The Tubeys

[Temis the Vorta]

Vote Early And Often!

Skipping all reality TV categories...

Best New Show: Caprica (wow, what an appalling list!)
Worst New Show: SG:U
Best Returning Show: Lost, RIP
Worst Returning Show: Heroes, also RIP (drive a stake thru its heart just to be on the safe side )
Most Overrated Show: Mad Men
Most Underrated Show: Caprica
Most Painful Cancellation: n/a (good job there, Hollywood!)
Most Disappointing: 24
Most Wasted Potential: V (really, it's a three-way tie with FlashForward and Happy Town)
Best Sidekick: Vincent, Lost
Best Villain: Trinity, Dexter
Least Villanous Villain: Dexter Morgan, Dexter
Least Favorite Actor: Brandon Routh, Chuck
Least Favorite Actress: Eliza Dushku, Dollhouse
Best Romantic Relationship: Sawyer and Juliet, Lost
Worst Romantic Relationship: Chuck and Hannah, Chuck
Best Almost-Romantic-But-Not-Quite Relationship: Sterling Archer and Lana Kane, Archer
Best Fictional Location: The Island, Lost (next year it'll be New Cap City)
Most Anticipated New Show of 2010-2011 Season: Terra Nova

There seem to be a few missing categories, but those will be along shortly I assume...

 

[Jetfire]

I voted but I can't remember them all.

 

[auntiehill]

Best New Show: Justified.
Worst New Show: Jersey Shore
Best Returning Show: LOST
Worst Returning Show: American Idol
Most Overrated Show: American Idol
Most Underrated Show: Doctor Who
Most Painful Cancellation: Law & Order, only because nothing else even registered on my radar
Most Disappointing: Heroes
Most Wasted Potential: V
Best Sidekick: Ben Linus, LOST
Best Villain: Man in Black, LOST
Least Villanous Villain: Dexter Morgan, Dexter
Least Favorite Actor: David Carouso, CSI: Miami
Least Favorite Actress: Eliza Dushku, Dollhouse
Best Romantic Relationship: Desmond and Penny, LOST
Worst Romantic Relationship: Sarah and Shaw, Chuck
Best Almost-Romantic-But-Not-Quite Relationship: Michael and Fiona, Burn Notice
Best Fictional Location: The Island, Lost
Most Anticipated New Show of 2010-2011 Season: I really don't anticipate any of the new shows, so I just voted for one I've seen that looked good: Rubicon.

 

[Temis the Vorta]

New categories!

Best Drama: Dexter (it's a toss up between that and Lost)
Best Comedy: Party Down (seriously, if you're not watching - start!)
Most Improved Show: n/a
Least Improved: Heroes
Most Egregious Product Placement: Chuck - Subway
Favorite Character: No Dexter Morgan? Okay fine, Sawyer from Lost
Least Favorite Character: Amanda Graystone, Caprica, in a squeaker over Tyler Evans from V
Character Most in Need of Getting Killed Off: Ah, here's Tyler's category...
Best Badass: Again, no Dexter Morgan? Who did these frakked up nominations? All right, then, Gemma Teller Morrow, Sons of Anarchy
Best Cast: Lost
Favorite Actor: No Michael C. Hall? It's a scandal!!! Okay, Zachary Levi, Chuck
Favorite Actress: Alessandra Torresani, Caprica
Best Performance by an Inanimate Object: John Deere lawnmower, Mad Men Okay, seriously: Serge, Caprica
Best Guest Star: I would have gone for Steven Weber or Ed Begley Jr for Party Down, but Titus Welliver, Lost gets my vote
Most Overhyped Big Name Guest Appearance: Brandon Routh, Chuck
Best Season Finale: Lost, I don't care what the haters say! (Once again: WHERE IS DEXTER!!!)
Worst Season Finale: No Heroes? No V? Okay then, FlashForward by default.
Best Musical Moment: Jeffster! performs "Fortunate Son" as the Buy More employees rock out in protest, Chuck
Best HoYay Couple: Waitaminute...Miles Straume and Richard Alpert? That got a nomination and not Jack & Sawyer???... My vote goes to Mark and Demetri, FlashForward
Best Non-Romantic Relationship: Sawyer and Miles, Lost
Worst Crime Against Fashion: I refuse to vote, because Alison Janney's Earth Mother Potato Sack Dress and Seashell Hairdo wasn't even nominated.

These have got to be the suckiest nominations The Tubeys have ever done. Next week's better be a big improvement!

