• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Scotty; pull the plug

We often talk about the scifi shows that were ended before they should have been..Firefly for example. (for me it was MAX HEADROOM)

But can you think of scifi/action/fantasy shows that went on TOO long and should have been axed before they had time to grow?

Rob
Scorpio
 
Stargate without a doubt. The X-Files probably should have had a definitive ending in season seven but I enjoyed what came after it nonetheless.
 
As it stands, I could cheerfully lose Space: 1999 series 2. However, if they'd continued the showin the style and spirit of series 1, and not had such a disastrous re-vamp, I'd have liked it to run for years.
 
Another vote for Stargate.

Seaquest - first season was good, second... no. Third. BAD.

Sliders. It should have had a decent finale where they got home or something.
 
Sliders. It should have had a decent finale where they got home or something.

They did get home at one point, didn't they? They just didn't realise it. I think it was the episode where the gate at Quinn's home didn't squeak -- he wrongly took it as an indication that they were in a different reality. I kind of like to think of that as an ending -- it nearly allows me to obliterate the CroMag and film rip-off-of-the-week episodes from my memeory.

My vote, however, goes to Stargate.
 
Stargate SG-1 went on two years longer than it should have done.
24 has gone on about 4 years longer than it should have done.
 
Sliders. It should have had a decent finale where they got home or something.

Yep. As Deuterostome mentioned, they briefly made it home at the end of the season two premiere, "Into the Mystic"; but they were only on that world for a few seconds, and reading the newspaper made it seem like a parallel world because they couldn't believe Earth Prime would have changed that much (i.e. OJ Simpson on trial for murder).

Even as a large fan of Sliders, I think it should have ended after season two. Season three had a few good episodes, but the damage it did to the series outweighs those good episodes. For instance, the Sliders again made it home in season three's "The Exodus", but that eventually was the set-up for the Kromagg destruction of Earth Prime in season four.

Sliders was at its best when it took alternate views of history; that aspect is what made Sliders unique. Throwing in epic science fiction stories (such as the Kromagg war) was more of a gamble with the Sliders premise, and the gamble didn't pay off in my opinion.
 
This thread belongs in the "Stargate" forum.:devil:

Yep. Apart from that, The X Files (which should have ended after about season 5) and Buffy (which should have ended with season 5)


I'm in two minds about Buffy's end. Originally, first run, I'd have agreed with you. But rewatching it recently, I found lots of season 5, cringeworthy, at least in terms of its overall arc. The whole Glory arc was revealed too early, forcing the writers to make her incredibly dense to drag the story out, the ending makes no sense, and Weight of the World is inexcusable. Season 6, on the other hand, has risen in my estimations. They still handled Willows 'addiction' arc poorly - going with drug addiction metaphor rather than 'willow is a control freak', But overall, season 6 holds up well.
Granted, if we'd stopped with 5 we'd have been spared 7. So I can see arguments either way.
 
X-Files went on so long there was no sense of discovery and it just seemed up its own behind with conspiracy theory stuff, which made less sense the more we heard about it and was never the main draw of the series anyway. The leads were probably the biggest draw, and it probably should have ended before David Duchovny didn't want to be in most episodes.

Sliders definitely went on too long. What it became was just unrecognizable compared to the solid two-hour movie that kicked it off. Budget dropped, cast replaced with noname actors (sometimes awkwardly playing some version of the same characters), and all of it built on the same foundation: in way too many episodes, the device they need to "slide" gets taken away and they have to have a few low-budget shootouts or fistfights to get it back. The promise of the alternate Quinn appearing in the first episode, a character who appeared to basically slide for the hell of it, wasn't ever realized. Star Trek is proof that watching people explore for the sake of exploring can be interesting at least some (enough) of the time.
 
^^^But by running long, X-Files gave us 2 years of Annabeth Gish, so I never complain about it.:)
(from a practical standpoint, yes, it ran several years too long)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top