I don't remember who did well or not, but these guys I think are hawt. 3. Jensen Ackles 4. Jamie Bamber 9. Jared Padelecki 10. Christian Bale 13. Tahmoh Penikett 24. Cillian Murphy 26. James Marsters 28. Heath Ledger 45. Mathew Fox 50. Skeet Ulrich 53. Matt Damon 54. James McAvoy 55. Tom Welling Others you could add to the list are Milo Ventimiglia (Heroes), Jason London (Alien Cargo, Jason and the Argonauts), Hayden Christensen (some little indie flicks), Ethan Hawke (Gattaca, Explorers), Vin Diesel (Pitch Black, Riddick), Josh Lucas (Stealth, Hulk), Chris Evans (Sunshine, Fantastic 4), Nick Stahl (Terminator 3), Michael Biehn (Aliens, Terminator), Ryan Reynolds (Blade III), Brian Thompson (...Argonauts, X-Files, ENT).
Thought of some others... "Spider Man" Tobey Maguire, "Supermen" Christopher Reeve and Brandon Routh, "Blade" Wesley Snipes, "Punishers" Thomas Jane (Deep Blue Sea) and Dolph Lundgren ("He-Man"), "Angel" David Boreanaz, Underworld's Scott Speedman, Cloverfield's and Poseidon's Mike Vogel, Tristan and Isolde's and Spider Man's James Franco, "Teal'c" Christopher Judge, Blood and Chocolate's Olivier Martinez, and (in the vein of older hunks like Harrison Ford) Kurt Russel, Laurence Fishburne, and TV Guide's sexiest Starfleeter by day X-Man by...other day, Patrick Stewart.