• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

OT: Vote for the Unreality SF - Media Tie-In Story of the year

Defcon

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Unreality-SF.net is celebrating its first year online and to celebrate this we have a vote for your favourite tie-in story from the last twelve months.

We had an open nomination period in the last week and the ten stories which received the most nominations have now formed the final shortlist. You can vote for your favourite of these ten stories until Sunday 22nd March 2009.

The final ten stories, in alphabetical order, are:

A Gutted World by Keith R.A. DeCandido
From the Star Trek: Myriad Universes collection Echoes and Refractions, DeCandido's story showed us a version of Deep Space Nine where the Cardassians never withdrew from Bajor, and discovered the wormhole. Reviewing the story in December, Unreality SF's Jens called it "one of DeCandido's darker works" in which "he easily proves his versatility", summing up A Gutted World as "easily the strongest in the book".

Almost Perfect by James Goss
Goss' debut novel was a popular Torchwood story, and was the first tale to be set after the dramatic events of Exit Wounds. It saw Ianto Jones wake up as a woman. Earlier this month, reviewer Naomi called it " a strong story, well told with all the elements needed for a good solid read", but also thought the story had several flaws.

Brotherhood of the Daleks by Alan Barnes
Continuing the fan-favourite partnership of the Sixth Doctor and Charley Pollard on audio, Alan Barnes' Brotherhood of the Daleks saw the return of Skaro's finest in a story where the nature of reality itself is threatened.

The Eyeless by Lance Parkin
The ever-popular Lance Parkin returned to Doctor Who fiction with The Eyeless, the first novel to see the Tenth Doctor travelling alone. It saw him visiting the Fortress - an imposing structure on an alien world, far in our future - which housed a deadly weapon responsible for exterminating the population of an entire planet.

Gods of Night by David Mack
Kicking off the epic Star Trek: Destiny trilogy, which formed the centrepiece of 2008's Star Trek literary schedule, was Mack's Gods of Night. Spanning several different time periods, it pulled together numerous continuing storylines, and united four Star Trek captains against the ongoing Borg threat.

Good Queen, Bad Queen, I Queen, You Queen by Terri Osborne
From the Doctor Who: Short Trips anthology The Quality of Leadership, Osborne's Who debut saw the Fourth Doctor and Romana encounter Boudicca, who wasn't quite what she seemed. Unreality SF's Dan enjoyed the "fantastically innovative and daring twist", and thought the depiction of Romana was "arguably the most successful characterisation of the entire anthology".

Greater Than the Sum by Christopher L. Bennett
Continuing the adventures of Star Trek: The Next Generation beyond the film Nemesis, Bennett's novel saw the Enterprise hunting down the Borg-controlled U.S.S. Einstein, in an exciting character-driven story. Unreality SF's Jens, however, wasn't impressed - he disliked the fact that the book was "basically a transitional novel to lead the TNG line into Destiny", and described it as a "disappointment".

The Prisoner's Dilemma by Simon Guerrier
Simon Guerrier makes unique use of the traditional Doctor Who: The Companion Chronicles format with this story, which crosses over with The Key 2 Time and does some clever things with the character of Ace. Reviewer Steve thought it was "a bit disjointed", but praised Guerrier for "a clever piece of writing".

The Raincloud Man by Eddie Robson
Another outing for the Sixth Doctor and Charley, this Doctor Who audio play also featured the return of D.I. Menzies, as the TARDIS paid a return visit to Manchester. Reviewer Rachel was thrilled with the cast, who "sparkle in this production; their enthusiasm for the material shines through in every line", and described the play as "high quality".

Wet Work by Dayton Ward and Kevin Dilmore
Only the second The 4400 novel to be published, Ward and Dilmore's Wet Work was a surprise latecomer in the nominations. The novel saw the return of the serial killer known as the Wraith, as one of the 4400 returnees - now armed with a special power. Reviewing the book for Unreality SF, Dan described it as having "many strengths", and said "the prose is tense and violent and exciting" in the action sequences.

You can cast your votes here.

P.S.: If you run Firefox with the NoScript-AddOn you have to allow bravenet.com to see the voting box.
 
