• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

"The Man From U.N.C.L.E." remake - what took them so long?

One probable reason is three of the last four attempts at remaking a classic spy series of the 1960s - Wild Wild West, The Avengers and I Spy - all sucked because the people who made the films had no clue as to what made the originals work.

The exception was the fourth, Get Smart, which managed to do it. I'm not counting the Mission Impossible films because they weren't anything related to the TV series, which is probably why they succeeded on their own merits.

They've talked about a Man from UNCLE movie for years, but I'm personally glad they haven't done it because they've have probably screwed it up. Until now - having a director like that and George Clooney as Napoleon Solo, now that may work. Clooney has the tongue-in-cheek attitude necessary for the part. Yet I can't see them deciding to make it an all-out comedy like, say, the remake of Starsky and Hutch.

The key will be who they get to play Kuryakin. Odds are he'll be reimagined as a female character, though. They seem to like doing that these days (ref. nuBSG, Hawaii Five-O...). Whatever they do, the chemistry needs to be there, otherwise it'll die on the vine.

And considering both Robert Vaughn and David McCallum are still very active - Robert in the US series Hustle, and David of course in NCIS - it would be a sin not to have them appear in cameos.

Alex
 
One probable reason is three of the last four attempts at remaking a classic spy series of the 1960s - Wild Wild West, The Avengers and I Spy - all sucked because the people who made the films had no clue as to what made the originals work.

That's probably not the reason. Lots of remakes in all genres suck, yet that hasn't slowed down the flow of product one iota. If studios followed that reasoning there would never have been another revival of a TV series after The Beverly Hillbillies.
 
One probable reason is three of the last four attempts at remaking a classic spy series of the 1960s - Wild Wild West, The Avengers and I Spy - all sucked because the people who made the films had no clue as to what made the originals work.

That's probably not the reason. Lots of remakes in all genres suck, yet that hasn't slowed down the flow of product one iota. If studios followed that reasoning there would never have been another revival of a TV series after The Beverly Hillbillies.

However if the people who own the property give a damn about it, that's another matter. For example, there was nothing stopping the BBC from commissioning a remake of Doctor Who. There was also a reason why that Jim Carrey comedy remake of The Six Million Dollar Man was euthanized before a single frame was shot.

I stand by my statement. I think the owners of the Man from UNCLE property saw what happened to the other films and decided to wait. There was supposed to be a remake made about 10 years ago - it was reported in numerous media outlets - and that was about the time I Spy and WWW stunk up the room. And so a new UNCLE never got made. That is not a coincidence, in my opinion.

The Get Smart remake shows how it can and should be done. It was a remake and reimagining, yet it retained enough of the original's charm to work. Plus they cast the right people. It's somewhat easier to do a reimagining as a TV series - V, Hawaii 5-O, BSG - because you have more time to smooth out the rough edges and give the show a voice of its own. A remake of a well known property such as UNCLE won't have time in 90 minutes to find its own voice, so for it to work, it needs to at least start singing in harmony with the original. And with Clooney as Solo, I think it stands a better than average chance.

Alex
 
This sounds cool. Clooney's a great choice- possibly the only person who could be Solo today.

For Ilya, I'd hope they go for Paul Bettany.
 
This reminds me of an NCIS episode. In the episode someone asks Gibbs what Ducky looks like. Gibbs pauses, thinks, and replies "Ilya Kuryakin".:lol:

personally, I would prefer a new version for TV. Maybe with the pacing of "24", though not the grittiness.

And for Kuryakin, I think maybe Christopher Gorham might work.
 
This reminds me of an NCIS episode. In the episode someone asks Gibbs what Ducky looks like. Gibbs pauses, thinks, and replies "Ilya Kuryakin".:lol:

Didn't they ask what he looked like then he was younger? I agree it was a very funny moment. :lol:
 
I mean, really - you think they'd have gotten to this five years or more ago.

Clooney is a really good choice, probably the best. So, who's going to be Kuryakin?

http://www.aintitcool.com/node/47486

With Sodenberg at the helm, and Clooney as Napoleon Solo, they should just go and bring in Brad Pitt to play Kuryakin. He and Clooney had great chemistry together in the Ocean's Eleven movies. Why not continue it here.
 
I mean, really - you think they'd have gotten to this five years or more ago.

Clooney is a really good choice, probably the best. So, who's going to be Kuryakin?

http://www.aintitcool.com/node/47486

With Sodenberg at the helm, and Clooney as Napoleon Solo, they should just go and bring in Brad Pitt to play Kuryakin. He and Clooney had great chemistry together in the Ocean's Eleven movies. Why not continue it here.

That's a good thought. Hopefully Pitt can do a vaguely Russian-really-British accent, which is all McCallum really managed. :lol:
 
Y'know, I don't remember this ever being on in syndication when I was growing up in the 70s and 80s. I see DVDs are out so I'll have to give it a look.
 
I mean, really - you think they'd have gotten to this five years or more ago.

Clooney is a really good choice, probably the best. So, who's going to be Kuryakin?

http://www.aintitcool.com/node/47486

With Sodenberg at the helm, and Clooney as Napoleon Solo, they should just go and bring in Brad Pitt to play Kuryakin. He and Clooney had great chemistry together in the Ocean's Eleven movies. Why not continue it here.

That's a good thought. Hopefully Pitt can do a vaguely Russian-really-British accent, which is all McCallum really managed. :lol:

Nah, getting tired of Pitt and Clooney, though I do think they could probably do some excellent remakes of the old Hope and Crosby road movies.
 
This has been linked to Tarantino and Matthew Vaughn in the past. I was sure that it would have followed the first Mission: Impossible movie to the screen but obviously not.

Clooney has been linked to the Solo role for as long as I can remember but I really think that Jon Hamm would be a better choice at this stage. Kuryakin - yes, Clooney/Soderbergh's Ocean's co-star's Pitt or Damon would fit too but what about someone like Jude Law or Daniel Craig, who has more of McCallum's Brit coolness? I suppose Craig is out - would his 007 contract allow for another spy piece, created by Ian Fleming?!

Glad to hear it's to be a period piece. I really think the concept will work better that way than as an update. But I do wonder if it's one of those shows like The Avengers or Wild Wild West, which just won't work as an update?
 
Hamm has no demonstrated drawing power at the box office, at all - Clooney still has oodles. Soderbergh likes to work with Clooney, so if the guy's available that's the way to go.
 
^ Oh, no arguments there. I just think age-wise Hamm is more appropriate and more like a young Robert Vaughn than Clooney. Plus he's pretty well suited to the 1960s look!

Of course, once Soderbergh became involved, Clooney's casting was/ is pretty much inevitable.
 
Clooney would play it well, but might be a little too old-looking for Solo, especially if it's set in the 60s...

Really, he should have been Hannibal in The A Team. (Though I was surprised by how well Liam Neeson pulled off that role)

Setting it in the 60s also... while I'd like it, box-office-wise it'd have the shadow of Austin Powers looming over it if they kept it tongue-in-cheek, and if they made it grim and gritty then they'd have missed the target...

Illya will be tricky to cast (if this was 1990, Andreas Wisniewski would be ideal, but not 20 years later)... Unless... No, any UNCLE fans would lynch me for suggesting it...

simm_blonde.jpg


Or if you *must* have a bigger movie name, and a Scot, then Ewan MacGregor


Just please don't them pull a Starbuck and recast Illya as female! (Though, oddly, I could see Angelina Jolie making a good female Solo...)
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top