• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Roger Ebert is dead...

it's weird to moan about a eberts 'liberal' politics while having an avatar from a show by david lynch, who votes democrat.
 
Can we just drop all the political bullshit, please?....There's lovely article at the Chicago Tribune about Roger's funeral---HERE.

There's a certain irony in asking to drop "political bullshit" and then linking to a "lovely" story about, among other things, Ebert's political views and eulogies from various politicians.

Be a man and bring it to TNZ. Otherwise, stick to the topic and if you can't, shut the hell up.
 
I printed out Ebert's 300 Great Movies list, and will be going through checking off what I've seen, and then working towards seeing the rest of them.
Might I suggest considering keeping track through letterboxd? The list has been bannered at the top of the main page since Ebert's death was announced.
 
There's a certain irony in asking to drop "political bullshit" and then linking to a "lovely" story about, among other things, Ebert's political views and eulogies from various politicians.

That word. Irony.

I do not think it means what you think it means.

:lol: To be fair, Morrisette didn't understand it either. Which ends up being the only thing ironic about her song. All her examples were merely unfortunate ;)
 
:lol: To be fair, Morrisette didn't understand it either. Which ends up being the only thing ironic about her song. All her examples were merely unfortunate ;)

Yeah, it was a running joke between myself and a couple of friends back in 1995 and 1996 that the Alanis song wasn't actually about irony, just unfortunate timing and bad luck. Jagged Little Pill was a pretty great little album that we all enjoyed, but we couldn't pass up making fun of the video when it played on TV.
 
Can we just drop all the political bullshit, please?....There's lovely article at the Chicago Tribune about Roger's funeral---HERE.

There's a certain irony in asking to drop "political bullshit" and then linking to a "lovely" story about, among other things, Ebert's political views and eulogies from various politicians.

Be a man and bring it to TNZ. Otherwise, stick to the topic and if you can't, shut the hell up.
But that's where the scary liberals live. They may defeat conservative ideals with facts and reality, he can't go there.

I need to start collecting all of Ebert's bad reviews. He could really tear into a movie if he hated it enough. His review of North is just amazing.
 
You'd think that after a while if you keep getting easily beaten by smart people you'd at least try to change things a little.
 
I need to start collecting all of Ebert's bad reviews. He could really tear into a movie if he hated it enough. His review of North is just amazing.

He published three collections of his negative reviews: I Hated, Hated, HATED This Movie; Your Movie Sucks; and last year's A Horrible Experience of Unbearable Length. Yeah, they're all up on his website for free, but there's something about having them in print.
 
Be a man and bring it to TNZ...

Yes because nobody but me has ever brought up politics outside of TNZ :rommie:

it's weird to moan about a eberts 'liberal' politics while having an avatar from a show by david lynch, who votes democrat.

I did not moan about Eberts liberal politics.

I discussed the hypocrisy of some posters who seemed to defend inserting politics in writing when it was a liberal viewpoint but not a conservative viewpoint.

Never in this thread have I attacked either the man or his politics.

The worst thing I said about Ebert on this thread was that hypothetically some people could take issue with some of his positions as strongly as some of the posters here took issue with Orson Scott Card.

Disagree with me if you want. reasonable people can do that, but at least disagree with what I actually wrote.
 
Regardless, you've dragged the topic away from being a memorial to Ebert in order to pursue some silly agenda. Bravo, good sir. You must be a great guy to have at a funeral.
 
He certainly doesn't care about the topic of the thread, so there really is no reason to pay any particular attention to what G-Man writes.
 
Might I suggest focusing on what you (the general you) would like this thread to be rather than continuing to discuss what it appears some posters might like it to become?

Put another way...dwelling on the subject won't make it recede into the distance any faster.
 
Wait. I've got it.

G-man is actually paying tribute to Roger by offering us his own written-post version of Plan 9 From Outer Space.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top