The Sixth Doctor and Charley Pollard? Didn't she start out as a companion of the Eighth Doctor? That's potentially a rather interesting situation, the Doctor having a companion who knows some things about his future.
 
The Prisoner's Dilemma by Simon Guerrier
Simon Guerrier makes unique use of the traditional Doctor Who: The Companion Chronicles format with this story, which crosses over with The Key 2 Time and does some clever things with the character of Ace. Reviewer Steve thought it was "a bit disjointed", but praised Guerrier for "a clever piece of writing".
When I first read this blurb over on Unreality, I momentarily thought it said "Ace reviewer Steve", and I was very disappointed that that was not the case.
The Sixth Doctor and Charley Pollard? Didn't she start out as a companion of the Eighth Doctor? That's potentially a rather interesting situation, the Doctor having a companion who knows some things about his future.
It's been pretty good so far, though it feels a little dragged out. But supposedly it's coming to an end within their next three audios. Colin Baker and India Fisher have excellent chemistry, too.
 
Because that would be like nominating all three LoTR movies as a group for an award?

As the only piece of short fiction on the list, I know I'm the underdog with my little story of kickass heroines and battling babes in First Century England. I would like to thank everyone who's voted for me so far, and hope that this will be the beginning of a trend for this little double-award-nominated story that apparently could. :)

And for anyone attending Lunacon this weekend, I'll be reading "Good Queen, Bad Queen..." during the Hot Chicks with Books reading on Saturday night. You'll still have plenty of time to vote after that. :)
 
Can we vote for more than one? I already voted for GoN, and but there were at least one or two others I wanted to vote for too.
 
Can we vote for more than one? I already voted for GoN, and but there were at least one or two others I wanted to vote for too.

As captcalhoun said it's one vote only:

If you vote multiple times, only your first vote will be counted. And we're logging IPs, so anyone who does manage to trick the system will have their extra votes disqualified. And will also receive a very stern glare.
 
So, basically, it's a David versus Goliath competition. Who. Will. Emerge. Victorious?






Probably Dave, because, really, I can't fight market penetration. More people simply have access to the novel than my story. (Though, I'm seeing what I can do to offer the PDF for reading for those who couldn't get the anthology.)
 
It's also sort of unbalanced by virtue of audiences. There's not really anyone out there who's just a "tie-in fan" (except for Steve Roby ;)), and if there's more Star Trek fans than Doctor Who ones on the site, obviously they're going to vote for what they've read. No Star Wars stories were even nominated, and that's got one of the most thriving tie-in lines of any licensed property.
 
No Star Wars stories were even nominated, and that's got one of the most thriving tie-in lines of any licensed property.
It may be thriving, but the books are geared to the lowest common denominator, and those readers (representing the majority of SW readers) don't read cool stuff like ST, DW or the rest.
 
The books are geared toward the lowest common denominator no more or less than any other work of tie-in fiction, and had it been on the ballot, I would have gladly voted for Luke Skywalker and the Shadows of Mindor.

(As it was, I voted for The Raincloud Man. Eddie Robson forever!)
 
There's not really anyone out there who's just a "tie-in fan" (except for Steve Roby ;))

Harrumph. I only ever read two of the Happy Days novels (well, they were written by the guy who wrote the Get Smart novels, and I liked those), two of the Starsky and Hutch novels, and maybe three or four of the Dirty Harry novels. And I sought out, bought, and read the Blake's 7 novels Afterlife and Avon: A Terrible Aspect despite all the warnings of their awfulness, which proved to be understatements. Problem? I don't have a problem.

My main concern with the list of nominees is that while I've been trying to buy all the Doctor Who audios, I'm years behind in actually listening to them, so I haven't heard any of the three audios nominated.
 
True, but you're better looking than goliath.

:cool:

And than Mack!

:alienblush: Well, I didn't want to be the one to say that, but thank you, guys. *bats eyelashes*


And I just noticed I'm not only the only short story, but also the only female on the list. No, the deck's not stacked against me in this in the slightest. :cardie:

The hazards of being a realist. :cool:

Of course, there's still time to prove me wrong. *points toward sig*
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top