• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 1x08 - "Broken Pieces"

Rate Episode 1x08 "Broken Pieces"

  • 10 - Fenris Rangers

    Votes: 57 24.1%
  • 9

    Votes: 94 39.7%
  • 8

    Votes: 48 20.3%
  • 7

    Votes: 19 8.0%
  • 6

    Votes: 8 3.4%
  • 5

    Votes: 6 2.5%
  • 4

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • 3

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • 2

    Votes: 1 0.4%
  • 1 - Power Rangers

    Votes: 2 0.8%

  • Total voters
    237
I was right about the android apocalypse vision being from the ancient past. Everyone else thought it was from the future! :nyah:

Kor
Maybe a time traveler from the future went back 200,000 years and destroyed the Tkon Empire?

Never discount time travel in Trek, its insidious and gets everywhere.
 
Oh ignore me I'm watching an entirely different series. Last week I made a similar listening error with something. :techman:

Whatever show I'm watching, I'm enjoying. It doesn't help that I've had the sound turned down on the TV when my husband is in bed still, or gone to bed at night.
Bluetooth Headphones make for a happy marriage.
And they aren't all that expensive anymore. :techman:
 
Control was a lousy idea in DSC and would be even worse if revived in any form in PIC. Just leave that idiotic plot in the same bin with the parasite infestation from Season 1 of TNG and the Kazon being developed as the main bad guys of VOY.
IDK, This most recent episode pretty much revealed an 'idiotic plot' for STP. Another problem I just realized is that Picard didn't even mention the fact that Commodore Oh is Romulan plant. And he has all the evidence he needs to prove it with Dr Jurati; but no, not a single word about her; just a tableslapping in celebration that He's "right".
 
I wonder if Seven could become Queen and stop/free/change the Borg?
She'd become queen of a nicer, better Borg that politely asks people if they'd like to be assimilated. Turn the Borg into an all volunteer collective where drones can join and leave as desired.
 
IDK, This most recent episode pretty much revealed an 'idiotic plot' for STP. Another problem I just realized is that Picard didn't even mention the fact that Commodore Oh is Romulan plant. And he has all the evidence he needs to prove it with Dr Jurati; but no, not a single word about her; just a tableslapping in celebration that He's "right".
Wait, a part of this conversation took place off-screen, right? Otherwise, why should Clancy be willing to send a squadron? So yeah, I hope he told her about Oh.

I've been very positive about this episode, but of course I do have some nitpicks and misgivings. I'll post them after my second viewing, when my (what I hope is a) cold/ flu is better.
 
She'd become queen of a nicer, better Borg that politely asks people if they'd like to be assimilated. Turn the Borg into an all volunteer collective where drones can join and leave as desired.
Would be kinda like Brainiac 5.
 
"Someone shows up," similar to how the Vulcans showed up to cause First Contact at Cochrane's first warp ship. So is synthetic life the problem, or just the bait that invites the problem?

Elnor seemed a little naive, "Are you going to assimilate me now?" He was curious, and also mostly expecting it. And Seven's black eyes was a cool effect, even if we've never seen it before. I like that they made her character say, "And... I'm not sure I'd want to release them." She knows what temptation means. (And so did Data... for 0.68 seconds)
Oh, and so, spaced Borg, they'd be able to live for a bit in space, but if you're just floating, you're not really contributing to much. Just more pre-warp-jump ejected trash flotsam (sorry, wrong fandom).

Oh is half-Vulcan, and half-Romulan. What does that even mean...

And why do the Borg just abandon a huge, useful ship?! Do they have so many they just don't care about this one, like a once-used tissue? Eh, I've got a whole box of 'em, half a booger so throw this one away. One freakin' ex-Borg just activates the ship and scares off the **** Rommies with only one minor, unrelated skirmish beforehand. Wish we saw somebody scratching out that sign, "5438 days without an assimilation" before dashing to an escape pod.

Also, the Romulans reported right at the end that they have found the homeworld? Really? Even our characters haven't! They are heading there, which isn't quite the same as "finding" it. Maybe I'm just being pedantic. So while they were saying that, all the Romulan ships were leaving the Artifact. Borg Cubes in the middle of the boot-up sequence ("Please wait... installing updates" must really suck at that scale) are really scary.

I appreciated Picard's not knowing how to operate the ship. He's Starfleet (which is why he wants to depend on a larger group; being a team player is important to the survival of a species like ours), and this ship is not Starfleet, and also customized out the wazoo by Rios. The different psyche components (apologies to Freud's mere 3) in the holos was great.

I like the general backstory, like Rios on his ship, and the poor dude who was stuck between a rock and a hard place. Follow shady orders and [not] live with the guilt, or let your whole crew die. That his back story ties in with $PLOT_OF_THE_DAY is a little disappointing. At least one of these people has a life outside of this plot: Raffi and her estranged son. (Well, she is the estranged one.)

@Gonzo https://www.trekbbs.com/threads/star-trek-picard-1x08-broken-pieces.303359/page-15#post-13309054, she wears sun
glasses because it gives her a sense of Security to wear them.

Picard had some very touching and inspiring statements in his conversation with Soji 3/4 of the way through.

 
Wait, a part of this conversation took place off-screen, right? Otherwise, why should Clancy be willing to send a squadron? So yeah, I hope he told her about Oh.

That conversation happens before Jurati wakes up, so I don't think he could have talked about Oh's involvement at that time. The working hypothesis was that Jurati herself was a Romulan agent. Kinda true, but not in the way they thought.

Having said that, I'm not sure why anyone would think that they haven't or won't send Starfleet word about this. I imagine we'll find out next week.
 
And we're given a reason why the Borg seem to be keeping their bald, wired up heads down on the galactic stage, despite carrying on after "Endgame" with their next generation of cube vessels:

they gleaned disturbing info from that Romulan woman, that would drive normal drones similarly crazed or suicidal, so the Borg Queens kept it to themselves (because they too are cosmic horrors) and withdrew all their forces back to the Delta Quadrant, to bunker down, and prep for the impending extra galactic threat!
 
@ Rom's Sehlat: the working hypothesis about the Borg is that the collective rejects cubes which contain toxic data and thought processes. That's how Hugh and company got free, remember. Apparently the Admonition is as toxic as free will.
 
Is this Star Trek: Picard or Star Trek: Rio? We're seeing more of him and his boring/irritating holograms in this series than of Picard. Also, they need to stop it with the manual interaction with the 3-D controls; grabbing, rotating, etc. It looks fake. I mean like "actor: pretend to be moving some object around in front of you. CGI the object in later. Doesn't look realistic at all." kind of fake, as expected I suppose! :D
 
Nothing we see in Voyager suggests an out-of-the-box Picardo would fail to report a murder and you conveniently ignored the second part of my argument involving common sense which would only grow more obvious the longer EMHs exist.
In early Voyager the doctor wasn’t able to turn himself on and off. That had to be added to his program. So no, he couldn’t report a murder until he was manually turned on again. In Picard, we’ve only see the La Sirena EMH turn on when the computer detects a possible emergency. Meaning he probably doesn’t heave full control over his activation like the Doctor was given.
One regret I have about this series is that The Doctor isn't involved. He is a synthetic lifeform. A completely different kind of synthetic lifeform, but one nonetheless.
Well Robert Picardo said his agent was contacted about a possible season 2 appearance.
 
I love that we’re being made feel sorry for one of the most fierce enemies in Trek history!
I didn't feel sorry for them at all. Good riddance! Now it's just Annika, Elnor and maybe half a dozen xBs running the Borg Cube for the good guys, with no pesky drones to get in the way.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top