• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Wars or Star Trek

Star Trek....
I've not even seen episodes 1 2 or 3... or any of those clone fart episodes....
 
Can I just avoid this whole thing by saying Lost In Space? Oh, okay if you insist... it's obviously Star Trek!
 
Trek by a landslide. Empire is an awesome movie, though, and John Williams rules the Earth.
 
I love Trek...

I do like Star Wars but recently it's lost it's appeal to me.....while the clone wars stuff is interesting it just doesn't compare to the Dominion War...hell those Jem'hadar would make Mincemeat out of Clone Troopers.
 
Both. If Lucas had done a Live Action TV show there would be something to fight over. As it is, there are only the movies. I saw reruns of TOS before I saw ANH.
 
Star Wars.

If this was just about TV shows Trek wins by a mile. Apart from that I enjoy Star Wars movies, books, comics and games much more than the Trek counterparts.
 
Star Wars always feels like a big spectacle where Star Trek doesn't, but there is alot more Star Trek out there. Star Trek movies don't feel like big events. They are usually crapped out as cheaply as possible. I do enjoy both shows though. I always love the Kirk man and Worf. When Star Trek does something big like in the DS9 battles then they seem more impressive.

I think even Star Wars' worst faults like Jar Jar or Jake Loyd are better than a cringe worthy scene like Picard doing the Mambo in Insurrection. My main fault with Star Trek is the low quality of the movies. I usually enjoy it as Television.
 
I like both equally. However, I find the Star Wars EU to be far more interesting than the Star Trek EU.
 
Im going with Star trek. And I totally base this on 'TV and Movies'. I just think there are far more better hours of TREk (meaning great episodes) than the four hours of good Star wars..what do I mean?

To me, JEDI, PHANTOM, ATTACK OF CLONES, SITH are good, not great movies (and to be honest, two of them are pretty bad)

EMPIRE and NEW HOPE are great movies...but thats just four hours of greatness. I can list at least twenty episodes of TREK(S), which adds up to 20+hours.

So, by sure volume of 'great hours' I can have rewatching Trek(s), I side with Star Trek. And IMO..its not even close...

Rob
 
Star Trek. I am a dyed in the wool Trekkie.
That said, Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back, is pure awesome and win.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top