• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

old school trek literature fans help-marshak and culbreath?

When The Price of the Phoenix first came out, I devoured it, because there was so little Trek to be had. By the time The Fate of the Phoenix came out, I'd reread Price a couple of times and had also become a bit older and more discerning, so I wasn't too excited about more Marshak and Culbreath. But I found Fate in many ways a better book, as I recall. Didn't like The Prometheus Design at all, and I remember waiting months before buying Triangle; it was the first Trek novel that I didn't buy as soon as I had the chance. And I didn't like it. But at least it was the last one from this particular team.

Still, Marshak and Culbreath gave us the two volumes of Star Trek: The New Voyages, and I wouldn't have wanted to miss those.
 
My favorite of the Bantam novels is The Galactic Whirlpool by David Gerrold. He wrote that up in novel form after having pitched it during the show's actual run as a two-part episode. Sadly, it was never made.

Its story is a lot more complicated than that. After he failed to sell it to ST, he tried selling it as a movie. When that failed, he started writing it as a novel called Yesterday's Children. The story veered off in a totally different direction, though (one that left the title as an orphan having nothing to do with the story). He published that book in the '70s. Then, in 1980, the same year he wrote The Galactic Whirlpool, he went back to Yesterday's Children and added several new chapters after the original ending to give it a different ending (which I didn't like as well as the original) and republished it. A few years later, it was reissued under the title Star Hunt. Sometime after that, after leaving the TNG staff, he took the main characters from YC and combined them with ideas he'd had for TNG, developing a TV series pitch called Voyage of the Star Wolf. When that didn't go anywhere, he did VotSW as a novel, and has since done two more novels in the Star Wolf universe, both adapted from scripts written for the unsold series (and one being a reworking of his rejected TNG script "Blood and Fire").

So really, a sizeable chunk of Gerrold's career has grown out of that single rejected Trek pitch.


BTW, this is the first time an "Away Team" is used in Star Trek. TNG did NOT invent that concept!

David Gerrold was one of the original developers of TNG, and he was the one who introduced that concept to the series. He'd proposed the idea of a dedicated "contact team" in his 1973 book The World of Star Trek, and when he came onto TNG's original staff, he incorporated that along with several of his other ideas into the series bible. (He also introduced the idea of the replicator in The Galactic Whirlpool.)
 
Yep. There's an article on the long Tomorrow Was Yesterday/Galactic Whirlpool/Yesterday's Children etc story at my website.

Considering the twists and turns that story took, it's funny that one of Gerrold's other unproduced TOS story pitches described in The Trouble With Tribbles book ended up being adapted in one of the Trek manga books decades later, almost unchanged.
 
(and one being a reworking of his rejected TNG script "Blood and Fire").
Which he has now adapted into a two-part script for the Phase II fan series. They've only released the first half so far, but I watched it and I loved it. It probably one of their best episodes yet.
 
(and one being a reworking of his rejected TNG script "Blood and Fire").
Which he has now adapted into a two-part script for the Phase II fan series. They've only released the first half so far, but I watched it and I loved it. It probably one of their best episodes yet.

It was pretty good, and I am also looking forward to the second part.

FWIW, I read the TNG script version of Blood and Fire and thought it was as good, if not better than, anything that actually did air in TNG's first season.
 
this is the first time an "Away Team" is used in Star Trek. TNG did NOT invent that concept!

David Gerrold wrote both the Bantam novel and the TNG Season One Writers' Bible.

Note also, in TGW, the appearance of one Admiral George La Forge, named for a disabled ST fan who befriended Gene Roddenberry and David Gerrold at conventions in the 70s. He died shortly before TNG came about and Geordi is his memorial namesake.
 
The two women gave us New Voyages. For this-thanks. Then they gave us the Phoenix stories. For this, a thousand curses upon their heads. I know many female(and some male) ST fans enjoy that K/S slash stuff but to find it in a published novel(as a child, no less) was more than a bit disturbing. As for their other 2 books- read them, took Tylenol and got over them fairly quick.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top