TNG Hurt/Heal Game - Grand Final

[Natural]

Knock it off with the silly AGT hate.

I don't like it. You can heal it if you want.

 

[RaymondJames]

Well despite Natural killing Genesis I will hold that against you. I will have to say AGT is agreat episode but I will join forces with natural to knock it down yea I just went total Dukat on AGT.

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 13
S2 A Matter of Honor 9
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 21+
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 16
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 11
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 8
S6 Tapestry 12
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9 +
S6 Timescape 11
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 8 -
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 6

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[Rhaenys]

Well despite Natural killing Genesis I will hold that against you. I will have to say AGT is agreat episode but I will join forces with natural to knock it down yea I just went total Dukat on AGT.

It's a great episodes, but you'll knock it? Do you think that AGT is the worst episode left, do you dislike it the most, or you just want to knock it down...?
I'm just interested why... It's a game, everyone can heal and hurt whatever they want.
But I don't think that results are very realistic always, the best and most popular episodes don't always win in this game.

 

[Orac]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 13
S2 A Matter of Honor 10 +
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 21
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 16
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 11
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 6 -
S6 Tapestry 12
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 11
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 8
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 6

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[RaymondJames]

Well despite Natural killing Genesis I will hold that against you. I will have to say AGT is agreat episode but I will join forces with natural to knock it down yea I just went total Dukat on AGT.

It's a great episodes, but you'll knock it? Do you think that AGT is the worst episode left, do you dislike it the most, or you just want to knock it down...?
I'm just interested why... It's a game, everyone can heal and hurt whatever they want.
But I don't think that results are very realistic always, the best and most popular episodes don't always win in this game.

I play using tactics. I like AGT but I don't want it to finish 1st, nor do I want to eliminate it yet.

 

[Natural]

Well despite Natural killing Genesis I will hold that against you. I will have to say AGT is agreat episode but I will join forces with natural to knock it down yea I just went total Dukat on AGT.

The kicker is, I really like Genesis and think it's easily top 25 for entertainment value alone, but it came down to either Genesis or Darmok going first. I feel that Darmok is one of TNG's top 10, so I didn't want it to be the first to go. There are and were far worse episodes in the list. I could have just healed Darmok and went -2 for something shitty like 11001001, but the next voters could have continued the strange Darmok hate and removed it first anyway.

As far as the philosophy of voting goes, I just make it a mix between healing my personal favorites and hurting episodes that I dislike or that I'd like to see strategically removed. I think AGT is better than Timescape for example, but I know that in the end AGT has a reasonable shot at top 5, so hurting it now helps the chances of an episode I might like more.

 

[RaymondJames]

Well despite Natural killing Genesis I will hold that against you. I will have to say AGT is agreat episode but I will join forces with natural to knock it down yea I just went total Dukat on AGT.

The kicker is, I really like Genesis and think it's easily top 25 for entertainment value alone, but it came down to either Genesis or Darmok going first. I feel that Darmok is one of TNG's top 10, so I didn't want it to be the first to go. There are and were far worse episodes in the list. I could have just healed Darmok and went -2 for something shitty like 11001001, but the next voters could have continued the strange Darmok hate and removed it first anyway.

As far as the philosophy of voting goes, I just make it a mix between healing my personal favorites and hurting episodes that I dislike or that I'd like to see strategically removed. I think AGT is better than Timescape for example, but I know that in the end AGT has a reasonable shot at top 5, so hurting it now helps the chances of an episode I might like more.

You vote like me.

 

[Star Treks]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 13
S2 A Matter of Honor 10
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 21
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 16
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9 --
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 6
S6 Tapestry 12
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 11
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 9 +
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 6

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[boognish]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 13
S2 A Matter of Honor 11 +
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 21
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 16
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 6
S6 Tapestry 10 -
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 11
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 9
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 6

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[Rhaenys]

Thanks for replies, Natural, RaymondJones.I was just curious what tactics people use in this game.
I agree with Natural's philosophy of voting too, I do the same.

 

[Captain Ryan]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 13
S2 A Matter of Honor 11
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 21
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 16
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 4 -
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 11
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 9
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 7 +

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis[/quote]

 

[BigFoot]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 13
S2 A Matter of Honor 11
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19 -
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 16
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 17 +
S5 Cause and Effect 4
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 11
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 9
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 7

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 13
S2 A Matter of Honor 9 -
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 16
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 18 +
S5 Cause and Effect 4
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 11
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 9
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 7

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[Skywalker]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 13
S2 A Matter of Honor 9
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 17 +
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 18
S5 Cause and Effect 2 -
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 11
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 9
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 7

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[The Old Mixer]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 14 +
S2 A Matter of Honor 9
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 17
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 18
S5 Cause and Effect 2
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 9 -
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 9
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 7

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[LeadHead]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 14
S2 A Matter of Honor 9
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 17
S3 Sarek 10
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16 -
S5 Cause and Effect 2
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 9
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 10 +
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 7

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[Mallory]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 14
S2 A Matter of Honor 9
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 17
S3 Sarek 8 -
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 3 +
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 9
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 10
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 7

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[Rhaenys]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 14
S2 A Matter of Honor 9
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 17
S3 Sarek 8
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 3
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 9
S6 Timescape 9
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 11 +
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 5 -

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[Ro_Laren]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 14
S2 A Matter of Honor 9
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 18 +
S3 Sarek 8
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 3
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 7 -
S6 Timescape 9
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 11
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 5

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis

 

[RaymondJames]

S2 Q Who 17
S2 The Measure of a Man 14
S2 A Matter of Honor 9
S3 The Best of Both Worlds, Part I 19
S3 Yesterday's Enterprise 18
S3 Sarek 8
S3 The Defector 15
S3 The Offspring 11
S4 The Drumhead 9
S4 The Wounded 16
S5 The Inner Light 16
S5 Cause and Effect 3
S6 Tapestry 10
S6 Chain of Command, Part II 6
S6 Relics 8 +
S6 Timescape 9
S6 Chain of Command, Part I 6
S7 All Good Things 9 -
S7 Parallels 6
S7 The Pegasus 5

Eliminated:
23rd: S5 I, Borg
24th: S1 Conspiracy
25th: S2 Contagion
26th: S7 Lower Decks
25th: S4 Reunion
26th: S2 Peak Performance
27th: S4 Brothers
28th: S5 Conundrum
29th: S1 The Arsenal of Freedom
30th: S1 Where No One Has Gone Before
31st: S4 Clues
32nd: S1 The Big Goodbye
33rd: S1 11001001
34th: S5 Darmok
35th: S7 Genesis