50th Anniversary Album Spotlight
Tumbleweed Connection
Elton John
Released October 30, 1970 (UK); January 1971 (US)
Chart debut: January 23, 1971
Chart peak: #5 (February 13, 1971)
#463 on Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All Time (2003)
This was a surprising bit of business for me when it came up on the Rolling Stone list--Elton's immediate follow-up to his breakout eponymous album was a Western-themed concept album with no singles and that I can't say I'd ever heard of...and it did quite well in the day.
Elton opens the album in good light-rocking form with "Ballad of a Well-Known Gun," about an outlaw who's caught while returning home:
I guess it's a loose concept--or at least doesn't have a storyline--because the lower-key "Come Down in Time" doesn't seem to continue the story of the first track...unless the story is flashing back to the character's origins.
The laid-back "Country Comfort" was originally recorded by Rod Stewart for his album Gasoline Alley, released earlier in 1970.
Both of the characters in the funk-flavored "Son of Your Father" die, so I guess it's not about the same character.
The first side closes with the ballad "My Father's Gun"...
Side two opens with "Where to Now St. Peter?," which "addresses the subject of whether the final destination is heaven or hell told through the point of view of a dying soldier."
This strikes me as Elton more on his game than in some of the side one tracks.
The airy "Love Song" is uncharacteristically acoustic guitar-based, with no piano:
The ivories are back for "Amoreena," which "appears to be about a young man yearning for his distant loved one":
I'd say that this one had potential single chops.
The album's penultimate track is the melancholy "Talking Old Soldiers"...
The album climaxes with its most ambitious track, "Burn Down the Mission":
Overall, this is a solid, listenable, well-crafted album, but relatively lacking in really stand-out material.
_______
Also, that album cover, which came out much later in the year, is totally riffing on Tapestry.
Tumbleweed Connection
Elton John
Released October 30, 1970 (UK); January 1971 (US)
Chart debut: January 23, 1971
Chart peak: #5 (February 13, 1971)
#463 on Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All Time (2003)
Wiki said:Tumbleweed Connection is the third studio album by English singer-songwriter Elton John. It was recorded at Trident Studios, London, England in March 1970....It is a concept album based on country and western/Americana themes. All songs are written by John and Bernie Taupin, with the exception of "Love Song" by Lesley Duncan.
This was a surprising bit of business for me when it came up on the Rolling Stone list--Elton's immediate follow-up to his breakout eponymous album was a Western-themed concept album with no singles and that I can't say I'd ever heard of...and it did quite well in the day.
Elton opens the album in good light-rocking form with "Ballad of a Well-Known Gun," about an outlaw who's caught while returning home:
A Genius contributor said:When Elton and Bernie Taupin first met Bob Dylan, on a staircase at the Fillmore East shortly after Tumbleweed Connection’s release, Dylan made a point to express that he “really liked the lyrics to ‘Ballad of a Well-Known Gun.’”
I guess it's a loose concept--or at least doesn't have a storyline--because the lower-key "Come Down in Time" doesn't seem to continue the story of the first track...unless the story is flashing back to the character's origins.
Wiki said:The song...outlines a conversation between a man and his lover; she urges him to come meet her one night. As he is walking and nears their agreed upon meeting place, he wonders whether she will be there or if he will be left alone to count the stars.
The laid-back "Country Comfort" was originally recorded by Rod Stewart for his album Gasoline Alley, released earlier in 1970.
Both of the characters in the funk-flavored "Son of Your Father" die, so I guess it's not about the same character.
The lyrics tell of an argument between two men (one blind) on "an East Virginia Farm." After a while, their argument leads to death because the two men did not follow the golden rule as stated in the lyrics (but in different words).
The first side closes with the ballad "My Father's Gun"...
The song tells the story of a young Confederate whose father has just been killed during the American Civil War. After burying his father in the South, he takes up his father's gun and goes off to rejoin the fighting, longing for a future after the victory of their cause. According to Elton, this was one of Bob Dylan's favourites when they first met in 1970.
Side two opens with "Where to Now St. Peter?," which "addresses the subject of whether the final destination is heaven or hell told through the point of view of a dying soldier."
This strikes me as Elton more on his game than in some of the side one tracks.
The airy "Love Song" is uncharacteristically acoustic guitar-based, with no piano:
The ivories are back for "Amoreena," which "appears to be about a young man yearning for his distant loved one":
I'd say that this one had potential single chops.
The album's penultimate track is the melancholy "Talking Old Soldiers"...
The song tells the story of chance meeting of a young man and an old man inside a bar. The old man describes his loneliness and his former comrades who died in combat. It is implied—"I've seen enough to have a man go out his brains"—that the old man has PTSD. The old man also thanks the young man for listening; no one else in the bar would.
The album climaxes with its most ambitious track, "Burn Down the Mission":
The lyrics..., while telling a simple story, are vague enough to be open to interpretation. Ostensibly the story is that of a poor community oppressed by a rich and powerful force, and the narrator, driven by some sort of revelation, has decided to take direct action to remedy the situation. However, his attempt fails and he is "taken away", presumably to meet his fate, and justifies his actions as an attempt to defend his family.
The music reflects this narrative structure by starting with a slow piano introduction and the telling of the hero's situation and his progress towards direct action; the middle section, which is faster, jazzier and brings in full instrumentation, can be read as an interpretation of the actual struggle in which the hero engages. Finally, the struggle has ended and the music returns to its initial understated form, reflecting the eventual defeat of the hero. The song ends with a restatement of the middle section while it fades out.
[...]
This is one of the most musically complicated works of John's career. The key changes four times before returning to the original opening chord sequence at the half-way mark. It has always been quite a fan favorite, and John has frequently performed it live.
Overall, this is a solid, listenable, well-crafted album, but relatively lacking in really stand-out material.
The album peaked at #2 on the UK Albums Chart and #5 on the US Billboard 200 chart. In the US, it was certified gold in March 1971 and platinum in August 1998 by the RIAA.
_______
I should note that the single version was apparently a vastly edited-down version...under three minutes. Is there any justice in a world where the next song makes the Top 10, but "Layla" doesn't even crack the Top 40? It should have been released at full length and become the next "Hey Jude".Mondo Classico.
This being the next single to come along may have made my decision about whether or not to get more Osmonds for me. I've had a high tolerance for bubblegum of the era up to this point, but this is more like a caramel-covered lollipop dipped in a bowl of sugar. A horrendous rearrangement of what turns out to have originally been an early Roy Orbison single.WTF?
Pretty, early '70s soft rock...Bread is back in their box.Beautiful poetry. I love Bread.
Still "early"? This one's decent, but I'd say it's roughly where he starts becoming "that" Neil Diamond...the one that people are reluctant to admit they like.Some nice early Neil Diamond.
Also, that album cover, which came out much later in the year, is totally riffing on Tapestry.
Last edited: