• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

SF/F Books: Chapter Two - What Are You Reading?

Just finished reading Robert Silverberg's "Starborne". To be honest, I had no idea what this was going to be like since I hadn't heard of or didn't know anything about the book or the author for matter. It was a loan from a friend.

I'm not really sure what to think of it. It felt a bit underwhelming somehow. I think part of the problem might be that it's rather short. And as a consequence, character building but also plot building seem a little on the thin side. Also, the revelation towards the end as well as the conclusion feel somewhat quick and easy to me.

Also, I found none of the characters really engaging. Apart from some rather foolish decisions (Planet B landing comes to mind) I have to wonder about the planning of the entire mission. The crew is just SO dumb-founded when the first year has passed and they need a new year captain. Also, how come there is like NOBODY in sight who could possibly replace him? Do they do no planning at all? This might be connected to what human society has become in that future, but I still found it rather hard to swallow.

Overall, well, underwhelmed best describes my feelings toward the book. A fairly pleasant read but not much more for me, personally.
 
Silverberg's written a lot of stuff, some of it thoughtful and classic stuff, some of it great entertainment, and (early in his career) some of it quickly churned out pulp. His most popular books are probably Lord Valentine's Castle and its sequels.

I hadn't heard of this book, to be honest, but given the length and breadth of Silverberg's career, it's entirely possible that there are other books of his you might like more. I certainly wouldn't dismiss him based on one book.
 
Silverberg's written a lot of stuff, some of it thoughtful and classic stuff, some of it great entertainment, and (early in his career) some of it quickly churned out pulp. His most popular books are probably Lord Valentine's Castle and its sequels.

I hadn't heard of this book, to be honest, but given the length and breadth of Silverberg's career, it's entirely possible that there are other books of his you might like more. I certainly wouldn't dismiss him based on one book.

I agree-I've read a dozen or more books by him and some have left me feeling "Bleh!" while others have been stunning. The Madjipoor Chronicles were quite good, as I recall. You really need to find a "Best 20th century Sci-fi" site and look up his titles there-I guarantee he'll have a couple.
 
Thanks for the hints on Silverberg, Steve Roby and Mistral. And, no worry, I haven't given up on him ;). It's not like I found the book awful or anything. And I can't certainly imagine that other works of his are more engaging (for me, anyway) given what he's credited with.
 
Currently reading the Soul Drinkers omnibus by Ben Counter, Warhammer 40k Space Marines gotta love it, talk about a dark and grim future,,,
 
Finished Star Wars - Millenium Falcon, quite a god book and had to re-read the end of the last book in The Legacy Of The Force series before reading this continuation
 
I'm 150 pages from the end of Stephen Lawhead's historical fantasy Byzantium, the story of a pre-Schism Irish monk designated to accompany a manuscript to Contantinople and his various trials and experiences along the way as he is kidnapped from his friends by Danes, accompanies them on a quest for the Emperor, and finds love in Arabia.

800 pages of cool stuff. Like D&D, only without the (2nd) D.
 
Right now I'm reading Fast Forward 2, an anthology of original short sf. I'm partway through the first story, which is by Paul Cornell-- the reason I bought the book.
Finally finished this. A decent mix of stories: some good, some all right, some dull. Nothing terrible, though a few were somewhat unsubstantial. I'll probably write up a more in-depth review later this month.

For an unthemed anthology, there sure were a lot of near-future stories about an Earth on the brink of environmental collapse.
 
That was 870 enjoyable pages. I'm exhausted from it. Not sure I'll start a new book today, nor am I sure what's next, the final Fleming Bond book -- The Man With The Golden Gun, Gaiman's Graveyard Book, or something else.
 
While I had been planning to get to it pretty soon, the premier of Legend of the Seeker kick-started my interest in starting the Sword of Truth series by Terry Goodkind. I'm now about 230 pages into Wizard's First Rule.
 
Even if I hadn't burned out on epic fantasy series years ago, just reading an interview with Terry Goodkind like this one would dissuade me.

So. I just finished Dead Romance by Lawrence Miles. It's a remarkable book, a book that stands apart -- way apart -- from the other books out there about Doctor Who, Bernice Summerfield, Faction Paradox, etc. It's not even an official Doctor Who tie-in, but then it could never be published as one. Instead, it draws on elements from the New Adventures series, which was allowed to carry on without Doctor Who TV elements when Virgin Books lost the licence, and from Miles's books in the BBC Books Doctor Who line. But it also features Time Lords, Daleks, Gallifrey, and other DW elements; they're just not referred to by their proper names.

