• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Overrated "Cult" Movies

And the "I want to shoot myself every time someone thinks they're being clever by quoting this godawful, dull f-ing movie" award goes to: Monty Python and the Holy Grail. Not funny whatsoever. Stop quoting lines from it, I hate you. :mad:
Same here, never really found Monty Python overly funny either.
Seems to be designed for Oxbridge students who think they're "ker-azy"
Sod off
 
It would seem my definition of 'cult movie' differs from that of most people who post here. Most of the films mentioned in this thread were embraced by mainstream audiences.

Some cult films I find overrated:

Funny Games
The House on the Edge of the Park
Dead and Breakfast
Stage Fright (Deliria)
 
Another one for Donnie Darko. It seemed like Harvey meets Sliders.

I hated that one too. Worse, I have co-workers who actually liked Southland Tales.:eek:

I'm going to go there and say Hot Fuzz. I love Shaun of the Dead. Hot Fuzz has some funny send ups of action but you gotta admit it's slloooowww in the first hour and the big action finale isn't very well filmed. Doesn't really work for me in the way Shaun worked.

Here I have to disagree. Hot Fuzz is the Swiss watch of movie comedies. The individual gears don't mean much but the whole is a breathtaking piece of perfection. OTOH, Shaun of the Dead was merely a decent first effort. Hot Fuzz was when they truly refined the comic balance between Simon Pegg & Nick Frost. I'm on pins & needles waiting for them to do another collaboration.

Although it has some decent bits, I was somewhat underwhelmed by Army of Darkness.

I'll agree that This Is Spinal Tap isn't the best comedy I've ever seen, although "Stonehenge" is pure comic genius!

I hated most of 2001: A Space Odyssey and I don't really get the fanatical devotion to Blade Runner.

I hated Sin City & 300. Quentin Tarantino may be overly violent but at least he writes funny dialogue to take the edge off. These 2 atrocities adapted from Frank Miller graphic novels are nothing but unrepentant, misogynistic testosterone orgies from a writer who is obviously compensating for something.
 
The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension. Wait, why am I dignifying it by writing out its full title? I think the idea is decent but the execution is way off. I mostly blame Peter Weller's performance. The man just generally doesn't generate enough charisma to carry a movie. (The only think I ever liked him in was Odyssey 5.)

He also insisted that I watch Twelve Angry Men with Gregory Peck, insisting it's the best film ever made. He looked crestfallen when I said I had seen it already and was aware it is an acknowledged classic. Apparently I was the first to say so as I had noticed his copy do the rounds at the office several times before. ;)

12 Angry Men (1957) starred Henry Fonda, not Gregory Peck.

Random aside: The 1997 remake of 12 Angry Men stars both Edward James Olmos & Mary McDonnell, the only project the 2 have done together besides Battlestar Galactica.

Edward Scissorhands

If I never see that again, it will be too soon.

Seconded. I normally love Tim Burton movies but that one's just a bit too Burton for my tastes. On the other side of the coin, my friend loves Sleepy Hollow. I think that Burton was just kinda sleepwalking through that one.
 
What little I'd seen of Go didn't grab me at all, it also looked and sounded very naff, dated firmly in the 1990s like Hackers or Johnny Mneumonic.

Road House was just cheesy, sleazy trash with a sweaty, homoerotic fightscene that made me openly chuckle ("I used to fuck guys like you in prison!!!").

Mortal Kombat is an overrated 'so-bad it's good' film.

While far, far better than the crap already mentioned here, I don't see The Life of Brian to be quite as good Monty Python and the Holy Grail (still very funny and more darkly satirical though).
 
At best, the only reason for posting a thread like this is to say, "I don't understand this movie's appeal to its limited but enthusiastic audience."

But that's inane. Of course you don't understand the appeal. If you did, you'd be part of the cult

You got that vibe too eh?

Threads like this seem to be for people who hate the cult as much as its object of affection.
 
