This episode was an improvement over the second one. But the show still feels like it needs to settle down tonally and stylistically.
And the mythology needs to get a lot more interesting.
I think it's coming along. If viewers and the network allow this show to breathe, I think we'll be satisfied. We got a major chunk of backstory this week - where the Cape came from, who Orwell is (I'm glad they aren't dragging that out - I had that figured out by the end of the pilot), who Max is. We got a surprise suggestion of a 'ship between Orwell and the circus guy (please let that pan out - it would be a refreshing direction), and on top of it all we get Orwell all but being adopted as part of the circus family. And they established a second recurring big bad while not letting us forget about Chess. I think they accomplished a lot in just an hour.
So far, where the show drags for me is with the family. I like the fact they've got the wife now investigating her husband, though hopefully she'll twig that his partner is a bad guy before long. But I feel the show works best when it's just Faraday and Orwell, and it sings when the circus characters are involved.
I also like the Blade Runner-influenced "undercity" set design for the circus and the area around Faraday's "Bat Cave". The only problem I have with it is it's sabotaged by the establishing shots that show a clean, modern city and don't really don't suggest where such an area might actually exist, let alone (as this episode firmly establishes) within quick walking distance of the circus.
Like most shows, I've taken the "I'll enjoy it while it lasts" approach. I really hope this show scores a hit with the mass audience, but it probably has too many strikes against it to last more than a season. Still, if No Ordinary Family survives, and Fringe manages to defeat the "Friday Night Death Slot" self-fulfilling prophecy, who knows. I only wish they'd kept the show on Sunday. Though we still get it on Sunday here in Canada, I think it might have had a better chance than during the week. We'll see.
Alex