• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Shore Leave Indoors

Spock's Barber

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Shore Leave is one of my favorite 1st season episodes. The fantasy aspect, plus the action and adventure are what intrigues me, not to mention the outdoor shooting locations. Quite a few of TOS later episodes resorted to indoor studio shooting for alien planets, sometimes because of budget limitations. Do you think Shore Leave would have been a lesser quality episode if the director was forced to shoot all scenes indoors?
 
Agreed. I'm glad Shore Leave wasn't filmed during the low budget 3rd season. The fresh outdoors is where it belonged, just like Paradise Syndrome.
 
Shore Leave, This Side of Paradise, and The Paradise Syndrome all benefit hugely from shooting in sunny "nature" locations. I can't imagine they'd be anywhere near as good indoors.

Yes. The studio planet sets for Man Trap, By Any Other Name, Amok Time, et. al. are impressive works by Matt Jefferies, but in the back of my mind I have to ignore the fake light, fake grass, fake rocks, etc.
 
I'd add to the list "Operation: Annihilate", an otherwise middle-of-the-road episode that benefitted hugely from the location shooting. The outdoor scenes themselves were short, but it gave the show a richness and quality lacking in, say, "Taste of Armageddon",
 
Amok Time filmed in Nevada or New Mexico would have been fantastic, and would have bankrupted the show.
 
Yes. The studio planet sets for Man Trap, By Any Other Name, Amok Time, et. al. are impressive works by Matt Jefferies, but in the back of my mind I have to ignore the fake light, fake grass, fake rocks, etc.
At least Star Trek's planet sets were supposed to look otherworldly. The fakery of an exterior set on a soundstage is even more noticeable if it's something we're all familiar with, like a section of forest or a suburban backyard.

I mean, does this look outdoors to you?

1707060252000114.jpg



Amok Time filmed in Nevada or New Mexico would have been fantastic, and would have bankrupted the show.
You know what they used to say: "A rock is a rock, a tree is a tree. Shoot it in Griffith Park."
 
The first episode to be partially filmed at Vasquez was "Shore Leave" (in which it depicted the Shore Leave Planet along with Africa, USA), spending two and half days on location, on Monday 24 October 1966, Tuesday 25 October 1966 and Wednesday 26 October 1966. In the next month, another two Star Trek episodes were shot there, "Arena", spending two days at Vasquez, on Wednesday 9 November 1966 and Thursday 10 November 1966, and "The Alternative Factor". The latter also spent two days filming on location, on Tuesday 22 November 1966 and Wednesday 23 November 1966. Star Trek returned to Vasquez for the second season, to film "Friday's Child", which also spent two days on location, on Wednesday 24 May 1967 and Thursday 25 May 1967.

Vasquez was seen again almost twenty years later in Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, when some of the Vulcanscenes were filmed there. Three years later, in August 1989, the Next Generation episode "Who Watches The Watchers" was also located at Vasquez. Star Trek: Voyager also filmed scenes at Vasquez, including the barren moon surface for "Initiations" in July 1995 and the desert for "Gravity" in September 1998.

Director J.J. Abrams shot the Vulcan scenes of 2009's Star Trek at Vasquez Rocks as an homage to its use in previous Trek productions. [1]

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Vasquez_Rocks

I don't think AT or Man Trap suffered from being on a sound stage. In fact, I really like how Man Trap looks. On the other hand, I think By Any Other Name suffers terribly from being on a stage. I think it has to do with the amount of screen time set outdoors.

Alternative Factor was shot at Vasquez? What a terrible waste of money and an outdoor location.
 
"The Alternative Factor" was a waste of production time, film stock, and typewriter ink.

It's not my favorite episode either. Too disjointed, too confusing at times. The story premise is okay. I think the director, Gerd Oswald, just didn't turn in a quality episode, which may explain why he wasn't invited back to TOS.
 
If every alien planet landscape were actually filmed outdoors, we would all be complaining that every alien planet looks exactly like earth. I can't imagine something like the Guardian scenes from COTEOF being filmed on location, for example, that set was perfect.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top