Imagine a universe in a bottle created by the Time Lords. Imagine being a human on Earth and finding out you're not on the real Earth, you're in a recreated Earth inside the bottle, and you're not necesarily who you think you are, either.

The events of the story are epic, but the perspective is from someone who doesn't really understand everything that's happening, and keeps learning that there are more things about her world and herself she didn't know, shifting her perspective on a regular basis.

Dead Romance doesn't even feature Bernice Summerfield as a character, although she's mentioned several times. It's a book that in many ways stands alone, but it can't be read in isolation, because it draws so much from a lot of related novels. It's the kind of book that makes you want to tell people, read this, it's really different -- but you have to be familiar with the Doctor Who New Adventures, the Bernice Summerfield New Adventures, and the Eighth Doctor Adventures. Figuring out what you have to read before reading Articles of the Federation or Destiny? Much, much easier.

(FWIW, I read the New Adventures version of Dead Romance. I also have the slightly revised version published by Mad Norwegian alongside its Faction Paradox line, and I'll read that one eventually.)

Boy, I'm glad I didn't wait any longer to get into reading Doctor Who books than I did.
 
^ Dead Romance is fabulous. I need to read it again because I had no idea what was going on, though. I have the MNP version, which as I'm sure you know, has a couple bonus short stories.
 
Yeah, Dead Romance is easily Miles's best novel; instead of the balance of strengths and weaknesses that characterizes his Who work, it's just well done on every level. It's also one of those books that makes for really satisfying rereading, because you can see all the foreshadowing of the final twist. I think it can safely be read in isolation, actually; there are subtle connections people would miss, but they'd still get the brilliant science fiction story at the heart of it. Certainly I hadn't read anything more than a couple other Who books before I first read it. [Edit: actually that may be a lie. I can't remember whether I read it when I first bought it or later on.]

Talking of Who books, I've almost cleared up a backlog of library books (including the thread-relevant Divided Kingdom by Rupert Thomson, a weird dystopian novel where the UK has been divided into four smaller nations based on the humours-- decent stuff) and am about to get back into the New Adventures with Conundrum.
 
Last edited:
While I had been planning to get to it pretty soon, the premier of Legend of the Seeker kick-started my interest in starting the Sword of Truth series by Terry Goodkind. I'm now about 230 pages into Wizard's First Rule.


The first couple are fine, then goodkind starts to forget that he's writing a novel and not a political manifesto and it turns into a (boring) train wreck.
 
I remember liking Vornholt's work on Masks. I don't know if he changed or I did, but I found his last few Trek novels almost unreadable, especially the first two A Time To... novels.

It's so good to hear about someone having the same feelings.

I loved TNG Masks back in the day (although I still only have read the german translation of the book) but found (not only the two first titles) of the "A time to..." series unreadable as well.

I have now picked up the destiny books from David Mack and started of with Star Trek Vanguard in it's german translation.
 
Here's my review of the stories in Lou Anders's new anthology of all-original sf, Fast Forward 2:

"Catherine Drewe" by Paul Cornell
Despite it being what drew me to this book, I was actually somewhat underwhelmed by Paul Cornell's contribution. Not to say that it was bad. But it was sort of insubstantial, really-- Jonathan Hamilton of British intelligence infiltrates a mercenary gang on Mars to stop the Russians from gaining hold of a piece of alien technology. It's a bit consciously James Bond, and Cornell plans to turn it into a series, apparently; story #2 will be appearing in the forthcoming Solaris Book of New Science Fiction, Volume 3. But despite Cornell's usual mixture of deft characterization and fun antics, I find it hard to get very excited about another Hamilton story. (I'll buy the book anyway, though.)

"Cyto Couture" by Kay Kenyon
This is fun little story about a genetically mis-engineered child working in a factory that grows clothes from plants. Enjoyable.

"The Sun Also Explodes" by Chris Nakashima-Brown
Another story about genetic engineering, and it won't be the last. There's some interesting ideas in it, but none of the characters ever really interested me.

"The Kindness of Strangers" by Nancy Kress
Aliens destroy most of the world's major population centers yet do their best to assist the survivors. Why could this be happening? You won't really be surprised by the answer, and neither was I. These sort of better-than-you-primitives aliens who like lording over us were sort of done to death by Star Trek in the 1960s, you know? Except here, there's no getting out of the situation with a grand, moralistic gesture, just some empty nihilism. I'm pretty sure this same story turned up at least twice in Brian W. Aldiss's Galactic Empires collections, anyway.