 

[Jetfire]

Best Drama: The Vampire Diaries
Best Comedy: The Middle
Most Improved: Smallville (way better than the Failsday stuff)
Least Improved: One Tree Hill (It has fallen way off from a few years ago)
Guiltiest TV Pleasure: The Vampire Diaries
Most Egregious Product Placement: The CW Network-Bing
Most Appalling Reality Show Star: RW Guy...don't care.
Best Late Night Talk Show: Coco
Favorite Character: Clark Kent-Smallville
Least Favorite Character: Tyler Evans-V
Character Most in Need of Getting Killed Off: Tyler Evans-V
Best Badass: Damon Salvatore-TVD
Best Cast: The Vampire Diaries
Favorite Actor: Matthew Fox-LOST
Favorite Actress: Elizabeth Mitchell-LOST/V
Best Performance by an Inanimate Object: Ajira Plane-LOST
Best Guest Star: Mia Kirshner-The Vampire Diaries
Most Overhyped Big Name Guest Appearance: Paris Hilton-SUPERNATURAL
Best Season Finale: LOST
Worst Season Finale: LOST
Best Musical Moment (Scripted or Reality): The Vampire Diaries - Damon and Elena dance to Within Temptation's "All I Need"
Best HoYay! Couple: Miles Straume and Richard Alpert - Lost
Best Non-Romantic Relationship: Hurley and everyone - Lost
Worst Crime Against Fashion: Clark's black Blur suit - Smallville

 

[Temis the Vorta]

Final round's up!

Best Episode - Drama - Lost - "Ab Aeterno"
Best Episode - Comedy - Archer - "Honeypot"
Worst Episode - Drama - FlashForward - "Playing Cards with Coyote"
Worst Episode - Comedy - n/a, haven't seen any of the nominees (good for me )
Worst Payoff - Lost - turning the light on and off
Most Unwelcome New Character - Daniel Shaw - Chuck
Most Welcome New Character - none of the above!
Most Wrongly Underused Character - Daniel Faraday - Lost
Most Redemptive Character in a Sucky Show - Demetri Noh - FlashForward
Supporting Actor/Actress Most Deserving of a Starring Role on TV - Josh Holloway - Lost
Best Death Scene -

Spoiler: Lost

Jack Shephard - Lost

Most Ludicrous Plotline - 24 - Dana Walsh's entire story arc
Best Line of Dialogue - "I'm a philanthropist." - Charlie Kelley, It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia (You had to be there.)
Worst Retcon -

Spoiler: 24

24 - Dana Walsh was actually a mole for the Russians

Neverending Subplot Most in Need of Resolution - Chuck - Chuck is/isn't/wants to be/doesn't want to be/should be/shouldn't be a spy
Best "Hell Yeah" Moment -

Spoiler: Lost

Lost - Juliet and Sawyer find each other in the afterlife

Best WTF Moment -

Spoiler: Lost

Lost - The flash sideways takes place after they are all dead

Worst WTF Moment - South Park - Comedy Central butchers then refuses to re-air 201
Best Pop Culture Reference - Mythbusters - tests the Gorn Cannon from the original Star Trek episode "Arena".
Best Unexpected Plot Twist (best for the show anyway...) -

Spoiler: Dexter

Dexter - Trinity killed Rita

Best Family Relationship - Deb and Dexter - Dexter

 

[Hermiod]

I'll try to vote, even though I don't watch nearly as much TV as I used to.

Best Single Episode (Drama) - Lost: "Dr. Linus".
Best and Worst Single Episode (Comedy) - Not a single thing I've seen on the list.
Worst Single Episode (Drama) - Smallville: "Persuasion" though "Roulette", "Crossfire", "Warrior" and the utterly atrocious "Escape" were far worse.

Worst Payoff -

Spoiler: Smallville

The Red Queen is Martha Kent

Most Unwelcome New Character: Stargate Universe: Colonel Young
Most Welcome New Character: Doctor Who: Amy Pond
Most Wrongly Underused Character: Lost: Miles Straume
Most Redemptive Character in a Sucky Show: Smallville: Chloe Sullivan
Supporting Actor/Actress Most Deserving of a Starring Role on TV - Enver Gjokaj
Best Death Scene:

Spoiler: Lost

Sun & Jin

Most Ludicrous Plotline: Smallville: Oliver's Man Pain
Best Line of Dialogue: "Hello. I'm The Doctor. Basically... run!" The Doctor, Doctor Who
Worst WTF Moment:

Spoiler: Smallville

Clark Kent heat visions the Rao Twin Towers and watches as they burn and crumble

Best Pop Culture Reference: Mythbusters - tests the Gorn Cannon from the original Star Trek episode "Arena".
Best Unexpected Plot Twist:

Spoiler: Lost

Sawyer and Miles are cops in the sideways universe - I suppose, there were better ones this year.