OK, maybe it's the wine talking, but I've been thinking about Discovery and its place in canon history. It's a ship that travels on "life force" across the galaxy in the wink of an eye. We have black alerts, black fleets, black Starfleet shields, and a war that killed 8000 in the first week.
My theory: Discovery is a ship of the "living dead" stuck in Pergatory: those phasing between life and death -- biology and physics, the same at the quantum level -- Schrodinger's cat, so to speak. Lorca is the one who judges who goes back, and who goes "south". Burnham and the crew of the Shenzhou perished in the initial battle. Her mutiny is not on record because all hands went down right afterward in the ensuing Klingon attack. Those prisoners on the shuttle were on their way to the bottom floor when the Discovery intervened. The Glenn and her crew passed through the gates of Hell.
Trying to find a way to win a war between those living and those dead (cue the themes to the Walking Dead, Game of Thrones, Harry Potter, etc...). Coincidental casting of Sonequa Martin-Green and Jason Isaacs!
This also explains why Lorca has a room filled with skeletons and dead tribbles....
Well? At least it gets around these damn canon arguments! Discuss!
My theory: Discovery is a ship of the "living dead" stuck in Pergatory: those phasing between life and death -- biology and physics, the same at the quantum level -- Schrodinger's cat, so to speak. Lorca is the one who judges who goes back, and who goes "south". Burnham and the crew of the Shenzhou perished in the initial battle. Her mutiny is not on record because all hands went down right afterward in the ensuing Klingon attack. Those prisoners on the shuttle were on their way to the bottom floor when the Discovery intervened. The Glenn and her crew passed through the gates of Hell.
Trying to find a way to win a war between those living and those dead (cue the themes to the Walking Dead, Game of Thrones, Harry Potter, etc...). Coincidental casting of Sonequa Martin-Green and Jason Isaacs!
This also explains why Lorca has a room filled with skeletons and dead tribbles....
Well? At least it gets around these damn canon arguments! Discuss!
Last edited: