I really liked this write-up the Hollywood Reporter did a few years ago, the 100 greatest episodes from the first 6 series (this was pre-Discovery).
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/l...5/item/andorian-incident-star-trek-100-926327
And it occurred to me that simply playing the full list would make a great elimination game. The selection of episodes communicates such an interesting point of view on the franchise, it really gives the first 6 series their due. It includes all the recognized greats, but also many less obvious highlights drawn from more obscure installments.
(episodes are listed exactly as they were by THR, so there's some peculiarities, like the 6-episodes of the Occupation Arc being one item, "Improbable Cause" being listed as it's own item though every other-two parter lists both parts, etc)
THE RULES. The basic idea is your standard elimination game. Below are the 100 "greatest" episodes, according to THR. Eliminate your FAVORITE or the one you deem the 'BEST.' Please provide an EXPLANATION for why you are eliminating your choice and be sure to copy and paste the list with your choice removed.
Leave at least 2 eliminations by other posters before you eliminate another episode.
No tactical voting! You cannot remove an episode just because you feel it would threaten your preferred episode's chance to win.
Enjoy!





1. “City On The Edge Of Forever”, TOS Season 1
2. “The Best Of Both Worlds, Parts I & II”, TNG Seasons 3 & 4
3. “Balance Of Terror”, TOS Season 1
4. “The Inner Light”, TNG Season 5
5. “Space Seed”, TOS Season 1
6. “Yesterday’s Enterprise”, TNG Season 3
7. “In The Pale Moonlight”, DS9 Season 6
8. “Mirror, Mirro”, TOS Season 2
9. “Far Beyond The Stars”, DS9 Season 6
10. “Family”, TNG Season 4
11. “Let That Be Your Last Battlefield”, TOS Season 3
12. “A Piece Of The Action”, TOS Season 2
13. “The Visitor”, DS9 Season 4
14. “Tapestry”, TNG Season 6
15. “The Trouble With Tribbles”, TOS Season 2
16. “Q Who”, TNG Season 2
17. “Arena”, TOS Season 1
18. “Chain Of Command, Parts I & II”, TNG Season 6
19. “Emissary”, DS9 Season 1
20. “All Good Things…”, TNG Season 7
21. “Ship In A Bottle”, TNG Season 6
22. “Homefront/Paradise Lost”, DS9 Season 4
23. “Where No Man Has Gone Before”, TOS Season 1
24. “The Naked Time”, TOS Season 1
25. “Year Of Hell, Parts I & II”, VOY Season 4
26. “Elementary, Dear Data”, TNG Season 2
27. “The Devil In The Dark”, TOS Season 1
28. “Amok Time”, TOS Season 2
29. “Call To Arms”, DS9 Season 5
30. “Equinox, Parts I & II”, VOY Seasons 5 & 6
31. “Measure Of A Man”, TNG Season 2
32. “The Menagerie, Parts I & II”, TOS Season 1
33. “The Enterprise Incident”, TOS Season 3
34. “Living Witness”, VOY Season 4
35. “Duet”, DS9 Season 1
36. “Redemption I & II”, TNG Seasons 4 & 5
37. “Scorpion, Parts I & II”, VOY Seasons 3 & 4
38. “A Time To Stand”/”Rocks & Shoals”/”Sons & Daughters”/”Behind The Lines”/”Favor The Bold”/”Sacrifice Of Angels”, DS9 Season 6
39. “All Our Yesterdays”, TOS Season 3
40. “What You Leave Behind”, DS9 Season 7
41. “I, Borg”, TNG Season 5
42. “Journey To Babel”, TOS Season 2
43. “Parallels”, TNG Season 7
44. “Soldiers Of The Empire”, DS9 Season 5
45. “The Corbomite Maneuver”, TOS Season 1
46. “The Drumhead”, TNG Season 4
47. “Past Tense, Parts I & II”, DS9 Season 3
48. “The Doomsday Machine”, TOS Season 2
49. “Inquisition”, DS9 Season 6
50. “Lower Decks”, TNG Season 7
51. “Once More Unto The Breach”, DS9 Season 7
52. “Blink Of An Eye”, VOY Season 6
53. “A Taste Of Armageddon”, TOS Season 1
54. “Endgame”, VOY Season 7
55. “Tinker Tenor Doctor Spy”, VOY Season 6
56. “It’s Only A Paper Moon”, DS9 Season 7
57. “The Siege Of AR-558”, DS9 Season 7
58. “Hope And Fear”, VOY Season 4
59. “Yesteryear”, TAS Season 1
60. “Future’s End, Parts I & II”, VOY Season 3
61. “Take Me Out To The Holosuite”, DS9 Season 7
62. “Relics”, TNG Season 6
63. “Timeless”, VOY Season 5
64. “Worst Case Scenario”, VOY Season 3
65. “Trials And Tribble-ations”, DS9 Season 5
66. “Little Green Men”, DS9 Season 4
67. “The Galileo Seven”, TOS Season 1
68. “Frame Of Mind”, TNG Season 6
69. “Necessary Evil”, DS9 Season 2
70. “Cause And Effect”, TNG Season 5
71. “Improbable Cause”, DS9 Season 3
72. “Deadlock”, VOY Season 2
73. “The Pegasus”, TNG Season 7
74. “The Infinite Vulcan”, TAS Season 1
75. “The Tholian Web”, TOS Season 3
76. “Brothers”, TNG Season 4
77. “Damage”, ENT Season 3
78. “Crossover”, DS9 Season 2
79. “The Offspring”, TNG Season 3
80. “Broken Bow”, ENT Season 1
81. “Mortal Coil”, VOY Season 4
82. “Shore Leave”, TOS Season 1
83. “Phantasms”, TNG Season 7
84. “Caretaker”, VOY Season 1
85. “Similitude”, ENT Season 3
86. “Flashback”, VOY Season 3
87. “Our Man Bashir”, DS9 Season 4
88. “In A Mirror, Darkly, Parts I & II”, ENT Season 4
89. “Skin Of Evil”, TNG Season 1
90. “Spectre Of The Gun”, TOS Season 3
91. “The Lorelei Signal”, TAS Season 1
92. “E2”, ENT Season 3
93. “His Way”, DS9 Season 6
94. “Demons”/”Terra Prime”, ENT Season 4
95. “Home”, ENT Season 4
96. “Borderland”/”Cold Station 12”/”The Augments”, ENT Season 4
97. “Someone To Watch Over Me”, VOY Season 5
98. “Shuttlepod One”, ENT Season 1
99. “Conspiracy”, TNG Season 1
100. “The Andorian Incident”, ENT Season 1
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/l...5/item/andorian-incident-star-trek-100-926327
And it occurred to me that simply playing the full list would make a great elimination game. The selection of episodes communicates such an interesting point of view on the franchise, it really gives the first 6 series their due. It includes all the recognized greats, but also many less obvious highlights drawn from more obscure installments.
(episodes are listed exactly as they were by THR, so there's some peculiarities, like the 6-episodes of the Occupation Arc being one item, "Improbable Cause" being listed as it's own item though every other-two parter lists both parts, etc)
THE RULES. The basic idea is your standard elimination game. Below are the 100 "greatest" episodes, according to THR. Eliminate your FAVORITE or the one you deem the 'BEST.' Please provide an EXPLANATION for why you are eliminating your choice and be sure to copy and paste the list with your choice removed.
Leave at least 2 eliminations by other posters before you eliminate another episode.
No tactical voting! You cannot remove an episode just because you feel it would threaten your preferred episode's chance to win.
Enjoy!






1. “City On The Edge Of Forever”, TOS Season 1
2. “The Best Of Both Worlds, Parts I & II”, TNG Seasons 3 & 4
3. “Balance Of Terror”, TOS Season 1
4. “The Inner Light”, TNG Season 5
5. “Space Seed”, TOS Season 1
6. “Yesterday’s Enterprise”, TNG Season 3
7. “In The Pale Moonlight”, DS9 Season 6
8. “Mirror, Mirro”, TOS Season 2
9. “Far Beyond The Stars”, DS9 Season 6
10. “Family”, TNG Season 4
11. “Let That Be Your Last Battlefield”, TOS Season 3
12. “A Piece Of The Action”, TOS Season 2
13. “The Visitor”, DS9 Season 4
14. “Tapestry”, TNG Season 6
15. “The Trouble With Tribbles”, TOS Season 2
16. “Q Who”, TNG Season 2
17. “Arena”, TOS Season 1
18. “Chain Of Command, Parts I & II”, TNG Season 6
19. “Emissary”, DS9 Season 1
20. “All Good Things…”, TNG Season 7
21. “Ship In A Bottle”, TNG Season 6
22. “Homefront/Paradise Lost”, DS9 Season 4
23. “Where No Man Has Gone Before”, TOS Season 1
24. “The Naked Time”, TOS Season 1
25. “Year Of Hell, Parts I & II”, VOY Season 4
26. “Elementary, Dear Data”, TNG Season 2
27. “The Devil In The Dark”, TOS Season 1
28. “Amok Time”, TOS Season 2
29. “Call To Arms”, DS9 Season 5
30. “Equinox, Parts I & II”, VOY Seasons 5 & 6
31. “Measure Of A Man”, TNG Season 2
32. “The Menagerie, Parts I & II”, TOS Season 1
33. “The Enterprise Incident”, TOS Season 3
34. “Living Witness”, VOY Season 4
35. “Duet”, DS9 Season 1
36. “Redemption I & II”, TNG Seasons 4 & 5
37. “Scorpion, Parts I & II”, VOY Seasons 3 & 4
38. “A Time To Stand”/”Rocks & Shoals”/”Sons & Daughters”/”Behind The Lines”/”Favor The Bold”/”Sacrifice Of Angels”, DS9 Season 6
39. “All Our Yesterdays”, TOS Season 3
40. “What You Leave Behind”, DS9 Season 7
41. “I, Borg”, TNG Season 5
42. “Journey To Babel”, TOS Season 2
43. “Parallels”, TNG Season 7
44. “Soldiers Of The Empire”, DS9 Season 5
45. “The Corbomite Maneuver”, TOS Season 1
46. “The Drumhead”, TNG Season 4
47. “Past Tense, Parts I & II”, DS9 Season 3
48. “The Doomsday Machine”, TOS Season 2
49. “Inquisition”, DS9 Season 6
50. “Lower Decks”, TNG Season 7
51. “Once More Unto The Breach”, DS9 Season 7
52. “Blink Of An Eye”, VOY Season 6
53. “A Taste Of Armageddon”, TOS Season 1
54. “Endgame”, VOY Season 7
55. “Tinker Tenor Doctor Spy”, VOY Season 6
56. “It’s Only A Paper Moon”, DS9 Season 7
57. “The Siege Of AR-558”, DS9 Season 7
58. “Hope And Fear”, VOY Season 4
59. “Yesteryear”, TAS Season 1
60. “Future’s End, Parts I & II”, VOY Season 3
61. “Take Me Out To The Holosuite”, DS9 Season 7
62. “Relics”, TNG Season 6
63. “Timeless”, VOY Season 5
64. “Worst Case Scenario”, VOY Season 3
65. “Trials And Tribble-ations”, DS9 Season 5
66. “Little Green Men”, DS9 Season 4
67. “The Galileo Seven”, TOS Season 1
68. “Frame Of Mind”, TNG Season 6
69. “Necessary Evil”, DS9 Season 2
70. “Cause And Effect”, TNG Season 5
71. “Improbable Cause”, DS9 Season 3
72. “Deadlock”, VOY Season 2
73. “The Pegasus”, TNG Season 7
74. “The Infinite Vulcan”, TAS Season 1
75. “The Tholian Web”, TOS Season 3
76. “Brothers”, TNG Season 4
77. “Damage”, ENT Season 3
78. “Crossover”, DS9 Season 2
79. “The Offspring”, TNG Season 3
80. “Broken Bow”, ENT Season 1
81. “Mortal Coil”, VOY Season 4
82. “Shore Leave”, TOS Season 1
83. “Phantasms”, TNG Season 7
84. “Caretaker”, VOY Season 1
85. “Similitude”, ENT Season 3
86. “Flashback”, VOY Season 3
87. “Our Man Bashir”, DS9 Season 4
88. “In A Mirror, Darkly, Parts I & II”, ENT Season 4
89. “Skin Of Evil”, TNG Season 1
90. “Spectre Of The Gun”, TOS Season 3
91. “The Lorelei Signal”, TAS Season 1
92. “E2”, ENT Season 3
93. “His Way”, DS9 Season 6
94. “Demons”/”Terra Prime”, ENT Season 4
95. “Home”, ENT Season 4
96. “Borderland”/”Cold Station 12”/”The Augments”, ENT Season 4
97. “Someone To Watch Over Me”, VOY Season 5
98. “Shuttlepod One”, ENT Season 1
99. “Conspiracy”, TNG Season 1
100. “The Andorian Incident”, ENT Season 1

And it's not that people watch this show for soap opera elements or who's banging whom... unless people are. Hmm, could Data (or "Datum" if TNG were scientifically accurate, but he was just "a bit player" in the show