• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

THE ORVILLE S2, E9: "IDENTITY, PART II"

It was not as great as Part I, mainly because it's hard to top that unexpected "kicking over the table " Still, it was pretty satisfying.
 
As far as second-parts of 2-part episodes go, that one stuck the landing pretty good. Lots to like in that one, some surprises, some non-surprises as well. Interesting to see the development with the Krill (and I wonder if next week will focus on the enemy they have and getting Union help.)

I thought the battle scenes were a little too cluttered and messy and there's not enough variety in the look of the Union (or Krill... or Kaylon) ships to really make much out but the battle was largely "secondary" to the narrative that was happening.

I also thought Yaphit had sacrificed himself.

And, hey, no "Reset Button!" (Beyond, thin excuses to allow Isaac to stay on the Orville.)

One question: Why are the [Jefferies Tubes] there if the entry points to them are too small for anyone to fit?

I guess they "could" be the climate/ventilation system, but some behind-the-scenes info on the show suggested the "atmosphere" in the ship was actually generated by oxygen-generating organisms built into walls and bulkheads and not by any central generation and dispersal system and the sides of the shaft looked to "complicated" and covered with greebles to just be the system of vents for any atmospheric or climate control distribution. So they must be work spaces... But with tiny slotted access doors?

In the end, though, very good episode. Look forward to where it goes from here.
 
Well, that was about as enjoyable an hour of sci-fi as you'd get anywhere

BTW, it's pretty cool that I never expected Yaphit to have such a sweet kill maneuver
 
Some of the folks working on the show are clearly big space opera fans - the show embraces the genre in a much bigger way than Trek does, maybe because they don't assay to be taken nearly so seriously.

What's marvelous is that they do know what their show is and where they're going - they don't just grab genre material at random.
 
Anybody else catch the ST5 call-back? (And, oh yeah, that battle was epic.) Think the Krill will continue to play nice now that they know that there's enemies out there that really don't have souls?
 
One question: Why are the [Jefferies Tubes] there if the entry points to them are too small for anyone to fit?
They probably have drones that go in and repair things.

My question is that if Issac has those built in weapons from the start, why didn’t he use them on the planet he and the Doctor were stranded on?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top