• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Number One= Starfleet Computer voice. Coincidence? I think not.

I've always liked the idea that just as Data was the son of Dr. Soong, The EMH Doc was the son of Dr. Zimmerman.

If that doesn't give him the right to that name, I don't know what does.

Maybe "Joe Zimmerman"? :p
 
Geez, leave it to Beaker to be offended by just about any innocent question! :rolleyes: (Hmm, this could be the start of a BBS sitcom, Leave it to Beaker, about a guy who grumbles about, oh, everything! Like Becker, only not as funny! :lol:)

Actually, the Enterprise computer voice was Daystrom's secret predecessor to M-5 -- call her M-1 -- "not entirely successful," based on Pike's Number One's memory engrams. But M-1 didn't stroke Daystrom's ego enough, so he went on to build the other unsuccessful multitronic units, till he built his teacher's pet, M-5! :bolian:

Red Ranger
 
Geez, leave it to Beaker to be offended by just about any innocent question! :rolleyes: (Hmm, this could be the start of a BBS sitcom, Leave it to Beaker, about a guy who grumbles about, oh, everything! Like Becker, only not as funny! :lol:)

Actually, the Enterprise computer voice was Daystrom's secret predecessor to M-5 -- call her M-1 -- "not entirely successful," based on Pike's Number One's memory engrams. But M-1 didn't stroke Daystrom's ego enough, so he went on to build the other unsuccessful multitronic units, till he built his teacher's pet, M-5! :bolian:

Red Ranger


Yes...M-5...the one with his engrams....the one that went on to murder several hundred Starfleet officers, and could have just as easily wiped out a whole crew of civilians if that other ship hadn't been a drone.

Amazingly successful.

I'm surprised Starfleet didn't order Data destroyed when that Starship crew found him decades later, in the echoes of the M-5 incident.
 
Geez, leave it to Beaker to be offended by just about any innocent question! :rolleyes: (Hmm, this could be the start of a BBS sitcom, Leave it to Beaker, about a guy who grumbles about, oh, everything! Like Becker, only not as funny! :lol:)

Actually, the Enterprise computer voice was Daystrom's secret predecessor to M-5 -- call her M-1 -- "not entirely successful," based on Pike's Number One's memory engrams. But M-1 didn't stroke Daystrom's ego enough, so he went on to build the other unsuccessful multitronic units, till he built his teacher's pet, M-5! :bolian:

Red Ranger

Yes...M-5...the one with his engrams....the one that went on to murder several hundred Starfleet officers, and could have just as easily wiped out a whole crew of civilians if that other ship hadn't been a drone.

Amazingly successful.

I'm surprised Starfleet didn't order Data destroyed when that Starship crew found him decades later, in the echoes of the M-5 incident.

Gastrof: Well, I was being sarcastic about M-5. But you raise an interesting point that should be the basis for an independent thread. What was Starfleet's reaction at first to Data's discovery? Wonder if any novel's delved into that? We do know Bruce Maddox was the only member of the Starfleet board that wouldn't approve Data's application to Starfleet Academy on the grounds that he wasn't a sentient being. Surely he's not unique! -- RR
 
Alas, in VOY "Prototype", Torres explicitly establishes Data as the only sentient android in the Federation in the 2370s.

So apparently all other sentient androids choose not to hold UFP citizenship, or have been hunted to extinction. It's possible that Federation AI technology has proceeded way past the stage where it would be useful or even interesting to squeeze the AIs into android bodies, and Data's body is just an insignificant antique toy that Dr. Soong created as a marketing tool for his new positronic technology. It's not as if anybody ever found Data's body technologically interesting, after all: it only ever held interest as the vessel to his advanced positronic brain, as a rarity item, or as a sex toy.

Timo Saloniemi
 
That's a nice one!

But that court didn't prove Data sentient, only that Data has the right to choose his own fate. All sides accepted that Data was a very clever machine, sentient in the usual meaning of the word, but that as such wouldn't have helped him in his case.

Lacking precedent (which is the odd thing about this trial), Louvois could have judged that a sentient machine is comparable to a toaster and is to be treated as property. Hell, given her apparent breadth of powers, she could probably have judged that Riker is comparable to a toaster and is to be treated as property, had there not been explicit precedent that made it unpalatable to treat members of H. sapiens as property.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Of course, "Number One" was from the very start identifiable as a piece of naval jargon, the title for the Executive Officer of the ship. I wonder how long a show starring Hunter and Barrett would have kept on referring to the character as "Number One" only? I'd actually think her name would have come up by the third episode already

Nope. According to convention stories from Gene, Majel and DC Fontana, the term "Number One" was not only "naval jargon", it was to make the character more enigmatic, to set audiences wondering about why she didn't use a personal name. Had there been an definite intention to "name her", that probably would have been added to the writers' bible. It wasn't left out simply because Gene couldn't think of a good name; this was a character he wrote for Majel, after all.

none of the writers would have dreamed of using "Number One" as an "alien" or "futuristic" expression...

Except that writers are expected to follow the show's Bible, and GR was rewriting episodes to his taste.

BTW, the Season One Writers' Bible for VOY mentioned how the EMH would search for a name (and eventually would select "Doctor Zimmerman"), which is which several early novels were using the name for the character.

I don't think that just because the name itself wasn't given in the WB doesn't mean that she wouldn't have eventually had one. Maybe that was being saved for a later date, and they didn't want it revealed too soon. If it had been known that she's really Betty Sue, some dumbfuck would have tried to be the one to put it on the air and kill the mystery.

So, save the mystery for a later date.

PS maybe she was going to be named laxawana?

But that might just be BC I'm used to serialized 21st century dramas that plot shit out 3 years in advance.
 
Geez, leave it to Beaker to be offended by just about any innocent question! :rolleyes: (Hmm, this could be the start of a BBS sitcom, Leave it to Beaker, about a guy who grumbles about, oh, everything! Like Becker, only not as funny! :lol:)

ok, first of all, I didn't say I was offended. Second, what, am I here to amuse you? Like a clown? Is that what you're saying? Third, I'm plenty funny. I'm an honest-to-christ card. Ask anybody. Come on, just the name "A beaker full of death" brings a smile to people's faces. True, most of them reside in the Afghani mountains...
 
I don't know Beaker. Every time I see your username I get images. Big red nose, bright orange hair that sticks straight out, great big floppy shoes...

But I guess that's just me.

Robert
 
Geez, leave it to Beaker to be offended by just about any innocent question! :rolleyes: (Hmm, this could be the start of a BBS sitcom, Leave it to Beaker, about a guy who grumbles about, oh, everything! Like Becker, only not as funny! :lol:)

ok, first of all, I didn't say I was offended. Second, what, am I here to amuse you? Like a clown? Is that what you're saying? Third, I'm plenty funny. I'm an honest-to-christ card. Ask anybody. Come on, just the name "A beaker full of death" brings a smile to people's faces. True, most of them reside in the Afghani mountains...

Could've fooled me! And yes, you are a clown, you do amuse me, you do make me laugh! Now go get your f***ing shine box! :guffaw:-- RR
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top