The Star Beagle Adventures
Episode 21:
The Revealing Science of God, Part 2
Scene 2:
Work Out the Story
Sent through the rhythm
Work out the story …
21.2
Work Out the Story
“I’d like to turn your attention to the events that occurred in the Jar Galaxy in the star system that you named the Leprechaun System.”
“I was afraid you were going to say that...”
Lieutenant Commander Grimur Nurzer, Captain Rhonda Carter, Captain Ronald “Skip” Howard, XIV, and Yeoman Svort had reconvened in the U.S.S. Mako’s hindmost room, the Caudal Lounge, located at the rear of the secondary engineering hull. Nurzer liked the comfortable size of the room, neither too big nor too small, as well as its privacy, given that it was not close to anyone’s quarters and the only departments located nearby, Engineering, Medical, and Quartermaster, each had their own conference rooms.
“There was a single gas giant in that system, apparently in a stable figure-8 orbit, orbiting once around the twin main sequence stars on one side of the system, and a blue giant on the other,” Nurzer continued. “Because of that unique orbit, you gave it the name of a star instead of a planet, calling it Leprechaun D. Tell me about why you approached that planet and what kind of threat assessment you performed before going in.”
“Yeah, I screwed that one up,” Carter admitted. “And Escort paid the price.”
“You weren’t on the bridge when the approach was ordered,” Nurzer observed.
“I had told my staff we needed to fuel up on deuterium and pointed us toward that system,” Carter recounted. “But I deliberately did not change the rotation and given our course, I knew that we would enter the system at the 6th hour of Ensign Sevork’s 19th rotation in command. He may or may not have been aware, but I had been monitoring the bridge from my quarters. I knew when he didn’t order a probe into orbit before ordering the ship in.”
“Why didn’t you countermand?”
“He was in command.”
Grimur Nurzer took a breath. “That decision did not turn out well.”
Rhonda Carter shook her head. “No, it did not. I underestimated the potential damage from that oversight.”
“Did you enter a reprimand into his fact file?” Nurzer asked.
“I didn’t need to,” Carter responded. “After we had the emergency under control, he wrote his own reprimand and asked me to sign it. I signed it without comment.” Carter looked up. “He was a promising young officer. It was a rookie mistake. I severely underestimated just how dangerous it could be. There was nothing on the sensors to indicate there was any kind of threat. And we had never encountered anything remotely like those space bound mushrooms before.”
“It was your mistake,” Nurzer said.
“Yes. It was,” Carter admitted.
“Twice?” Nurzer asked.
“Twice,” Carter confirmed. “I didn’t order the probe in advance. It was okay to test the ensign, but not to risk ship and crew on it. I should have ordered the probe in advance.”
“And the other mistake?” Nurzer asked.
“Training and doctrine,” Carter responded.
“You paid a heavy price for those oversights. Your ship. And, arguably, your crew,” Nurzer said.
“I did the math,” Carter said. “We would have encountered Stephanie anyway.”
“With fully functional nacelles,” Nurzer countered. “You could have left after shooting up that inter-dimensional mushroom.”
“I seriously doubt that,” Carter rejoined. “It had sufficient attitudinal control of Escort to make sure our phasers were pointed at its inter-dimensional nads. We weren’t going anywhere Rocky didn’t want us to go.”
“No,” Nurzer mused. “No, perhaps not. But you might have tried if you had the option. And you didn’t have that option. Why?”
“Insufficient training and doctrine. Insufficient orders. Insufficient oversight,” Carter responded.
“It helps that you are aware of that,” Nurzer said. “Captains have lost their commands for less.” He sighed and dropped his hands to the table with a thump. "Now let's talk about using the ship's transporters to kill what was, if not an intelligent, at least a sentient life form. Thousands of them."
"I won't apologize for that," Carter replied.
"It could be considered, in fact it has already been characterized as a war crime," Nurzer retorted. "It is hard to imagine a more cruel and painful death."
"It would be cruel and extremely painful for me to kill you with a spoon. But if you're trying to kill me and all I've got is a spoon, I'm going to kill you with a spoon."
Nurzer suppressed a shudder. Even if he had not been aware of Rhonda Carter's impressive and rather grim record of kills in hand-to-hand combat, the cold look in her eyes alone was enough to convince him she was entirely capable of killing him with a spoon. There was something about her expression and bearing that screamed "KILLER" in capital letters.
"You had no other option?" Nurzer asked.
"Those little mushroom bugs walked through our shields like they weren't even there," Carter responded. "They were partially phased into subspace, so the phasers wouldn't have done anything to them. They got into the transfer chambers of the nacelles as if they were open to space and started gobbling up hydrogen. Do you know how much hydrogen is in your body?"
Nurzer's eyes widened.
"So yeah, kill or be killed," Carter concluded.
Nurzer sighed heavily. “Okay Captain. I will prepare my report and recommendations for the commodore and deliver them to her within the next 48 hours. I probably shouldn't tell you this, but just for your peace of mind, I do not believe this rises to the level of a court martial. There was no deliberate misconduct. And you are probably aware of the political considerations. No one instructed me about them, but that does not mean I am unaware of them. When it comes to any consideration of war crimes, Star Fleet captains are given pretty broad latitude when it comes to saving ship and crew. But there is a case to be made for gross negligence of duty. And the horrible death you inflicted on those creatures flows directly from that failure.”
“I will accept your report, Lieutenant Commander,” said Carter.
“I have no doubt you will, Captain. Especially considering those were your conclusions in your after-action report to the commodore. Your frankness in that report does not hurt you at all.”
“I will see you again before this is all over. Let me take this moment to thank you for your service, Captain Carter.” Nurzer stood up slowly. “It is no exaggeration to say that you have been credited with saving thousands, if not tens of thousands of lives during the wars. Quite possibly more. I was unaware of your record and accomplishments until I was given this assignment. It has not been an easy assignment for me.”
“I would rather you hadn’t known about my war record in advance of this investigation.”
“Me too.” Nurzer offered a formal salute, which was unusual for Star Fleet.
Carter responded by offering her hand.
“Thank you, Lieutenant Commander,” she said as he ended the salute and shook her hand.
“Thank you, sir.”
21.2