The lead Robbie Amell lands up in between a husband and wife in the first episode, and he's now in between boyfriend John and and girlfriend Cara. Emma, Jacob and Paul on The Following were villains. I doubt that Tomorrow People will be tomorrowish enough to follow up. The guy playing John has the most life so far.
Mark Pellegrino as Uncle Jedekiah is eeeeeeevil, but does that thankless role pretty well.