"Alone with an Inconvenient Companion" by Jack Skillingstead
After reading this, I felt vaguely unsettled and unsure of the world around me-- which was exactly what Skillingstead was going for, I assume. Strange and really quite good.

"True Names" by Benjamin Rosenbaum and Cory Doctorow
The longest story in the book, I wasn't quite sure what had happened after I read it, because I didn't know what the protagonists were. Artificial intelligences? Memes? Post-singularity entities? Disembodies consciousnesses? Biological programs? Demiurge knows. But I enjoyed the story anyway. Whatever the protagonists actually are, they have a fascinating culture and way of life, one that Rosenbaum and Doctorow exploit to good effect. The characters are actually quite well drawn for entities of uncertain provenance, and there's some serious craziness going on at times to add to further enjoyment. Another good one.

"Molly's Kids" by Jack McDevitt
It's like McDevitt thought of a good problem for his characters, but he couldn't think of a solution. So he ends the story with the characters promising they'll think of a solution. And I don't understand why waning public support for a space probe would result in its launch being terminated mere minutes before its scheduled time. Surely by that point you've spent all the money; what would you gain? The characters themselves almost point this out, but no one ever answers it.

"Adventure" by Paul McAuley
At times this reads like a synopsis of a good story, but it comes together in the last few scenes, which make you realize that human existence will probably be just as meaningless and purposeless once we can live on other planets, and that growing up will still suck. Thumbs up.

"Not Quite Alone in the Dream Quarter" by Mike Resnick and Pat Cadigan
This one left me lukewarm. It's well-executed, but most of the ideas are a bit old hat, and I'm not sure that the spin the authors put on them is that different from what's gone before.

"An Eligible Boy" by Ian McDonald
A contender for my favorite of the collection, this is a story of Future India, 2047. The culture McDonald devises for the subcontinent in the mid-21st century is fascinating, and it makes a welcome break in a genre where the only country in the future always seems to be America. It's a great look at what these amazing technologies would do to society other than my own. The story's only flaw is that though the plot is quite good, it's wrapped up with some fairly humdrum stuff about two AIs falling in love, meaning that the story doesn't really live up to the potentials of its fascinating setting. Apparently McDonald's written a novel and several other short stories about this Future India; I'll certainly be checking them out.

"SeniorSource" by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
The entire story of this story turns out to be a distraction for the real story, which is brought up and resolved in one scene. Not so great.

"Mitigation" by Karl Schroeder and Tobias S. Buckell
This is a fun story about an environmental terrorist working for the Russian mafia who's not quite the player that he thinks he is.

"Long Eyes" by Jeff Carlson
A story about an intelligent spaceship with a human brain in it feels like it should be old hat, but it really works in Carlson's hands for some reason, probably the good characterization of the spaceship itself.

"The Gambler" by Paolo Bacigalupi
A sweet little story about an ex-Laos journalist, and his attempt to change a world that increasingly doesn't care about the kind of stories he has to offer. A little simplistic and preachy perhaps, but still effective because it feels all too plausible.

I didn't really hate anything in this book-- even the worst stories just left be disinterested more than anything else-- but I didn't really love anything, either, though several of the stories were quite good. Oh, and for an ostensibly unthemed anthology, there sure were a lot of stories about a future Earth with its ecology either on the verge of collapse or already collapsed. Maybe that happened because it's what's actually going to happen, but it got a little tiring after a while. Overall, a fine enough anthology, but I wish that it had provided a little bit more bang.


Now I'm catching up on my tie-in reading with Star Wars: Darth Bane: Rule of Two: A Novel of the Old Republic, or as I like to call it for short, SW: DB:RoT:aNotOR.
 
Hmm. "Rotanotor". Rather rolls off the tongue. :p

I had picked up Bradbury's The Illustrated Man, but while I still like Bradbury and enjoy his stories, I've also started realizing that he's one of those authors whose writing style needs to be taken by me in small doses, rather like an extremely rich wedding cake. So I've moved on to Dickens. Go figure.
 
Finally completed the Bernice Summerfield New Adventures. The books that follow Dead Romance really don't reach that level; in fact, the last handful of books is as inconsistent as the series as a whole, but more than good enough overall to make me glad I decided to buy them. I'll wait a while before I start the Big Finish Bernice Summerfield series, I think.

Also read one of the Doctor Who Short Trips Christmas anthologies. A few good stories there.

So... what to read today? I'm tempted to read something Lovecrafty. I started reading Lovecraft around Christmas of 1979, and around Christmas I often think about Lovecraft and reread "The Festival," but I did that a few days ago...
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top