• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

News Seth MacFarlane’s The Orville

Yep.

Having a female child or being born female is such a source of intense shame to these folks that not many are going around comparing notes or collecting data.
 
I enjoyed "About a Girl", so did my wife and son. I hope The Orville sticks around for a while, I'm really enjoying it.
 
When the old woman came in at the end, anyone expect her to say "Being female sucks! Give her the operations!"????

After they didn't go the expected route of "entire colony of females" or "half the population is female in hiding" I was totally expecting that as the twist.... a life time secluded in a cave alone? Was definitely expecting a comedic backfiring of sorts, and I was half expecting the same....


On such an overly developed and industrialized planet, where did she find her secluded cave, anyway?
 
As much as I didn't buy the Rudolph Epiphany, I got a great laugh out of Bortus' "Of course - if Rudolph had been euthanized as his father wished..." and Gordon and John's "Uh, I don't think that was ever the plan..."
Maybe that helps to sell the Rudolph Epiphany as that could be used to rationalize that Bortus was filtering the story through his own culture and nature and thus may be more emotionally affected. That, and the beers. :)

Of course, IMO Rudolph is a great tale on its own and doesn't need any extra explanation. ;)
 
Think a little deeper. Isn't that what Star Trek storytelling itself represents? I mean, here we are having an issue discussion about gender because of...a goofy TV show. How is that any different from the Rudolph special other than the age demographic? Yes, it's really pretentious, but it runs to the core of Star Trek. Bortus could very well have been watching Let That Be Your Last Battlefield. So The Orville went highly post-modern and meta that way. I don't think it trivializes things at all because we really do take media that seriously, at least when we decide to get outraged about it (Gay Sulu, Gal Gadot armpits, all-female alamo drafthouse screenings, James Cameron dustup, etc...)
You missed the point. I already said in this thread that this was very much like watching a TNG that I had somehow missed. My point with Rudolf is that the humor and drama didn't mix together well in this case. The humor interfered with the drama. Agreed that this would've worked as a typical TNG episode.
 
As much as I didn't buy the Rudolph Epiphany, I got a great laugh out of Bortus' "Of course - if Rudolph had been euthanized as his father wished..." and Gordon and John's "Uh, I don't think that was ever the plan..."
Woot! We agree on something! :techman:
 
I think this episode did what good sci-fi does and it gets people talking about issue's. It doesn't have to provide answers only questions. It also offers insight on a new alien culture that I think we will be seeing again and new insight on one of your series regulars. I for one hopes the show does more of this and doesn't just settle on being a comedy. PLus we kind of forget that TNG and most of Trek was kind of able to tell different type of stories. Next week might be a horror episode and the following week a mystery story. I've head Macfarlane talk about how he liked that about TNG in that they could tell any kind of stories they wanted which is also something you see on "Family Guy." Sometimes they do sci-fi and then they do one with Peter and his friends and then you got one about the family and so forth.

Jason
 
:brickwall: :brickwall: :brickwall: :brickwall: :brickwall: :ack:

"I have laid an egg".

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

That's "Heveena" 25 years ago.

She has some strong opinions about eggs.

HA!

In Star Wars Attack of the clones, playing one of those giraffe necked Kaminos, Rena cloned the dude beating her in that clip above, and sold millions of him into slavery to the Old Republic to be murdered by battle droids.

Did you really have to post that?
 
Backstory matters. Come on. Yours is a real-life beat the shit out of a female, the other is a Seth Farlane TNG wank.

CONTEXT.

Edit: And ignore me. Not my problem.

I took the clip down an hour ago.

If you're interested in context, here's an actual trailer.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top