• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch: 6x13 - "Aquiel"

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
Aquiel.jpg


Apologies for the delay, been a busy couple weeks and, well, the episode wasn't exciting me.



The Enterprise is sent to investigate the loss of communications with a Starfleet subspace radio repeater station, the crew arrives to find the station's computers locked out, the stations two personnel missing and organic residue on a deckplate.

The investigation begins to figure out what happened which begins leading them down a number of paths, the station's shuttle is missing -meaning someone left the station- and review of the station logs finds that there were regular visits by a Klingon commander.

Once recovered, Geordi reviews the logs of one the station's personnel, Aquiel Unari, and learns that things were apparently tense between her and the commander. For now the investigation is assuming that Unari is the one who is deceased. This is until Picard contacts the local commander for the nearby Klingon sector who brings with him a battered Unari, saying he found her inside their borders in the shuttle.

Unari claims she was attacked by the station commander and she fought back in self-defense, blacked-out, and next found herself on the shuttle being picked-up by the Klingons. She relays more of her side of the story and also begins a growing connection with Geordi -who's viewed all of her personal and professional logs.

The harassing Klingon is also soon recovered and he pleas innocence and ignorance to what happened, saying he only arrived on the station after everyone had gone missing.

The investigation over the death of the other communications officer begins to point to Unari, particularly after Worf finds a set-to-kill phaser in the recovered shuttle's glove-box.

Meanwhile, Crusher has been trying to analyze the remains found on the stations but has ran into hurdles due to the damage to the material. She's able to isolate and enhance the remains and begins analyzing them as she does the remains morphs into a blobous pod and touches Crusher's hand, it retracts and then solidifies into a copy of her hand.

It's determined that the being is capable of replicating the organic matter it comes into contact with and maintain the new form for a period of time before having to pick a new one. It's felt the missing officer was a copy, this being, and needed a new form and has either copied Unari or the Klingon commander.

Both are apprehended and put under watch. As Geordi sulks in his quarters and watches over Unari's dog -recovered from the station earlier- the dog turns out to be the being it morphs and tries to absorb Geordi but Geordi manages to destroy it before its attacks can take root. Geordi and Aquiel solidify their bond and life goes on.

-----

Stop me if you heard this one:

During an investigation Geordi has to review the logs of a female whom he crushes on and then sort-of pervs on when meeting her for real, almost to the detriment of his career and person.

Okay, maybe this isn't quite as bad as what happened with Leah Brahms but it's fairly similar. He hears the logs of a female, is surprised when he finally sees her (Brahms in the holodeck recreation, Unari in the video log) and she's attractive (because the 24th century is so filled with un-attractive women) which makes him so much more adamant to put on his blinders (er... sorry) to the point of not potentially seeing the real her.

In Leah's case he fails to see that she's kind of a hard-assed bitch and in Unari's case it's that she's not a model officer and that she may be guilty of killing someone; as at that point the evidence is pointing at her and her excuse is pretty much convenient amnesia.

Now, granted, in both cases he was hardly "wrong" in that almost to Leah's admittance she was being sort-of harsh when she first got on the ship and Unari is not only innocent but Geordi more rightfully gives her the benefit of the presumption of her innocence until proven otherwise. Still, her memory-lapse seems terribly convenient at the time she claims it.

The "governor" for the nearby Klingon sector says -almost matter of factly- that the shuttle Unari was in was nearly destroyed. Ummmm.... There's an alliance between the Klingons and the Federation, should he really have been so quick to destroy an occupied Federation shuttlecraft?

After learning that there may have been a death on the station Worf later reports that a phaser is missing from the station's weapons locker, this is after a couple days have passed. So, checking the weapons locker wasn't one of the first things they did when investigating the station?

Why doesn't the shuttle have a transponder on it or leave some sort of trail through which it can be tracked, if only by other Starfleet vessels? Everyone seems at a loss on how to find or recover the missing shuttle.

It's a nice touch that the subspace repeater station looks almost exactly like the diagram of one in the TNG Technical Manual. The manual and the episode were made a few years apart and while there's some differences the one in the episode shares a lot of design influences from the one in the manual.

When they know the shape-shifting being is the "real killer" they narrow down the number of suspects to only two, Unari and the Klingon. Why/when was the dog dismissed as a possible candidate? Was there any indication the being had to take on a humanoid form?

