I Madred would have been a little scared when Sisko lost his clothes.
"O.. My... Are all Humans so well... Well, yes. Um. The three of us were talking about something? What was it?"
...
Seriously, would Sisko have "lied" to get out of the discomfort? I do see him as a more adaptable character but the whole dehumanization here is a little too "Roots" to get away with but Picard kept to the truth so long he actually broke. however, listening to Ben's black and white certainty about the Maquis being dirty rotten traitors even though he ended up bedding one of them.