• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

No privacy curtains in sickbay?

There is a difference between "naked" and "guts hanging out". I'm okay with the doc and other patients seeing me in the buff, but not all sick and gross.
 
Maybe. But curtains are cheap, and some aliens receiving aid from a Star Fleet vessel may have different social norms than a military organization. They may not be trained as well as Star Fleet personnel.
 
FWIW, the sick bay set consisted of four rooms (as labeled in the original set diagrams reproduced in The Making of Star Trek): Characters walked in to the Sick Bay Exam Room (the one with the single bed); to their right was Dr. McCoy's Office...past that, McCoy's Lab. To their left was the Sick Bay Ward, which had the extra beds. Offscreen sources usually speculated more sick bay facilities than that...those are just the only areas we usually needed to see. It would certainly be fair to imagine more wards that were used on an as-needed basis. And M'Benga probably had his own office space somewhere.
 
I would like to think people had the option of privacy even if nudity isn't that big a deal in the future. There is always the off chance you will get a Reg Barclay type who has the odd hang up about whatever....
 
I'm okay with the doc and other patients seeing me in the buff, but not all sick and gross.
We never see casual nudity in Star Trek, off duty we did see people in casual dress, but not walking around naked. The same on various planets, including Earth.

Social customs concerning dress and modesty are in place.
 
If privacy curtains were needed they would probably drop down from the ceiling. We never saw the ceiling, so that's where they must have been. :techman:

I remember being quite surprised when Neelix started saying how ugly the infirmary's ceiling looked. It's true though that the ceiling is normally the great unseen.
 
People will always be concerned with their dignity, and will want control over whether they're seen in this or that personal situation. People will have different ideas as to what's a bit too personal. Being given NO choice takes away dignity, even if your choice would have been to have everything show.
----------------------
Announcing that no one should mind nudity therefore no one will, in unison, seems awfully presumptuous, and has nothing to do with not wanting to be witnessed defecating, say.
------------------------
Doctors need easy access to each patient at a moment's notice. However, 24th century sickbays take this too far, putting beds out in the middle of the room. That feels a hell of a lot more exposed.
 
Perhaps unseen long-term care wards have more accommodations for privacy. The main sickbay could be more like an army field hospital...just a bunch of cots sharing a tent.
 
One of the conventions of framing shots for television is generally not to show too much of the ceiling.

Kor
 
One of the conventions of framing shots for television is generally not to show too much of the ceiling.

Kor

I think one of the advantages of cgi sets (if that's what it's called) is that you can show absolutely every nook and crannie of a room without restrictions.
 
And if there were any bathrooms, they wouldn't have separate partitions, either. Just a bunch of toilets and a urinal trough all out in plain view.

In fact, it wouldn't even be a separate room. It would just be a completely open area adjacent to the corridor. :eek:
I read a short story (non-Star Trek) some years ago about a ship that had a floor that absorbed and recycled any contaminant that came in contact with it - skin cells, dirt, hair... or human waste. One of the bridge crew was from a planet with absolutely no concept of privacy concerning biological functions. When he decided to urinate or defecate, he just pulled down his pants and did so, on the floor, in front of everybody.

It ended up causing some visiting aliens a great deal of offense, and an interstellar incident ensued...
 
I read a short story (non-Star Trek) some years ago about a ship that had a floor that absorbed and recycled any contaminant that came in contact with it - skin cells, dirt, hair... or human waste. One of the bridge crew was from a planet with absolutely no concept of privacy concerning biological functions. When he decided to urinate or defecate, he just pulled down his pants and did so, on the floor, in front of everybody.

It ended up causing some visiting aliens a great deal of offense, and an interstellar incident ensued...

What a load of crap! ;)
 
I've been having x-rays of my knees taken for over a decade. Used to have to strip off and put on one of those bizarre hospital gowns that seem to be designed for a thinner species with three arms. Lately, I can get x-rayed with my pants still on.
I'd hope that in 300 years, they can diagnose you with all your clothes on.
 
And if there were any bathrooms, they wouldn't have separate partitions, either. Just a bunch of toilets and a urinal trough all out in plain view.

In fact, it wouldn't even be a separate room. It would just be a completely open area adjacent to the corridor. :eek:

Kor

Just like prison! Then the Enterprise was really a prison barge!

NO! The answer is really simple, folks. We all know that much of what accented the sets on Star Trek came from the dumpsters on the Desilu (later Paramount) lot. Obviously, no one threw away curtains that John Dwyer et. al. could then fish out of a dumpster.

I guess that pretty much settles that.
 
I read a short story (non-Star Trek) some years ago about a ship that had a floor that absorbed and recycled any contaminant that came in contact with it - skin cells, dirt, hair... or human waste. One of the bridge crew was from a planet with absolutely no concept of privacy concerning biological functions. When he decided to urinate or defecate, he just pulled down his pants and did so, on the floor, in front of everybody.

It ended up causing some visiting aliens a great deal of offense, and an interstellar incident ensued...

I'm picturing Picard unhitching and letting flow mid negotiations. It has to be Picard, with Kirk it seems just a little too feasible.....
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top