• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Strange New Worlds Episode 7 - Those Old Scientists

Grade The Episode


  • Total voters
    319
My favorite Star Trek episodes are bottle shows.


Not by THAT much. And mostly by height, IIRC.


So... 150-200 feet wide? What was the original? 70 feet?

Gotta say, adding the landing target from the Star Fleet Technical Manual does make me feel yummy.

I was referring to people calling episodes bottle episodes when they aren't (like people calling characters Mary Sues when they aren't, people calling episodes filler when they aren't) not saying bottle episodes are bad.
 
That opening narration, BTW, was something cobbled together at the last minute to get the production credit sequence done - written by Roddenberry with input from Justman. It had nothing to do with the pitch, the hiring and assignment of stories to writers, or the production of the series itself. It is not and never was actually a mission statement for what Star Trek as a production was "about."
 
The episode would've been funnier in my opinion if Pike said, "Sorry Ensign Boimler, I have to keep the ship safe even if it means offending your sensibilities" and attacked the Orions as pirates, chased them across the galaxy after they took the portal, stunned an entire crowd of Orions on the way to the Orion crew only for Pike to find the nerdiest looking Orions you've ever seen and the Orion captain to be like, "Dude, we're scientists, we're just getting a scan and were going to put the portal back and we'd have done it sooner if you had just asked". Have the Orion scientist look a bit like Doc Brown/Einstein even.
No, that would not have been funnier or funny at all. Actually, it's a pretty horrible idea.
 
"Trials and Tribbleations(DS9)" is utterly pointless? That's a first, or at least the first time I've heard someone place it so low on their scale in a very, VERY long time. So long I can't even recall the last dismissive comment I heard about it.

"Trials and Tribble-ations" is sublime. It's an obvious labor of love and full of heart and humor.
 
Okay, something I didn't know until yesterday that gave me an after-the-fact chuckle.

That scene at the end where Jack Ransom sees the poster and says Una is 'the hottest first officer in starfleet'?

Little did I know that Ransom's voice actor is married to Rebecca Romjin in real life. Well played! :rommie:
 
Okay, something I didn't know until yesterday that gave me an after-the-fact chuckle.

That scene at the end where Jack Ransom sees the poster and says Una is 'the hottest first officer in starfleet'?

Little did I know that Ransom's voice actor is married to Rebecca Romjin in real life. Well played! :rommie:
I’ve been a Jerry O’Connell fan since I was a kid watching Sliders, and I did not recognize his voice in that role.
 
I have thought this. It can always be argued that they are exploring the 'Strange New Worlds' of the human psyche. I just don't think that's the intention.

Well, that's arguably always been part of Trek since Day One. "The Cage" has telepathic aliens messing with Pike's psyche. "The Naked Time" laid the crew's inner longings bare. "The Enemy Within" literally split Kirk's psyche in two. Alien spores messed with Spock's brain, liberating his human emotions . . . again. Etc, etc.

And that's just the very first season of the very first STAR TREK show, plus the original pilot.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top