• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

THE ORVILLE S1, E11 "NEW DIMENSIONS"

Rate the episode:

  • ***** Excellent

    Votes: 23 43.4%
  • ****

    Votes: 20 37.7%
  • ***

    Votes: 7 13.2%
  • **

    Votes: 3 5.7%
  • * Fear the banana

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    53
...Star Trek-pretender...

I don't think it is a pretender. I just think the writing staff chose to emphasize the wrong things from Star Trek's past. I think the show would've been better served as an ensemble that didn't rely so heavily on things from Trek's past right off the bat.

Featuring the Klingons first thing, and having Sarek and Mudd and constant name drops and winknod background props make the show feel very derivative with no identity of its own.
 
Just asking, but can we have Orville threads about "The Orville" instead of about how sucky Discovery is with a few scattered defenders?
Chill, bro. When the episode airs we'll discuss the hell out of. Until then we'll shoot the shit however we like, and if that means a few criticisms of Discovery, well, there we are.
 
Just asking, but can we have Orville threads about "The Orville" instead of about how sucky Discovery is with a few scattered defenders?

It gets brought up for reasons that are more than obvious. People have opinions. My opinions of both shows are the same here or in the Discovery forum.
 
I thought previous ep was fall finale, how many more eps for half season?

I've been back and forth on Orville vs Discovery when what I really want is a show with the fun of Orville but the ability to have gravity in high stakes arcs and original take on established mythology like Discovery. Really my favorite at the time tends to be one where most recent ep was best.
 
I thought previous ep was fall finale, how many more eps for half season?

I've been back and forth on Orville vs Discovery when what I really want is a show with the fun of Orville but the ability to have gravity in high stakes arcs and original take on established mythology like Discovery. Really my favorite at the time tends to be one where most recent ep was best.

Next week is the season 1 finale for Orville. There is no fall finale. It’s just a 12 episode season.
 
Hey, on this show when they talk trchnobabble something cool happens.
 
Okay, this was excellent. I mean, wow. I loved all of the "2D Space" stuff and seeing Lamar's character grow (I guess this was "his episode" like almost everyone else previously got.) The 2D space stuff was cool liked things like the "bigger on the inside" thing with the 3D space inside the 2D shuttle and all of that wild, trippy, way of thinking is the kind of sci-fi I love.

It reminds me of an old "Cosmos" segment with Carl Sagan talking about 2D space.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Just all neat and wild. I'd have liked to seen a bit where Yaphit admits Lamar was a better fit for the job or something along those lines since Lamar stood up for Yaphit.

Very good. Wow.
 
That was nice overall. There isn't much I disliked about the episode - which is great after three episodes with notable flaws in execution. On the other hand, there wasn't really much truly gripping about the episode either.

The supposed "A plot" of the show - the anomaly/gateway into the two-dimensional universe - was pretty boring. It basically existed for one reason and one reason alone however, which was to provide some actual character development into LeMarr. Up until this point he just seemed to be Malloy's sidekick, except in Majority Rule, where he was an idiot. Here it is established that this was all an act, and he's actually very intelligent. More importantly, despite his own lack of confidence in his leadership skills, he actually has "the right stuff."

The "B plot" was once again revolving around Mercer/Grayson - and similar to the A plot, the focus was on lack of confidence - in this case Mercer doubting himself when he finds out Grayson put in a good word for him. I like that the crew of the Orville isn't so sure of itself, but given Kitan has also had two episodes centering around her command insecurities, I really hope the writers stop going back to the well here.

In the end, I think my feelings on this episode hinge on how much The Orville makes sure to not press the "reset button" at the end of each episode. This could mark the transition into a new season, with a more confident crew more assured in their roles, and something like a character arc starting for LaMarr. On the other hand, if the conclusion of this episode has no consequences on the next episode, it will be very disappointing.

I am concerned already that the trailer for next week showed LaMarr back on the bridge in his old seat. Maybe they produced these episodes out of order, and we won't have this issue going forward.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top