• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TNG Rewatch: 6x06 - "True Q"

Trekker4747

Boldly going...
Premium Member
TrueQ.jpg


The Enterprise is picking up supplies for it's next mission -to go to an industrial planet to help the repair atmospheric conditioners/biospheres. While picking up the supplies they take-on a young woman, Amanda, as an intern. She's a bright and gifted young woman seeking a career in Starfleet in some-sort of science, though she's unsure of which one at this point.

Almost immediately after getting on the ship it seems she's not everything she seems, moments after being shown to her quarters she's able to materialize her litter of pet dogs from Earth and send them back.

As Amanda travels around the ship carrying out her various duties she happens to come across a couple minor problems she quickly is able to dispatch using her -unknown to everyone else- powers, things culminate when she stops and reverses a warp-core breach while in Engineering.

Soon after the Engineering incident Q drops in on the senior staff and announces he's there to take Amanda back to the Continuum as she's the offspring of a Q, though she is unaware of this. Picard and Crusher take to Amanda's defense and insist that Q talk with her first and allow her to make the decision to leave her corporeal life.

Picard's suspicions about Q's interest grows steeper and has Data investigate Amanda's past and the history of her biological parents. Q, meanwhile, seems to be acting under orders from the Continuum's "leader."

Amanda agrees to speak with Q, though makes no promises on the decisions she'll make about her future. Q is insistent that Amanda embrace her omnipotence and tries teaching her how to use it. Crusher, meanwhile, continues with Amanda's more mundane internship.

The investigation by Picard and Data reveals that when Amanda was a toddler her biological parents died in Kansas on Earth when a tornado slipped past the planetary weather controls. When confronted with these findings Q all but admits Amanda's parents were "executed" by the Q since they used their powers during exile. The current fears are that Amanda may be a Q/human hybrid and could pose something of a threat if she's not taught about how to use her powers. If Amanda doesn't agree to return to The Continuum, Q has orders to execute her.

Amanda continues to struggle with balancing her "humanity" with her powers, but soon discovers that her powers cannot truly give her her true desires. She learns this when kidnapping Riker into a romantic fantasy of hers and uses her powers to force Riker to love her.

Ultimately, The Q decide to allow Amanda to live so long as she renounces her powers. She's sure she can do this, but Q cautions that her parents had said the same thing and weren't able to. Hence their execution.

It's at this point the ship is aiding the polluted planet when a severe problems arises on the surface that threatens the away team and the entire planet. Amanda uses her powers to correct the problem with power system and to completely remove the atmospheric pollution around the planet. She then agrees to go with Q back to The Continuum, once she's returned to Earth and spoken with her adoptive parents.

This episode: Meh.

Not a complete snooze but not a lot to really go for here and there's a few just odd things in it. It's more or less indicative of Season 6 as a whole. Largely meh. For me it's also the weakest of the Q episodes.

The young actress who plays Amanda does a good job and love the little flourish she does with her arms/hands when using her powers -as a contrast to Q snapping his fingers. I wonder if the director of the episode came up with it or if the actress did.

I know Q was behind it, but this is the third time I can think of in this series where some is (nearly) injured by something falling in one of the crago bays. (Transfigurations, Ethics,) You'd think there'd be some-kind-of safety system, a tractor-beam that'd detect something falling accidentally, or something in place to prevent accidents like this if they're so "common." I've worked in a grocery store for over 20 years and I think three times is the most I can think of where something has fallen off a high stacked item or tipped off a pallet-lift or something.

I wonder if when Amanda's biological parents died on Earth if there was any real investigation into the apparently very rare -and very strangely behaving- tornado. Seems like it was largely shrugged off by Earth.

And a tornado killing people.... In Kansas? Really, Star Trek? Is that how you want to portray our life here?

The scene/effect of Q turning Crusher into a dog, for me, goes down as one of the more ridiculous moments in the series. It's just very, very odd and out of place.

The scene of Amanda and Q on the outside of the ship, standing on the Engineering deck/engine pylons is, for me, a very beautiful thing.

Corny as it was, I liked Amanda's little "southern belle" romance fantasy with Riker.

All I go. Meh episode. Next week? The meh continues, and we get a dose of pain.
 
