• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

"The Best of Both Worlds" - What Would Spock Have Done?

Admiral_Sisko

Lieutenant Commander
Red Shirt
"The Best of Both Worlds" is an often discussed two-part episode of The Next Generation, both for its inclusion of the Borg and for the decisions made by the Enterprise crew in Picard's absence. Riker, in particular, is faced with several difficult decisions, and it is only when he decides to make these decisions based on what he- not Picard- believes is best for his crew.

Suppose, however, that the events in question had occurred not in 2366-67, but one hundred years earlier, during the Enterprise's initial five-year mission under James Kirk. Were Kirk abducted by the Borg, thus leaving Spock in command of the Enterprise, how might the Vulcan first-officer dealt with the loss of his commanding officer and the looming threat of the Borg?

Bear in mind that concepts such as saucer-separation weren't possible with Spock's Enterprise, so that wouldn't have been an option, but based on Spock's behavior during the course of The Original Series, what could we realistically expect of him, given his command style and expectations of his crew?
 
Instead of Data plugging his head into the Borg Collective to issue shut-down commands, Spock would have used a mindmeld to access the Borg consciousness and done the same.
 
Instead of Data plugging his head into the Borg Collective to issue shut-down commands, Spock would have used a mindmeld to access the Borg consciousness and done the same.

I wonder how he may have tolerated that, as he was completely overwhelmed by his attempted mind-meld with V'Ger during The Motion Picture. Trying to absorb the thoughts of the entire Borg Collective would have been difficult, even for a mind as disciplined as Spock's.
 
Bear in mind that concepts such as saucer-separation weren't possible with Spock's Enterprise, so that wouldn't have been an option

Maybe from a budgetary standpoint since they couldn't afford to do the effect, however, the original Enterprise DID have that ability. Kirk even suggested it to Scotty in The Apple. Now assuming this was an epic two parter with a larger effects budget, then they could film it. I say use of saucer separation is still a valid option, if anything to use the matter/anti-matter engines as a weapon by blowing them up inside the Borg cube's shields.
 
I agree with the mind-meld attempt or if that fails, some sort of looping paradox-thingy to confuse the Borg for a few minutes. Hope it would work, could you imagine a Kirkcutus? "Resistance IS... futile!" On the other hand, I can also imagine Kirk having his way with the smitten Borg queen.
 
I can see Spock performing a mind meld. He might try the same technique to put the Borg to sleep, or introduce some illogical thoughts or out of spec conditions for the cube to get it to self distruct.
 
I agree with the mind-meld attempt or if that fails, some sort of looping paradox-thingy to confuse the Borg for a few minutes. Hope it would work, could you imagine a Kirkcutus? "Resistance IS... futile!" On the other hand, I can also imagine Kirk having his way with the smitten Borg queen.


kirkborg01.jpg
 
They'd just beam over one of those bowling ball thingys full of antimatter. Along with a couple of disposible redshirts.
 
Instead of Data plugging his head into the Borg Collective to issue shut-down commands, Spock would have used a mindmeld to access the Borg consciousness and done the same.

I wonder how he may have tolerated that, as he was completely overwhelmed by his attempted mind-meld with V'Ger during The Motion Picture. Trying to absorb the thoughts of the entire Borg Collective would have been difficult, even for a mind as disciplined as Spock's.

Well, if you go by Voyager's depiction of Vulcan's being assimilated (not quite the same as mind-melding, but close enough) all you need is a week between episodes to fully recover. :lol:
 
On the other hand, I can also imagine Kirk having his way with the smitten Borg queen.


The Borg Queen didn't exist until First Contact. This hypothetical is about Best of Both Worlds. (Despite the First Contact writers attempt to retcon the Borg Queen into BoBW)
 
On the other hand, I can also imagine Kirk having his way with the smitten Borg queen.


The Borg Queen didn't exist until First Contact. This hypothetical is about Best of Both Worlds. (Despite the First Contact writers attempt to retcon the Borg Queen into BoBW)

Borg queen was such a lame idea. They just made a borg queen because they couldn't meet the challenge of writing the borg well in the movie.

I like to pretend it never happened. In the star trek universe inside my head, there is no borg queen.
 
Every single Borg episode needed some kind of representative for the Borg:

"Q Who?" used Q and Guinan to "speak" for the Borg.

BOBW had Locutus.

"I, Borg" and "Descent" had Hugh and Lore.

FC just did the same thing.
 
On the other hand, I can also imagine Kirk having his way with the smitten Borg queen.


The Borg Queen didn't exist until First Contact. This hypothetical is about Best of Both Worlds. (Despite the First Contact writers attempt to retcon the Borg Queen into BoBW)

Actually, the Borg Queen fits in very well to The Best of Both Worlds. I included her in my novelization of tBoBW, and it worked very well. Link in my signature.
 
I agree with the mind-meld attempt or if that fails, some sort of looping paradox-thingy to confuse the Borg for a few minutes. Hope it would work, could you imagine a Kirkcutus? "Resistance IS... futile!" On the other hand, I can also imagine Kirk having his way with the smitten Borg queen.

Hewould i guess have a little trouble figuring how to park his "shuttle" in her "shuttle bay":guffaw:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top