Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 3x02 - "Far From Home"

[Cyrus]

I finally saw this episode. It was OK.

They writers knew the episode starts with Discovery crash landing on a planet and end with Burnham on the view screen. So they just had to fill the rest with Discovery crew having some adventure on the planet. What they came up with was very uninteresting. The production values were great as usual and Iceland location was fabulous but the story wasn't that good.

Saru was great as the captain.

Nhan is now one of the regular characters,with the actress listed in the opening credits.

 

[Phoenix219]

Star Trek: The Wrath of Zareh

Zareh: I never forget a face, Miss... Tilly. Isn't it? I never thought to see your face again.

Book: Tilly, who is this man?

Tilly: A criminal, Book, ...a product of post-Burn corruption.

Zareh: You didn't expect to find me alive. Allow me to reintroduce you to Coridan Colony's only remaining indigenous lifeform. Parasitic ice. You see it enters through the ears ...and wraps itself around the cerebral cortex. This has the effect of rendering the victim extremely susceptible to suggestion. Later, ...it grows, ...follows madness. ...And death.

Tilly: Zareh, listen to me! Saru was only doing his duty!

Book: No! No!

(Zareh grabs both Book's and Tilly's heads and shove them into the snow)

Tilly/Book: (screams of pain. When they are pulled out, they have blank looks on their faces)

Zareh: That's better! Now tell me ...why you are here? ...And tell me where I may find Saru.

That...... is AMAZING.

 

[Candlicious Ghost]

Reno is becoming one of my favourites. I love her snarkiness. Always loved the Empress and am very glad that Detmer is getting more to do then just sit there and push buttons.

 

[hbquikcomjamesl]

I liked it. And I'm glad I saw it before I got past the prologue of Wonderlands.

There seem to be some rather sadistic people in the 32nd Century, though.

Not especially fond of the Empress, but I definitely like Detmer and Reno. I wonder what's eating Detmer, though.

Given the title, I half-expected to see Pakleds.

Hmm. Two episodes into the season, already an episode depicting a particularly sadistic bad guy, in a way that's quite visceral, and yet so far, no direct invocations of the "eye scream" trope, beyond a couple of corpses. I stand by my assertion that the use of that trope in Icheb's torture scene at the begining of PIC:"Stardust City Rag," and Leland's booby trap scene in DSC:"The Red Angel" were entirely gratuitous.
(If the eyes of a cadaver are gouged out with no sentient witnesses, is it still ? -- the Eye Scream Koan)

 

[Candlicious Ghost]

Icheb's death was pointless

 

[fireproof78]

Worked well enough.

 

[F. King Daniel]

Icheb's death was pointless

How can it be pointless? It was Seven's entire motivation for the episode.

 

[Quinton]

How can it be pointless? It was Seven's entire motivation for the episode.

I was just about to say the same thing.

 

[hbquikcomjamesl]

The in-universe pointlessness of Icheb's torture and death was the point in terms of storytelling, and in terms of Seven's motivation.

That said, the invocation of the eye-scream trope was an unnecessary and counterproductive shortcut towards achieving the goal of giving Seven a motivation and establishing the ruthlessness, sadism, and general depravity of the episode's "big bad."

I'm reminded of the even more gratuitous eye-scream in Never Say Never Again. (After seeing the picture, I immediately said "Never again"; I prefer the Moore Bond and the Dalton Bond to the Connery Bond anyway.*) If it weren't such a gross-out moment, going to all that trouble to fool an eye-scanner would be the kind of ludicrous long-way-around sort of thing that you'd expect to see in an episode of Get Smart, rather than a Bond movie.

_____
* I have a friend who claims to prefer the Lazenby Bond.