screen. Her every action in those scenes demonstrated it.

Maybe, just maybe, Spock ain't all that after all, guys.

Well he's the second lead of the series, so he actually is. But I can imagine Kollos - not Spock - was so overcome with sensation that he merely forgot. But Kirk had every right to say it. Not only could be be correct, but his first officer and best friend was now close to dangerous insanity. Clearly, Kirk was upset.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top