While 24th century officers and people may not have to worry about things like sexual harassment or attacks between adult officers it seems odd to me to stick two officers of opposing genders on a station alone, almost asking for trouble. Seems there'd need to be one or two other people on the station to make any foul-play less likely and, well, I'd think it'd take more than 2 people to operate the station. There's a lot of space and stations inside the main room, is two people really enough to man the station 24/7? (Or whatever the 24th century/space equivalent would be.)

In the end, I suppose this isn't too terrible of an episode. Unari actually turns out to be a fairly interesting character and her and Geordi do seem to make something of a genuine connection, but it's just odd how much this mimics how he is/was with Leah Brahms.

The episode really doesn't inspire much from beyond a "meh," though. Even the semi-conflict between Riker and Geordi doesn't really do much or go anywhere beyond a brief encounter in a corridor.

Whatever, next week we've got something better to look forward to.
 
Last edited:
During an investigation Geordi has to review the logs of a female whom he crushes on and then sort-of pervs on when meeting her for real, almost to the detriment of his career and person.
It's nice to have character consistency!

Now if there had been a third installment in the series, one where this actually backfires with real negative results, things might have been more interesting. Well, we get a future where LaForge has married somebody named Leah, so that's another sort of conclusion to the "story arc"...

Ummmm.... There's an alliance between the Klingons and the Federation, should he really have been so quick to destroy an occupied Federation shuttlecraft?
According to this episode, the Klingons were still raiding Federation installations seven years prior, when the alliance supposedly was already in place... That's Klingons for you, I guess. At least they don't backstab - it's all up front!

Why doesn't the shuttle have a transponder on it or leave some sort of trail through which it can be tracked, if only by other Starfleet vessels? Everyone seems at a loss on how to find or recover the missing shuttle.
The team isn't exactly CSI: Outer Space, but one could argue this is one issue they didn't fumble: they have already lost shuttles to malice in the earlier seasons, and would know that villains have the means to prevent tracking. Deliberate shutting down of the transponder might be assumed to be the most probable explanation for the shuttle not sending a signal, with total destruction a less likely cause, and transponder malfunction virtually unthinkable.

It's a nice touch that the subspace repeater station looks almost exactly like the diagram of one in the TNG Technical Manual.
...It's a bit more difficult to explain why this installation needs a crew. "It has rooms, beds and staircases" doesn't really suffice, and "it has lots of monitors" doesn't help much, either.

But I guess a "research outpost" would have been a less imaginative McGuffin for isolating the suspects. This at least is something we haven't seen before. Plus the suspects and victims can be regular Joes rather than scientists, allowing for different personality types disassociated with Trek scientist cliches.

Why/when was the dog dismissed as a possible candidate?
Probably right after it became friends with LaForge: you may suspect ugliness and sexiness, but you don't suspect cuteness.

But there is actually a rational reason for dismissing the dog: the theory is that the lifeform replaced Lt Rocha and pretended to be him, then tried to replace Lt Uhnari the same way. Supposedly, the lifeform wants to wander from body to body, with a time limit on how long it can stay in one form. Becoming a Starfleet officer allows it to roam and find new victims. Becoming a dog would be a dead end, even if there's a resupply run arriving in the relatively near future.

Of course, the critter probably became the dog simply because there was no alternative and its time was running out. It didn't even have enough time to arrange for new humanoid victims, now that Aquiel had fled, before it had to become the dog. But the surviving humanoids are by far the likelier cases of what the entity would have chosen to become, had it had that luxury, and our heroes may be thinking in those terms.

One thing about this murder mystery undermines it quite a bit for me: the body. The whole story depends on our heroes first misidentifying the victim, and then uncovering the truth, because of an analysis of the corpse.

But how can there be a corpse in Star Trek? The phaser was set at 10; phasers at 8 already make victims totally disappear. Are we supposed to think that in the cases where a phaser at 8 was used, there actually was a thick puddle left on the floor, even thicker than what we see here? That the floor always was melted a bit, even though here the dent is in what looks like steel and many phaser kills take place atop a carpeted floor?

Either the choice of having a body at all was a writing error, or then the choice of the suspected murder weapon was. But bodies are intuitively acceptable in murder mysteries, while coming up with a complex (and probably all-new) suspected murder weapon would be just annoyingly unrelatable technobabble.

Timo Saloniemi
 
My only question about this episode is why, oh WHY, did Aquiel have to be an alien with a funny forehead appliance. Everything about the way it was written and the way the actress acted said "typical young Earth woman who grew up in a middle class western society." The forehead was needless and distracting. It was a total TNG cliche by this time - guest actor? Put a forehead on them.
 