In terms of Beverly being turned into a dog, I don't know if that's the most ridiculous moments. The prior Q episode included everyone playing out Robin Hood and also had a reference to Animal House. Aside from the dog thing, it's a totally forgettable episode. Thankfully Q was not wasted in this season as we eventually got the excellent Tapestry.

Try watching this and then Voyager's Q and the Grey, now THAT is ridiculous. True Q - Q having babies is no big deal, nor is killing a Q. Q and the Grey? (and by extension Death Wish, I guess) Q allowing an individual Q to die triggers a civil war, and the act of making a Q baby is such a big deal, it settles the civil war. Sure, whatever. Interesting, that episode also had a dog joke...
 
I thought the dog was perfectly cast and was a high point of the series. That animal actor nailed Crusher.

Absofragginlutely Nailed IT!
 
In terms of Beverly being turned into a dog, I don't know if that's the most ridiculous moments. The prior Q episode included everyone playing out Robin Hood and also had a reference to Animal House. Aside from the dog thing, it's a totally forgettable episode. Thankfully Q was not wasted in this season as we eventually got the excellent Tapestry.

Try watching this and then Voyager's Q and the Grey, now THAT is ridiculous. True Q - Q having babies is no big deal, nor is killing a Q. Q and the Grey? (and by extension Death Wish, I guess) Q allowing an individual Q to die triggers a civil war, and the act of making a Q baby is such a big deal, it settles the civil war. Sure, whatever. Interesting, that episode also had a dog joke...

The stuff Voyager did with The Q is ridiculous. They should have remained a mystery never having going to an "interpretation" of The Continuum. One thing I liked about this episode was the ominous shadow/"leader" that checks in on Q for a report. Added a bit more dimension to the Q and mystery to them without explaining anything. Should have stayed that way, but Voyager -like with the Borg- had to go and try and to explain things and and more and more levels to it.
 
The episode suffers from the "One shot romantic guest star" trope but without the romance. Now I like and respect the idea of having a story focus on characters who are not the series regulars ("Lower Decks" being a fine example), but unlike the officers in Lower Decks who are a part of the Enterprise crew, Amanda's role is a very predictable one. Will she refrain from using her powers and stay, or will she use her powers and leave with the continuum?

It's almost like they could have made this an episode about Crusher, but thought she was better as the butt of the jokes. Hey, at least it's better than being flat out ignored when Star Trek: First Contact happened.

Also, good to see folks still doing these recaps. :) I still don't feel as well as I'd like to, but I'll chime in when I can.
 
I tend to think this is one of the better Q stories after rewatching it a few weeks ago. Feels like there's an actual dramatic reason for Q to be there.
 
When rewatching this episode recently on the S6 BR set, I found most of it less engaging than I did years ago. I always like watching DeLancie as Q and loved the quick, menacing scene of that "shadow Q", but otherwise, because the episode spends so much time away from the main cast, I didn't find it as interesting.
 
This episode usually gets a short shrift when it comes to the Q stories, but after watching it with the rest of Season 6 on blu ray, I've come to really enjoy it. I like Amanda, and the call backs to the first season between Q and Picard were really nice. It's not my favorite Q episode, but it's not the worst either, even though I don't think there is really a bad "Q" episode.
 
I enjoy this episode, but:

The young actress who plays Amanda does a good job and love the little flourish she does with her arms/hands when using her powers -as a contrast to Q snapping his fingers. I wonder if the director of the episode came up with it or if the actress did.

That actually really bugs me, more than it should. It's like some corny saturday morning superhero gimmick, or something...
 
I enjoy this episode, but:

The young actress who plays Amanda does a good job and love the little flourish she does with her arms/hands when using her powers -as a contrast to Q snapping his fingers. I wonder if the director of the episode came up with it or if the actress did.

That actually really bugs me, more than it should. It's like some corny saturday morning superhero gimmick, or something...

Plus her yelling "SHAZAM!" every time was distracting.
 
Her little arm/hand motions reminded me of Tabitha from "Bewitched".

Rewatching the series for the first time, I can see why I started losing interest in season 6. Compelling episodes are few and far between.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top