Ronald D. Moore Trek XI review

[jdp13]

Anyone know if Ronald D. Moore has a review of Star Trek XI posted anywhere? I'd like to hear his thoughts.

 

[Peter the Younger]

As someone who has listened to his podcasts, it probably goes something like, "So, what do I think about Star Trek..." (sound of zippo lighter, exhalation) "I liked it. But I think they should have made Spock a chick."

 

[jdp13]

As someone who has listened to his podcasts, it probably goes something like, "So, what do I think about Star Trek..." (sound of zippo lighter, exhalation) "I liked it. But I think they should have made Spock a chick."

Love those podcast. I had the same thought that he'd probably make Spock a chick .

 

[Borgminister]

He'd probably say it isn't the direction he would've taken it in, and that he's "evolved" beyond Star Trek.

 

[Trekker4747]

"It needed more darkness. More "reality." People should've watched that movie and wanted to blow their own brains out just for something interesting to do."

 

[stonester1]

"We're at the studios, so drink of choice is diet Coke. And the smoking lamp is off. So...JJ, think you know anal retentive crazy-mad fans stuck in the past? Lemme tell you, sir..."

 

[Dream]

Moore is pissed that the Romulans weren't changing their plans for the Federation every five minutes.

 

[Peter the Younger]

Moore is pissed that the Romulans weren't changing their plans for the Federation every five minutes.

Too true.

"We have a plan. That plan involves having a years-long dysfunctional cocktail party in space, and sex with humans, and convincing the humans that our plan is actually much more involved and complicated than this."

 

[stonester1]

"So...JJ...these crazy mad anal fans I'm telling you about? Unless you dot every T and cross every eye, they will jump in every gap and shout FAIL!! to the high heavens. Know what I say? Frak 'em. Make that mad cash."

 

[Temis the Vorta]

Moore is pissed that the Romulans weren't changing their plans for the Federation every five minutes.

Too true.

"We have a plan. That plan involves having a years-long dysfunctional cocktail party in space, and sex with humans, and convincing the humans that our plan is actually much more involved and complicated than this."

Oh.

NOW I get it.

Why didn't they just frakkin well say so in the first place?

 

[EnsignRicky]

He probably gets a kick out of the Vulcan angle.

 

[Admiral Buzzkill]

He'd probably say it isn't the direction he would've taken it in, and that he's "evolved" beyond Star Trek.

I doubt it. That doesn't sound at all like him. It sounds a little like a fan attempt to parody him, though.

He had some pretty positive things to say about this movie before it was released, IIRC.

 

[Tom]

He was probably upset they did not use the Nexus . LOL

 

[Stone_Cold_Sisko]

He probably likes it.

 

[Mr. Laser Beam]

"Engineering wasn't disorganized enough."

 

[Destructor]

I've been thinking the same thing recently, I wish he'd pipe up about it. I'm pretty sure he'd say he liked it, as he liked The Phantom Menace.

 

[Marc]

I've been thinking the same thing recently, I wish he'd pipe up about it. I'm pretty sure he'd say he liked it, as he liked The Phantom Menace.

is that something a person should ever admit to?

 

[stonester1]

TPM, though it didn't live up to the landmark set by the Holy Trilogy, isn't the crapfest that many make it out to be. In fact, in my view, it's a good flick. I just don't think it was the movie everyone imagined or expected lo those years.

Lots of problems, definitely. Did it expose George Lucas' weaknesses as a filmmaker? Definitely. But it was not the disaster some are inclined to say it is.

IMAO.

 

[Cdr MacDuff]

"Not enough flawed adult acting with the maturity of 15yo teenagers"

 

[Nowhere Man]

He'd probably say " You Suck!"