• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The very best TOS episode

evangelist6589

Lieutenant Commander
Red Shirt
City on the Edge Forever?
Whom gods destroy?
or what?

Season 1 had many, many winners. In fact I think the only dumb episode of the season was "Lazarus." Season 3 also had a number of good ones, but a few bombs. Season 2 in my POV had a mix of good and bad ones. But it still was good trek with the great music.
 
Picking a very best episode out of all TOS would be difficult, but my favorite comedy episode is "A Piece of the Action." It has a serious subject, yet is handled with humor and lots of color.

I know "City on the Edge of Forever" is The Best™ to many fans, but the paradox flaw undermines all the drama for me. Again, it would be hard to pick a best out of so many great stories, but I've always had a fondness for "The Corbomite Maneuver." It is introspective, has action without going so far as car chases and explosions, and in many ways set the example for other episodes to come.
 
Doomsday Machine of course
Yep. To me The DM is the perfect ep. It's got everything and in exactly the right proportions.

I thought Shatner was awesome in this ep. Right at the end, when he's looking at the DM and doing his beam-me-aboards, just before he's beamed out, he has a look on his face that says to me: I pushed my luck too far this time. I am fucked. He didn't, and he wasn't, but that look says it to me. Just great.


Good episodes. None from season 3? Season 3 had many good episodes in my POV.

I've come to really like Wink of an Eye. I won't say it's number 1, but for me it's a top 5. It has more science silliness in it than most, but I don't care.
 
"A Taste of Armageddon"
I don't know about best but this one has always been my favorite. It's just such a cool sci fi concept and you can totally see why the aliens would want to behave as they did. Plus it has a great social message about trying to ignore or hide from the cost of war.
 
"Operation -- Annihilate!"

Nicholas Meyer is so fond of talking about how "Art thrives on restriction," which is not entirely baseless (sometimes, though, you really need good resources to bring the best to the screen). The location shoot looks really great. Even 50 years later, it's interesting and visually striking and, I suppose, the facility was "paid" with free publicity, at the time. So, there's $aving$, there, that work for this episode. The alien creatures are absolutely brilliant. They're like a buck-and-a-half's worth of plastic, but it's brilliant, how effective they - still - are at getting the story told. And what they're meant to represent is an over-the-top concept that I think really works, here.

The threat is dealt with locally, even globally and the stakes are Galactic! This is a very densely layered episode with so much on offer that anyone, at all, is going to like it. I mean, even on Down-to-Earth terms, Captain Kirk's family is relevant to the story. And we even get to learn a thing or two about Mister Spock. For 1960's television, this episode is surprisingly thoughtful and intelligently written. Whilst not, exactly, my most favourite TOS offering, it's certainly one of them and I qualify it as one of the best, overall.
 
I don't know about best but this one has always been my favorite. It's just such a cool sci fi concept and you can totally see why the aliens would want to behave as they did. Plus it has a great social message about trying to ignore or hide from the cost of war.
which one?? Do you mean A Taste of Armageddon?
 
For me:
"The Corbomite Maneuver"
^^^
IMO - it really encapsulates what I enjoy about Star Trek from the various character personalities, the fact they're in a dangerous First Contact situation where both sides are testing the other, and the reason Kirk is the Captain is displayed for all to see (as well as the fact he needs two of his friends and senior officers help in getting out of the situation.) They're not perfect, but when their lives are on the line they work it out together to survive the situation.

50 years after it was made I still feel it's the best overall episode of the Star Trek Franchise - and really holds up. (YMMV of course.) ;)
 
Last edited:
For me:
"The Corbomite Maneuver"
^^^
IMO - it really encapsulates what I enjoy about Star Trek from the various character personalities, the fact they're in a dangerous First Contact situation where both sides are testing the other, and the reason Kirk is the Captain is displayed for all to see (as well as the fact he needs to of his friends and senior officers to help in getting out of the situation. They're not perfect, but when their lives are on the line to work it out together to survive the situation.

50 years after it was made I still feel it's the best overall episode of the Star Trek Franchise - and really holds up. (YMMV of course.) ;)
My mileage is the same.
 
"This Side of Paradise"
A really lovely episode. Tied with "Amok Time". You might argue that there are better episodes, but they were the best for me.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top