• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Implications of a [spoiler]

JRoss

Commodore
Commodore
The internet has been buzzing with speculation as to the identity of Missy, a mysterious new character introduced in the seventh series premiere, "Deep Breath." The usual assumptions to her identity are flying, she's the Rani or Romana in a new form, she's a previous companion (with Amy or River Song being the top choices), she's a future Doctor. But one character keeps popping up with growing frequency and credibility. Before you read on, be warned that the ideas here are laden with spoilers from the current series and the classic show.

Many fans now believe that the name "Missy" is short for Mistress, the female variant of Master. If you're unfamiliar with that character, the Master is both the Doctor's oldest nemesis and his childhood friend. The Third Doctor once referred to him as "my best enemy."

When we last saw the Master he was coming to terms with the horrible revelation of the cause of his descent into madness and confronting the Time Lords on Gallifrey. If the Master is now Missy this implies several story developments.

First, the Master somehow has escaped from Gallifrey, which is currently trapped outside of normal time. Either that or he (she) has the ability to draw people to Gallifrey, as Missy is seen welcoming newly-deceased characters to a supposed afterlife. If the Master/Missy can initiate travel to or from Gallifrey then we may be in line to see it restored to the universe by the end of this series.

Second, that the Master has probably not mended his ways since he had a near-heroic moment during the finale of "The End of Time, Part 2". Missy's overly soothing manner and severe manner of dress paint her as a probable villain. Showrunner Steven Moffatt used Madame Kovarian, the main antagonist of Series 6 in a similar manner.

Finally, if Missy truly is the Master, then the powers behind the show are opening the door for a future incarnation of the Doctor to be played by a woman. Neil Gaiman introduced the idea of a gender-changing Time Lord in "The Doctor's Wife," but the Master/Missy would be our first on-screen view of an established character taking on another gender after regeneration.

Who is Missy, truly? If Steven Moffatt continues the style of previous seasons we'll have to wait until the premier of the finale, Death in Heaven, on November 8. Until then we have eight more episodes worth of clues and teasers to discover and analyze. Happy hunting!
 
I think a female Master would have worked better in a pre-Day of the Doctor era. It would have added sexual tension to their rivalry and it would also add the element that technically, they could save the Time Lord race. But that would mean the two of them pro-creating. Would you have sex with your worst enemy if it would save your species? And what if they did procreate -- imagine that famiy structure! "My mommy is an evil genius who wants to save the world and my daddy is a super hero that tries to save it."

But now that we know that Gallifray is still out there, somewhere, that kind of pressure can't be worked into the story.
 
If Missy is a previously established character, than the Master seems the most likely. Moffat likes revisiting his earlier ideas and making them episodes of Doctor Who, and this would basically be the ending of Curse of the Fatal Death, only with a female Master instead of a female Doctor, and this time it would be played seriously as opposed to for laughs.

But I'd say it's equally as likely Missy's a new character. And seems the kind of anti-climatic thing to happen, turn fandom rabid trying to figure out who from Who lore this mysterious character is only to reveal she's someone new.
 
I'd like it a lot if the Master returned as a woman.

But I'm kind of hoping that Missy is Death. That could be fun- and the implications of Death calling the Doctor her "boyfriend" seem right up Moffat's alley.
 
I want Missy to be the manifestation of the TARDIS that never was.

In The Name of the Doctor, Trenzalore was the Doctor's grave, including a dying old TARDIS where Clara entered his time stream and saved him throughout his lives, including pointing the first Doctor to the right TARDIS. The events of Time of the Doctor kind of undo all of that. Trenzalore is no longer his grave, that dying old TARDIS doesn't exist and Clara never had the chance to stop the Doctor from stealing the "correct" TARDIS. Now through wibbily wobbley timey wimey there is an almost insane TARDIS that has 2 different histories, and is "collecting" things while trying to get back to the boyfriend that loves her.
 
^ Ugh, I hope it's not that just because I want that whole convoluted mess to end! I enjoyed those stories, well except for Time of the Doctor, but those various timelines are just to convoluted to carry forward.

Mr Awe
 
I've been looking at it from the robot's end, thinking why robots would want to seek the promised land. It is clear these robots are not highly sentient, which makes me believe they're programmed by someone. Someone who cannot look for the promised land themselves, so they're doing the NASA thing of sending robotic probes instead.

Since "The Girl In the Fireplace" is written by Moffat and intentionally linked to Deep Breath, I am presuming those robots are related too. Both ship's names, and the fact that human body parts were used by the robots in TGITFP suggests these robots are made by humans, possibly from the future?
 
Since "The Girl In the Fireplace" is written by Moffat and intentionally linked to Deep Breath, I am presuming those robots are related too. Both ship's names, and the fact that human body parts were used by the robots in TGITFP suggests these robots are made by humans, possibly from the future?

Well, yes, The Girl in the Fireplace's future is something like three thousand years later, which presumably is where the ship in Deep Breath is from, being the sister ship after all.
 
Is it just me, or has this malarkey in the new season diminished the exceptional 'Girl In The Fireplace' ?

They should've left well alone...
 
Is it just me, or has this malarkey in the new season diminished the exceptional 'Girl In The Fireplace' ?

They should've left well alone...

The Girl in the Fireplace was already diminished in 2010 when it was remade as The Eleventh Hour.
 
Is it just me, or has this malarkey in the new season diminished the exceptional 'Girl In The Fireplace' ?

They should've left well alone...

The Girl in the Fireplace was already diminished in 2010 when it was remade as The Eleventh Hour.
If any story which shares elements with another story is a "remake", then Goethe was wrong: there aren't as many as 36 dramatic plots, there is just one, and every story is just a remake of every other story.
 
Is it just me, or has this malarkey in the new season diminished the exceptional 'Girl In The Fireplace' ?

They should've left well alone...

The Girl in the Fireplace was already diminished in 2010 when it was remade as The Eleventh Hour.
If any story which shares elements with another story is a "remake", then Goethe was wrong: there aren't as many as 36 dramatic plots, there is just one, and every story is just a remake of every other story.

Well, The Eleventh Hour really does have a lot of similarities with The Girl in the Fireplace. Both are stories of the Doctor being an imaginary friend of a child and coming back when they're grown up to help fend off an alien attack. The aliens are fixated on this person. And we even get the line "you've had some cowboys in here" in both episodes.
 
Yeah, if you want to count Eleventh Hour as a copy of Girl in the Fire Place, then every episode where the Doctor time travels must be a copy of every other time travel episode. I hope you don't watch an episode and think, "God, The Doctor is traveling in time again! This is even worse than Voyager!"
 
I think a female Master would have worked better in a pre-Day of the Doctor era. It would have added sexual tension to their rivalry and it would also add the element that technically, they could save the Time Lord race. But that would mean the two of them pro-creating. Would you have sex with your worst enemy if it would save your species? And what if they did procreate -- imagine that famiy structure!

Considering the Master's line in Planet of Fire hinting the Master was a relative of the Doctor's makes that even more funny.

(For the sake of reference the truncated line was "Won't you even show mercy to your own-")
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top