My only question about this episode is why, oh WHY, did Aquiel have to be an alien with a funny forehead appliance. Everything about the way it was written and the way the actress acted said "typical young Earth woman who grew up in a middle class western society." The forehead was needless and distracting. It was a total TNG cliche by this time - guest actor? Put a forehead on them.

I know what you're saying. My friend said at the time, back then, that the real reason Picard was so respected by all of those alien types was only because his head was so smooth! No bumps to be found there! :lol:
 
Yes, Homo sapiens out of all the Trek humanoids does have the smallest cranium... Might explain why we agree to be the mercenaries of the Federation!

Why not make Aquiel an alien? I dislike the face ridges as a thing, for their timidity - make her horny instead! Or holy or something. But there are already too many humans in Trek anyway.

Timo Saloniemi
 
My only question about this episode is why, oh WHY, did Aquiel have to be an alien with a funny forehead appliance. Everything about the way it was written and the way the actress acted said "typical young Earth woman who grew up in a middle class western society." The forehead was needless and distracting. It was a total TNG cliche by this time - guest actor? Put a forehead on them.

I know what you're saying. My friend said at the time, back then, that the real reason Picard was so respected by all of those alien types was only because his head was so smooth! No bumps to be found there! :lol:

:lol::lol::lol:
 
This one seemed to me to be TNG taking a legitimate stab at noir. In fact, there are a couple of 1940s movies that this reminds me of a lot - man investigates murder of a woman, falls for her, then she turns up after all, and the killer has been lurking around the whole time. It's not bad. (The next one, "Ship in a Bottle," though, is kind of boring and a little confusing to me).

LaForge's lovesick routine gets a little hokey, but it seems that he's a bit too smart and a bit too much of a workaholic.
 
My only question about this episode is why, oh WHY, did Aquiel have to be an alien with a funny forehead appliance. Everything about the way it was written and the way the actress acted said "typical young Earth woman who grew up in a middle class western society." The forehead was needless and distracting. It was a total TNG cliche by this time - guest actor? Put a forehead on them.

I guess so we could have the telepathic connection/ceremony between Geordi and Aquiel, causing the tension since it's presumed she's the one absorbing bodies.
 
This one seemed to me to be TNG taking a legitimate stab at noir. In fact, there are a couple of 1940s movies that this reminds me of a lot - man investigates murder of a woman, falls for her, then she turns up after all, and the killer has been lurking around the whole time. It's not bad. (The next one, "Ship in a Bottle," though, is kind of boring and a little confusing to me).

LaForge's lovesick routine gets a little hokey, but it seems that he's a bit too smart and a bit too much of a workaholic.
This episode has always struck me as TNG doing a riff on the classic noir film "Laura", about a cop investigating a murder, seemingly of a beautiful woman whose portrait hung in her apartment, reading her diary, and falling for her, only for her to show up alive, with some story about how it was her friend who had been killed, by someone who had been after her.

Hmmm. I need to see this movie again. I don't remember how it ends.
 
This one seemed to me to be TNG taking a legitimate stab at noir. In fact, there are a couple of 1940s movies that this reminds me of a lot - man investigates murder of a woman, falls for her, then she turns up after all, and the killer has been lurking around the whole time. It's not bad. (The next one, "Ship in a Bottle," though, is kind of boring and a little confusing to me).

LaForge's lovesick routine gets a little hokey, but it seems that he's a bit too smart and a bit too much of a workaholic.
This episode has always struck me as TNG doing a riff on the classic noir film "Laura", about a cop investigating a murder, seemingly of a beautiful woman whose portrait hung in her apartment, reading her diary, and falling for her, only for her to show up alive, with some story about how it was her friend who had been killed, by someone who had been after her.

Hmmm. I need to see this movie again. I don't remember how it ends.

Yep! One of my favorite classic movies - classy and suspenseful. There are obvious differences between Laura and "Aquiel," but the premise is the same, yes. The titles are even the respective names of the central female characters.

I won't spoil it (there's a neat twist), but the detective figures it all out at the very last minute. Laura was a model, and who was killed was actually a woman who looked like her, so Laura doesn't know who is trying to kill her either - until the end. Very clever movie.

And in "Aquiel," the "killer" is the dog, which I did not see coming! The Klingon is kind of the loose cannon and who you suspect (and I think there is a similar character in Laura who turns out to not be the killer). "Aquiel" is just an easy one to sit back and enjoy, IMO.
 
I enjoyed this episode, it was fun, And I think Geordi was consistent, falling for the girl (did Geordi ever end up with the girl? lol

I actually think, if Geordi had kept in touch with this one, he might have eventually ended up with the girl, personally :)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top