Ranking the Episodes of Season Four

[bigglesworth]

I can rate these based on my own personal scale factor...

Your sentiments mostly mirror my own. I moved a couple of your bad episodes to the "Meh" category, but it's mostly a straight copy/paste. I voted for "The Drumhead" as the best episode of S4.

Good
Best of Both Worlds Part II
Family
Brothers
Future Imperfect
Remember Me
Clues
The Drumhead
Redemption Part I
Reunion
The Mind's Eye
Galaxy's Child
The Wounded

Bad
The Host
Suddenly Human
Final Mission

Meh
In Theory
QPid
Half a Life
Identity Crisis
The Ninth Degree
First Contact
The Loss
Legacy
Devil's Due
Night Terrors

 

[Spirit of 73]

Agreed! However, the turbolift scene with Picard just makes me laugh more then scare me.

Fair point. One of the few times where Picard may have overacted a bit. Perhaps poor direction.

 

[Spirit of 73]

Your sentiments mostly mirror my own. I moved a couple of your bad episodes to the "Meh" category, but it's mostly a straight copy/paste. I voted for "The Drumhead" as the best episode of S4.

Good
Best of Both Worlds Part II
Family
Brothers
Future Imperfect
Remember Me
Clues
The Drumhead
Redemption Part I
Reunion
The Mind's Eye
Galaxy's Child
The Wounded

Bad
The Host
Suddenly Human
Final Mission

Meh
In Theory
QPid
Half a Life
Identity Crisis
The Ninth Degree
First Contact
The Loss
Legacy
Devil's Due
Night Terrors

Pretty close agreement, indeed. The Drumhead is definitely my favorite episode that is completely season four, since Best of Both Worlds feels like a season three episode.

I thought Devil's Due was too silly to take seriously.

 

[Armus]

^I like Devil's Due because it feels like a first season show. My favorite part is when Picard outdoes Ardra's "magic". This episode originated from a Phase II script but it turned out much better than The Child. Originally Ardra was male.

 

[Spirit of 73]

^I like Devil's Due because it feels like a first season show.

LOL. That's why I don't like it! De gustibus, non est disputandum!