that was a GOOD idea

[RobertScorpio]

Uhhh, did you bother to read the original post? It ain't that long buddy, take the 2 minutes.


I think that Berman letting Behr run DS9 was a good idea. And as much as I love what Behr did with the show, I think Berman not letting Behr have the Federation loose the Dominion war was a good idea.

Why on earth would we want to see the Federation loose the Dominion War??

Cuz it would be fun!

But this would only work if Series V were a continuation of the storyline. The Feds have to win in the end, but let them suffer for seven years fighting as underdogs.

Hey it would have been better than what we got instead: ENT.

But even then, it works only if the DS9 writers stay for Series V. Berman & Braga doing Star Trek: Resistance would have had all ENT's problems anyway.

You read my mind...I totally agree. Its not that Voyager/Enterprise are bad, its just that they seemed so sterile and they just went over the same 'moral' based episodes that TNG had done....they needed to shake up the formula and they never did..and then they all got fired...good.
Rob