Honestly, its a revolving door for me. There are so many TNG episodes I could choose my top 10 based on the mood I'm in. For this thread, and it will change again when this conversation drops in again, in no order:
Haven
We'll Always Have Paris
The Icarus Factor
Time Squared
The Dauphin
Up The Longer Ladder
Pen Pals
Captain's Holiday
A Matter of Perspective
Devil's Due
I'm sure not many fans have those in their Top anything list but these episodes on my list were based on how I felt. They're character driven stories and from my perspective I thought they were moving stories. Devil's Due was a hoot of an episode; Picard once again has to deal with an adversary who is confident and sure of herself, there were times I had questions he was asking amongst the crew about the current dilemma, and they were all valid and the ending had a nice touch. If you dismissed my listing, I would ask to take a look at them again, probably not in my order. Maybe try one of these episodes along with the ones you really like, just to cleanse the palette, but give them another chance. They're really good episodes IMO.