• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Trek Episodes That Were Never Made

Harvey

Admiral
Admiral
I posted about this in the Fact Check thread, but I figured it was interesting enough to warrant its own discussion.

@Maurice and I have been doing a ton of research lately looking through reams of paperwork from the original Star Trek. Some of the most interesting material — and I don't necessarily mean to use that as a synonym for "good," since some of this stuff is just dreadful — are the story outlines and scripts written for episodes that were never made.

Some of this stuff has long-circulated at conventions or has become well-known via making-of books, but outside of an archival setting, much of it has never been seen. Even Cushman's books give a lot of this stuff short shrift.

Anyway, I wrote the following article with @Maurice covering ten of those unmade Treks, doing my best to excerpt as much behind-the-scenes material as possible given the limitations of where it was published. I'd love to hear what people think — and also, more generally, discuss these and other stories that were never filmed. (Someone in the comments on What Culture claims to have read Darlene Hartman's spec script "Shun-Daki" and called it "racist and embarrassing" ... so now I definitely want to read that, if anyone here has it.)

https://whatculture.com/tv/10-star-trek-the-original-series-episodes-that-were-almost-made
 
:)

episode02.jpg


episode03.jpg


episode04.jpg


episode05.jpg


episode06.jpg


episode07.jpg


episode08.jpg


episode10.jpg


(Just messin' around with my 1/350 E model :) )
 
I would have loved to have seen some of these bypassed episodes produced. I mean, could they have been worse than some of the 3rd season klunkers? Maybe that’s a rhetorical question....
 
Dolinsky be damned! :lol: No I'm joking as I've seen other shows written by Meyer! apparently Vikor for The Invaders was his written under his pseudonym of Michael Adams and that is a great episode along with ZZZZZ, O.B.I.T. and Architects of Fear for The Outer Limits all of which were good but in my opinion he made a boo-boo with Trek! :shifty:
JB
 
The whole concept of The Architects of Fear is grotesquely chilling, made most effective by the very little seeing of the transformation, which was largely left to our imagination until the end. Worryingly, the warped philosophy of those scientists is probably as polemical today, if not raised higher. That and the Zanti Misfits, are my top OL episodes.
 
Some of those pitched ideas actually sound better than some of the shit produced
It would have been interesting to see "The Joy Machine" for instance
Great work by the two investigators involved in the paper trail
 
I read The Joy Machine when it was published as a book. It was rather meh. Same with one of David Gerrold’s unproduced story ideas: The Galactic Whirlpool.
 
Last edited:
The most common complaint from the producers seems to have been too much dialog, not enough actual plot or involvement from the heroes. I can think of a lot of fan film episodes that suffer from the exact same issues.
 
The most common complaint from the producers seems to have been too much dialog, not enough actual plot or involvement from the heroes.

IIRC, Bob Justman also made those complaints about Let That Be Your Last Battlefield. Too much talky-talky. Boring.
 
I read The Joy Machine when it was published as a book. It was rather meh. Same with one of David Gerrold’s unproduced story ideas: The Galactic Whirlpool.

Are there any other classic Trek novels that were retooled from ideas originally written for the live action show?

I know "The Entropy Effect" was based on a screenplay Vonda N. McIntyre had written on spec while the show was still on the air, but she never submitted it to the show.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top