The MOST Disliked Episode of ENTERPRISE - Season Three...

[Yanks]

I'll save Proving Ground

The Andorian Mining Consortium runs from noone

THE XINDI
ANOMALY
EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE
NORTH STAR
CARPENTER STREET
CHOSEN REALM
DOCTOR'S ORDERS

 

[Discofan]

I know many people hate this episode but I am saving CARPENTER STREET. I loved how the bad guy tells the police everything that's happened and they treat him like he's crazy or loaded-up on drugs.

THE XINDI
ANOMALY
EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE
NORTH STAR
CHOSEN REALM
DOCTOR'S ORDERS

 

[MakeshiftPython]

Saving "Chosen Realm" just for this exchange alone:

ARCHER: These people you're fighting. What makes them heretics?
YARRICK: We believe the Makers created the Chosen Realm in nine days. They believe it took ten.

On the nose? Sure, but it made me chuckle.

THE XINDI
ANOMALY
EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE
NORTH STAR
DOCTOR'S ORDERS

 

[Discofan]

I am reposting the list as it should be after the last elimination.

THE XINDI
ANOMALY
EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE
NORTH STAR
DOCTOR'S ORDERS

 

[Farscape One]

I am putting "ANOMALY" off the list. We see the effects of being in the Expanse to ships and people. And I remembered the interrogated guy as Lt. Warren Keffer from season 2 of BABYLON 5.

THE XINDI
EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE
NORTH STAR
DOCTOR'S ORDERS

 

[Garth Rockett]

I'll save The Xindi. It was a solid start to what ended up being a very enjoyable season.

EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE
NORTH STAR
DOCTOR'S ORDERS

 

[MakeshiftPython]

And so we have the remaining weak links. "Doctor's Orders" is pretty okay, but clearly a rip-off of the Voyager episode "One".

 

[Discofan]

I am assuming that you removed Doctor's Orders from the list.
And now I am saving NORTH STAR. A little cowboy action once in a great while doesn't hurt...

EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE

 

[tomswift2002]

“North Star”. WeaK story, but I liked the sepia tone look that the episode had.

EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE
DOCTOR'S ORDERS

 

[Discofan]

I am reposting the list... again!

EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE

 

[iliescu]

Season 2 is a big avoid one when giving thought of Enterprise. The Xindi arc is the most interesting here.

 

[BigDaveX]

Whether or not they actually wanted to, MakeshiftPython wasn't eligible to remove "Doctor's Orders" from the list, as it was less than six hours since they last posted. The list therefore remains as:

EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE
DOCTOR'S ORDERS

 

[Sakonna]

I know many people hate this episode but I am saving CARPENTER STREET. I loved how the bad guy tells the police everything that's happened and they treat him like he's crazy or loaded-up on drugs.

Ha! I haven't even seen most of season three, but I recently saw this episode (along with some others from season 4), and I really liked it, it's one of the things that inspired me to go back and actually watch Enterprise from the beginning (first time I mostly stopped mid-season-two and never really returned)

A lot of my enjoyment was seeing how this LA-set show created their version of then-contemporary Detroit. If you can ignore the fairly significant issue of no black people and the fact that the last shot for some reason goes to a wide angle of the lush green hills of California, they did a pretty good job of it!

 

[iliescu]

RAJIN is hard inclusion with where the intelligent rest of the Xindi Arc which is Season 3 am finding.

 

[BlueStuff]

Well, I'll save Doctor's Orders because it was entertaining enough, even if the twist was easy to see coming and didn't make much sense (how could Phlox forget that he'd put T'Pol in a coma?).

Also this was the first episode of Enterprise I ever saw while flicking through stations, so it has some nostalgic value.

EXTINCTION
RAJIIN
EXILE

 

[Discofan]

RAJIN is hard inclusion with where the intelligent rest of the Xindi Arc which is Season 3 am finding.

If you save an episode, you need to remove it from the list and repost the list, otherwise, it doesn't work.

 

[BlueStuff]

If you save an episode, you need to remove it from the list and repost the list, otherwise, it doesn't work.

I couldn't tell if they were saving it or just commenting on it in general.

 

[Discofan]

Well, I'll save Doctor's Orders because it was entertaining enough, even if the twist was easy to see coming and didn't make much sense (how could Phlox forget that he'd put T'Pol in a coma?)...

Unless it's a trait of Denobulan psychology that they can forget things on purpose to keep themselves from going crazy. I think Phlox said something to that effect at some point, although I don't remember to whom he was talking.

 

[iliescu]

To stay on topic...

RAJIN is the worst Season 3 episode that is in notice.

 

[BigDaveX]

I'll send Exile out of the list. It's dull, but out of the three that remain it's still the best, and a little more relevant to the story arc.

EXTINCTION
RAJIIN