• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sucker Punch (Film 2011) Grading/Discussion

Grade The Film!


  • Total voters
    45
  • Poll closed .
This movie is what I like to call "review proof" (for me that is). No matter how bad the reviews are I see something special in the previews, therefore I'm seeing the movie tomorrow no matter what.
 
that's true loved battle los angeles can'nt wait for sucker puch even if its in IMAX .

getting up early to go see it @ amc 15 northpark dallas . 9:45 am viewing.
 
I used to pay attention to reviews, mainly to get a sense of what to expect from a particular film. I try not to pay attention to the critical parts of one.
 
People said the same thing regarding Whedon and Wonder Woman. But he was pretty much kicked off the project once Serenity underperformed.


Uh, no. Whedon was kicked off Wonder Woman after spinning his wheels for a really long time and not delivering a god damn thing.
 
The reviews make it sound a lot like I felt about Watchmen... which was that it was a pretty soulless, heartless, boring POS. I may even just breeze by this one on DVD too at this point...
 
A reviewer that I'm fond of stated something interesting...he said that the movie is indeed just that a "Sucker Punch". I'm guessing that he meant that it draws you in with the visual spectacle but while you're distracted with that, the story bangs you over the head and not in a good way. I dunno. I wasn't expecting to hear such overwhelming negative reviews, it doesn't matter. I'm still seeing it tomorrow night.
 
Just got back from seeing it, I gave it an A!

Holy shit, I'm in love with this film, though if it's true that Snyder cut 18 minutes out of it to secure a PG-13, than I'm really eager to see what was cut out. Cause while I did love the film and I do feel it deserves the A that I gave it, I did feel like something was missing, it felt incomplete...and there were a few moments where I could tell harsher language was cut out.

There's so much of the story that I want to discuss here, but I think I'll wait till more people have seen it. I realize it's not going to be for everyone but when the movie started and that beautiful version of "Sweet Dreams" was playing, I was hooked.
 
I saw this movie today and loved it . fantastic Five stars I hope they do a sequal .way better than watchman .
 
lol - the viewer rating on Rotten Tomatoes dropped 10% overnight. Not that viewer rating is anything to go by, I just thought it was pretty funny. I'm guessing some people who don't just want mind-numbing action from their films finally got to seeing it.
 
I think usually people like some plot to go with their action. From everything I've read, that's where this movie fails. That and the random unrelated imagery/music is either hamfistedly trying to make its point or it's so random as to not really make any sort of point.

At any rate, the people who like it will ask "what did you expect" as if that excuses a movie for being shitty somehow (see Battle: LA), while simultaneously claiming it's smarter than it appears to be.

I may still see it just so I can at least legitimately complain about it. Who knows, maybe I'll even like it.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top