If Archer gave her that coffee black, I can understand her reaction. I hate black coffee! But add two cream and two sugars and I love it. Tea, on the other hand
must be drunk black with just a single sugar.
OK, so Henry got killed or seriously hurt testing his warp engine on the ringship
Enterprise, and Jon blames the Vulcans. Unless the Vulcans actually sabotaged the ship it still seems childish to me. After all, it's been a good 30 years. To still be sad at the anniversary is understandable. To still be acting like a 12-year-old about it, isn't.
Yes, the anger can be there, and even come out on occasion. But not on duty and especially not in front of the crew. There's an old saying in the service -
Praise in public, punish in private - I may not have the words exactly right, but it basically means you never dress down a subordinate in front of their subordininates. Doing so destroys that officer's authority. I was only in Air Force ROTC but my instructors drilled that into us constantly, and they always practiced it as well. A few of my friends have also served in other branches - three in the Army (one a corpsman and two officers, a Captain and a 1st Lieutenant, the latter a combat veteran) and the last in the Navy as a PO 1st class aboard an SSN. All have confirmed that this is how their branches handled it as well. And what's more, any officer that violated that rule as constantly as Archer has, vis-a-vis T'Pol, would be in serious trouble and would probably have to explain himself to a review board.
Frankly I'm afraid that you've written yourself into a corner here. The only way to continue with him in command of
Enterprise is to do exactly what B&B have always done, give him a free pass - He's the Hero, so there are no consequences no matter how badly he screws up. The only way that I can see to leave him in command is to leave him on the other side of that wormhole long enough for him to straighten up and learn to fly right, and even then he's going to have to pull off some kind of minor miracle to get himself out of the hole he's dug for himself.
I'm sorry CX. I generally like
Foundations, but I think
Soli was a giant step backwards.
