We just got back, as well. While the majority of the actors seemed like they were sequestered and separated from the "hoi poloi", there were some who seemed happy to mingle and talk to fans, and I didn't see anyone abusing that. I only got one photo taken, though, and didn't do autographs, so I could have missed stuff in that, but there were so many events to do, especially on sea days!
My thoughts: I've decided that ECP really stands for Extremely Chaotic Productions. While I appreciate the difficulty of making what's essentially a floating convention, it's still a smallish convention (of about 2300 attendees) and any time I asked a question of the ECP staff, they either gave me conflicting info or didn't know the answer. Occasionally, I met one person who knew the answer. I didn't do any celeb excursions or paid events, and I heard from those who did that there were mixups, especially with the one Connor Trinneer hosted. There was confusion about photo retrieval and times and unfortunately, they had things scheduled so that if you wanted to do photo or autograph sessions, you would have to miss or forgo part of the daily "show". I wish I had known from the first day that I could wait until the Blue show's start time, then go in and sit in open seats, if something I wanted to do conflicted with my Red show time.
The ship: The NCL Jade is a nice ship, although it's not a ship for kids. That said, since the Star Trek cruise was mostly 13+ (with a few young uns grandfathered in from the single day they opened for 6+, or because they're the family of the celebs), I didn't experience any problems from the minors aboard. The ones I did see seemed very well behaved and interested in Star Trek, so the lack of things to do for children had no effect on the cruise. The outdoor pools are unheated, so most folks were in the hot tubs. The food was all right, nothing special. The buffet coffee was ashtray flavor, but it was fine in the dining rooms and restaurants. So if I hated the coffee at the buffet breakfast, I simply moseyed on to Finnegan's (O'Sheehan's renamed) or the Grand Pacific and got coffee there. My cabin steward was friendly and accommodating. Just about all the ship facilities were clean and inviting. The stateroom was nice, and the TV in the stateroom showed Star Trek episodes and movies on various channels
The basic events: These took place on sea days, or after 4pm on port days. The schedule was jam packed. I found myself wishing we could have afforded the time and money to go on both cruises, as we could have then been able to attend most of what we wanted. These included Rick Searfoss (real astronaut) and Phil Plait (actual astronomer) speaking about real science matters, Lolita Fatjo speaking about scripts and behind-the-scenes stuff, Q&A panels with the cast of TNG, DS9 and VOY, some fun script readings, a women's view panel with all the female actors, makeup sessions, writer's workshops with Robb Perlman, Karaoke (some nights hosted by the celebs), and various small performances that the celebs choose to do. There were "ship building" competitions, tribble toss, Gorn Gong Show, Poker (extra fee) with Jeffrey Combs, pub crawl (extra fee) with Robert O'Reilly (Gowron), and wine tasting (extra fee) with Casey Biggs (Damar).
The big show: Each night, 1-3 celebs would put on a show, 2 times per night, at 6pm for the early show or 9pm for the late show. George Takei and Brent Spiner swapped, so that they weren't doing 2 shows in a single day, but all the others were the same show repeated the same day. LeVar Burton talked about Reading Rainbow. Nana Visitor and Rene Auberjonois did some readings (I missed the first night). Denise Crosby did Interstellar Improv, which was great She, Robert Picardo and Rene Auberjonois (there might have been a 4th there, but I forget at the moment) did a showing of TOS: The Way To Eden, with no sound, and they provided an impromptu script that was hilarious. George Takei spoke about his life and Brent Spiner did lots of show tunes (which people didn't seem to like). Robert Picardo and his friend Jordan Bennett also did show tune/story stuff, which, again, people didn't seem to like, although Jordan Bennett has an absolutely amazing voice. One night, they had Star Trek Squares, which was a Hollywood Squares thing that was amusing enough, but only had 4 actual celebrities and Jonathan Frakes seemed fairly put out to have been in it. (To be fair, Frakes wound up having to sit in last minute for other stars who fell ill. Spiner, Auberjonois, Picardo and Urban all got sick, either before or during the cruise.)
The parties: Just about all the parties were fun, or seemed fun, but I'm in my 50s and didn't last past midnight on most nights.
The celebs: Photo and autograph sessions were snaking lines and confusion, for the most part, but the celebs themselves seemed in decent spirits. Some, like Denise Crosby, were friendly and open. Others were more aloof, although I couldn't tell, since if I saw an aloof, I didn't bother them. I don't know about how it was up in The Haven area (where most of the stars were), but if you were in a normal cabin, you could probably go the whole cruise without bumping into any stars. I mostly bumped into Casey Biggs, Ethan Phillips and Vaughn Armstrong, who had penthouses on the 11th deck. Except for one night where he introduced someone, I never saw LeVar Burton around the ship.
The other passengers: In the whole week, I didn't meet anyone I didn't like. Everyone was friendly, supportive, fun and interesting and I considered it the highlight of the cruise to meet all these other Trekkies/Trekkers, from all countries and cultures, who all came together for this.
The value: Now, given that a similar 7 day cruise on the Jade to the Western Caribbean would have been $2900 less for our cabin type, was the Star Trek Cruise worth the extra $2900 we spent? Would that money have been better spent by going to a land-based Star Trek convention? For my husband, who hates being on boats, the answer was yes. This was fun to do, but not a great value. For me, I like cruising and I like conventions, so it was like having a moving convention. We certainly can't do it every year, especially if they don't have price drops like this year.