I liked Rose, liked Martha, but didn't care much for Donna.I hear Amy and Rory are good though.
I loved Rose, didn't care for Martha - though the actor was quite good in a thankless part - and couldn't be rid of Donna quickly enough. Amy and Rory are adorable - Amy's easily the best companion since Rose, and is often out ahead of the Doctor.
I just think its funny how much animosity comes through in a lot of these articles with studio heads/producers/creators. Like I was reading a description for Alphas in EW the other day & the producer/writer/whoever just has to point out that anyone can like this show b/c we have no one flying or wearing tights or icky nerdy stuff like that. It also comes out in just about any article with SyFy honchos these days. 