Rocky Horror Picture Show.

Same as above, but even more pretentious. The plot, such as it is, can be summed up in this phrase: A bunch of perverts dance to rock music while the audience yells back random stuff. The end.

To be fair, the movie itself is only a 'cult classic' BECAUSE at the midnight shows at theatres (and I used to attend them occassionally in the 1980ies when it was something interesting to do); the entire audience effectively participated in an MSTK 3000 style sendup of it as it aired (and new or changed comeback lines that were good stuck and were used in later viewings, etc.) NOBODY should ever be forced to actually watch that film in it's 'original' form. ;)
 
OH! Here's one I never got: Trainspotters.

Buncha zero-sum losers with their heads in toilets and needles in their veins. Bleah.
 
Fight Club, seriously that film was popular? I couldn't stand it.

I'm with you there. Fight Club is dull, the twist is nonsense and the ending whatever. It's by far my least favorite Fincher movie, Alien3 included in that list.

I didn't get Hot Fuzz at all. That's pretty rare for me to just completely miss the point.

I watched wondering what I'd miss by not being able to quote scenes from cop movies.

I liked the references in top cop movies, even felt they could've gone farther than Point Break and Bad Boys II. Also, like I said earlier, the movie dragged in the beginning 2/3rds. The action pieces weren't that great.
 
"pump up the volume" with christian slater and samantha mathis. "kuffs", with christian slater and milla jovovich.
 
Rocky Horror Picture Show.

Same as above, but even more pretentious. The plot, such as it is, can be summed up in this phrase: A bunch of perverts dance to rock music while the audience yells back random stuff. The end.

To be fair, the movie itself is only a 'cult classic' BECAUSE at the midnight shows at theatres (and I used to attend them occassionally in the 1980ies when it was something interesting to do); the entire audience effectively participated in an MSTK 3000 style sendup of it as it aired (and new or changed comeback lines that were good stuck and were used in later viewings, etc.) NOBODY should ever be forced to actually watch that film in it's 'original' form. ;)

How are people who have never seen this film (or at least have never been in an audience for it), supposed to learn how to do a proper audience response? Do you just go with friends who'd previously done it, and they teach you?

Do the DVDs, for example, have a 'how-to' audience response track?
 
Rocky Horror Picture Show.

Same as above, but even more pretentious. The plot, such as it is, can be summed up in this phrase: A bunch of perverts dance to rock music while the audience yells back random stuff. The end.

To be fair, the movie itself is only a 'cult classic' BECAUSE at the midnight shows at theatres (and I used to attend them occassionally in the 1980ies when it was something interesting to do); the entire audience effectively participated in an MSTK 3000 style sendup of it as it aired (and new or changed comeback lines that were good stuck and were used in later viewings, etc.) NOBODY should ever be forced to actually watch that film in it's 'original' form. ;)

How are people who have never seen this film (or at least have never been in an audience for it), supposed to learn how to do a proper audience response? Do you just go with friends who'd previously done it, and they teach you?

Do the DVDs, for example, have a 'how-to' audience response track?

Yes, you go with friends and that's how you learn, and at your first midnight show, you make sure everyone know's it's your first time so you get your cherry popped.
 
I think I am the only person I know that doesn't understand the appeal of "Napoleon Dynamite". Everyone I know said "you gotta see this movie, you gotta see this movie." I saw the movie.... for about 15 minutes before I turned it off, making it the first and ONLY movie I have ever turned off in the middle of it.
 
I think I am the only person I know that doesn't understand the appeal of "Napoleon Dynamite". Everyone I know said "you gotta see this movie, you gotta see this movie." I saw the movie.... for about 15 minutes before I turned it off, making it the first and ONLY movie I have ever turned off in the middle of it.


The appeal of Napoleon Dynamite is easy, it's this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIf8y0h3lH0

If you don't enjoy that on at least some level, you're just no fun.

Vote for Pedro
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top