• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Nimoy's Love/Hate Relationship with Mr. Spock?

TiberiusK

Captain
Captain
Another new article at Trekdom, this time on Nimoy's struggles to disassociate himself from the character of Spock, as well as behind-the-scenes drama during the 1970s and 1980s.

Is this author fair and objective? Are the facts correct? Is the interpretation debatable?

Read the full article here:

http://startrekdom.blogspot.com/2007/05/leonard-nimoys-lovehate-relationship.html


Short excerpt:

While Nimoy’s relationship with Star Trek’s producers soured, so too did his relationship with Mr. Spock. Initially, he attributed the popularity of the character to his own acting and creative ideas, having personally fashioned many aspects of the Vulcan’s mannerisms, such as the neck pinch and the V-shaped “Live Long and Prosper” hand gesture. Yet, by the third season, he had grown so protective of his creation that he resented many of the scripts. Feeling like the writers simply didn’t understand the character while the producers refused to take his concerns seriously, he stopped trying. While waiting anxiously for someone to finally pull the plug on this doomed T.V. show, he wrote one final scathing memo bitterly complaining about the writing for Spock. This memo has infamously gained the title of “The Letter.” It concluded with these words:

My primary interest in contacting you gentlemen is my concern over my lack of experience in playing dummies. Perhaps you could arrange to get me educated in this area. Maybe if I watched some “Blondie” episodes and watched Dagwood as a role model, I could pick up some pointers. Or better still, I could get right to the bottom line by wearing some braids and feathers and learning to grunt, “Ugh, Kimosabee”? (Nimoy, 1995:126)
 
Well, the title of his first autobiography was "I Am Not Spock," which was actually written to show the readers the man behind the character, and not necessarily a disdain on the Spock character he portrayed.

Who out there wants to be typecast? Sure, Nimoy got plenty of work during the 70's and 80's, but he was primarily known for those "pointy ears." Even John Wayne came up to him at a party and joked about what happened to his ears once during the 70's.

I suppose with age, and the fact that Nimoy realized that Star Trek was helping him pay his bills (and then some...), and allowed him to explore creatively those artistic projects and pet projects (photography, environmentalism, etc.), he came to embrace his role as Spock in the public's eye. Spock made him very successful. After all, in the mid-90's he wrote a second autobiography titled "I Am Spock." :cool:
 
Those two titles are so telling IMO. I Am Not Spock!, no wait.. I Am Spock. It's like a split personality disorder that Nimoy's coped with for 40 years.

It is true that I Am Not Spock wasn't meant to be an outright negative statement about typecasting, but the book contains some interesting tidbits that show how uncomfortable Nimoy was the rebirth of Trek in the 70s.

If the article is correct, then at the very time Nimoy was doing everything that he could to not be called Spock, he was becoming Spock in a huge way.

So, I don't think it was just a joke to label his first memoir I Am Not Spock!
 
Nimoy, like Shatner, like Doohan and Takei and Koenig, wanted to be actors. A little three-year job they took on to pay the bills basically foreclosed all meaningful acting gigs for the rest of their lives. In the 70s, they all resented the hell out of it. By the 90s they all became reconciled to their fate.

I excluded De here; he fairly happily retired after TOS.
 
^^^The same thing happens to all of us, eventually. It's called "growing up." When I was a kid I wanted to be the world's greatest disc jockey. Instead, I became a better than average radio news guy. I suspect I came to grips the fact that the big dream wouldn't happen at about the same age, Nimoy and company came to grips with the reality of their lives.

I think if you look at in perspective, they all managed to make a decent living in their chosen fields and that's an accomplishment in itself.

Another comparison would be someone who has a lifelong ambition of finding a cure for cancer, but has to "settle" for being a family doctor.

I think they've all reached a stage where they realize they have very respectable bodies of work and if none of them replaced Olivier as the "next great actor" they've all done some work they can be proud of and if there are roles they'd rather everyone forget about, that's the nature of the beast. After all, F. Murray Abraham played the grapes in a fruit of the loom ad before winning an Oscar for Amadeus...
 
Good Will Riker said:
MikeH92467 said:
After all, F. Murray Abraham played the grapes in a fruit of the loom ad before winning an Oscar for Amadeus...
...and went onto star in Star Trek: Insurrection! :guffaw:

I wonder which one he considers the bigger professional embarrassment?
:vulcan:
 
Well, it's not so bad - to millions of Transfans, Ninoy is also revered as the true voice of this fellow:



(Ha - maybe after 'I am not Spock' and 'I am Spock', his next book could be 'I am also Galvatron!')


Gary
 
I don't think Nimoy's love/hate relationship with Spock is all that unusual. I'm sure most actors who have had tremendous success with one particular role have the same sort of feelings: Love that the character has brought them such fame; hate that it has hurt their ability to play other roles.
 
An interesting subject. I suppose it's time to read his books. I went for the lesser known books 1st, Takei & Nichols, then Kelley's. Some celebs quite enjoy their fame, & others prefer their privacy. Which is certainly understandable. The guy who played Frank on MASH had a hard time getting serious roles after that, so I can see how that would be frustrating.

As for fame, Paul Stanley was asked by an interviewer if he got tired of people following him around, bothering him & asking for autographs & such, he replied; I have to keep a towel with me to wipe up all the tears.
 
I loved that book -- I Am Not Spock. I had it autographed by him in 1983 and he told me, while signing it then turning the pages over in his hand -- "I loved writing this book."

reading that book, it makes you realize how incredible that character really was. whoever's responsible for it, Roddenberry, Coon, Fontana, Nimoy etc... if not for that character, Trek would not be where it is today.

those of you who haven't read it yet, run to amazon now. :)
 
indranee said:

reading that book, it makes you realize how incredible that character really was. whoever's responsible for it, Roddenberry, Coon, Fontana, Nimoy etc... if not for that character, Trek would not be where it is today.
I agree with this completely. There are thousands of Kirks out there, as he is one of "A Hero With A Thousand Faces." However, there is only one Mr. Spock. He was for me (and many fans out there) the longest time the primary reason for watching Star Trek regularly. :vulcan:
 
Let's also remember Leonard's other book in the series, I Am Also Scotty. :D

sunshine1.gif
 
^^ Ronald, it's a Simpsons gag. There was an ep where the comic book guy bought Nimoy's books, including I Am Not Spock, I Am Spock, and I Am Also Scotty.

sunshine1.gif
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top