• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

New version of The Twilight Zone to be on CBS All Access

After watching the train wreck that this last ep was, I really have to wonder: are there no good writers on staff who can write a short 20 mn episode with a solid premise, suspense, and a good twist at the end?
Agree. This new Twilight Zone's episodes are disappointing like Rod Serling's Night Gallery episodes were.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Oofa, just saw the most recent one. Very Anthony Fremont and nowhere near as well done. The whole thing made zip sense.
 
It sounded horrible from the descriptions and the trump stuff really does get old, but the actual ep actually amused me more than I expected. I kinda liked it
 
"The Wunderkind" might very well be the absolute worst Twilight Zone episode ever in the entire history of TV. I feel like I have been psychologically tortured. There is so much that is wrong about the episode that I am struggling to even organize my thoughts.

1) It is a such a blunt metaphor for Trump that it loses all value. The episode literally hits the viewer in the head over and over again with the criticisms of Trump (immature, incompetent, uninformed, etc) but there is zero subtlety and zero intelligence in how the episode does it. Metaphors have to have some intelligence to them in order to work. This episode did not do that.

2) The child was super annoying, it was grating. I just wanted to smack the kid. Why anyone would ever listen to this kid in the first place is beyond ridiculous.

3) The very concept of a kid running for president completely strains credibility. For one, it completely violates the constitution because he fails the age requirement. The episode tries to get around this by saying that the mother's name was on the ballot. What!? No, that does not work! If her name were on the ballot, she would President, not the kid. Plus, it would be obvious election fraud if her name were on the ballot but the kid was going around being the candidate. The Federal Election Committee or whatever would never allow it. The other candidates would never allow it. And where was the vice-president in all this? No mention of the vice-president. And the episode completely skips from the Iowa caucus straight to Inauguration day. So the kid somehow got through all the primaries, and the party still nominated him and he won the general election? Seriously!?! Oh and what party was he running on? Was he running as an independent and he somehow beat both major parties? Or did one of the major parties (Democrats or Republicans) actually nominate a 11 year old kid to be their national candidate? And we are really supposed to believe that one video about his dying dog would save his campaign after literally having him cry for his mommy on national TV. It is utterly preposterous and had so many plot holes, it makes your head spin.

4) Are we really supposed to believe that grown men like the Chief of Staff and the General would take orders from a 11 year old kid? And what about Congress? Impeachment? 25th amendment? Are we really supposed to believe that the entire government and as we see in the episode, the entire nation is so enamored with the kid that they are ok with it? I get the Trump metaphor (Trump acts immature or incompetent or obstructs justice and nobody does anything to remove him from office) but it just strains all credibility.

Basically, when your metaphor is implausible and ridiculous, it fails because the audience can't get pass how ridiculous it is. There has to be some realism for the metaphor to work. The very premise of a 11 year old running for President is so ludicrous that it causes everything else to collapse.

5) The episode was not even well written and it was too long.There were no interesting scenes or thought provoking scenes. Nothing. It was just an episode with a bratty kid running around that dragged on way too long.

6) It was too predictable. They literally show us Ralph in some type of creepy surgery scene right off the bat and tell us it is a flash forward which gave away the ending. And we knew as soon as he decided to represent the kid that the kid was going to be elected somehow. It was utterly predictable.

There are probably other flaws but those are the main ones that I could think of off the top of my head.

Black Mirror actually did this very same topic much better, in the ep "the Waldo moment" where an offensive cartoon character runs for president and wins. That episode was much better because while a cartoon character running for president is absurd, it is a bit more believable than a kid who wants to play video games. And that episode actually had some good scenes in it. And the episode did explore some nice themes of how the population responds to an outsider candidate.

The Outer limits also did a good "President" episode with Babylon 5's Bruce Boxleitner called "Decompression". That episode dealt with a mysterious time traveler from the future who convinces a presidential candidate that he needs to jump from a plane that is going to crash to save himself. The traveler promises to save him when he jumps and tells him that he must do it to live because only he can save America from a horrible dystopian future. The candidate, being a total narcissist, jumps and naturally falls to his death and we learn that the traveler from the future essentially tricked him into committing suicide because he was not going to save the country, he was actually going to be the dictator that destroys America. Now that was a great episode! It had tension. It had great acting. It had an ironic twist. This episode had nothing like that.
Thank you for taking the time to write all of that because that's exactly how I felt, especially point 3).

The metaphor of this episode wasn't just painfully obvious, it was redundant. It just kept beating the same drum over and over and over again with no attempt to learn from the metaphor, which is very essence of The Twilight Zone. I'm shocked that this episode was actually produced and that anyone involved thought it was any good.

I see the latest episode is really disliked here, but I thought it was OK. I enjoyed the Trump digs. I guess whether you like it or not may depend on how you feel regarding the current president.
I'm all for mocking him but put some effort into it. This was just plain lazy. I've seen more effort in a Colbert monologue (not a knock on Colbert, I love him and his monologues).
 
I've watched the first 5 episodes and it's excellent nonsense! A good range of stories here, (Star Trek was already repeating it's themes 5 episodes in). Nice nostalgia with the original closing theme and other easter eggs. My favourite episode so far is episode 3. Worst episode so far IMO was probbly episode 4, I forget the titles.

Agree. This new Twilight Zone's episodes are disappointing like Rod Serling's Night Gallery episodes were.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Night Gallery is the shit! Just skip the ones not written by Rod Serling.
 
While "The Wunderkind" may be absolute horseshit, it did have one redeeming quality: Chief Tyrol from nuBSG as the Marine general. He was actually pretty funny.

The kid, on the other hand...made Trump look like JFK. I don't think I've ever seen any character in any TV series in history, as annoying as this little shit.

About the only way I can make this episode make sense is that it never actually happened, and it's something Raff Hanks dreamed up in an alcoholic haze. That's probably what the writers did, anyway.

No 1015, though. That's the only reason I watched the whole thing - to see if 1015 would pop up again. :lol:

And I understand the reference, but...the "Whipple News Network"? :guffaw:
 
Last edited:
This week we have episode five, "The Wunderkind" (starring that guy who was on the first season of Sleepy Hollow). This one was the most baffling yet. I think at this point we can safely say that this revival is aimed squarely at the Millennial Generation, because the levels of political naivete and thematic misfires are astonishing.

There really wasn't what you would call a story here. There was a sequence of events that involved a child being elected president, followed by his campaign manager apparently being killed because of a random statement the kid had made outlawing adult doctors. There was no thematic connection to any element of the story and no relevance to the assumed target of the satire. He might as well have been set upon by that pack of dogs. Furthermore, this pseudo-twist was telegraphed from the opening scene, so it wasn't even a surprise.

The most glaring deficit, aside from a plot, was the lack of a catalyst propelling us into the Twilight Zone. The original show would set the stage for a social satire of this magnitude by placing us unambiguously in an alternate reality or a vaguely futuristic time. But here there was no such surreal setting, nor was there even a mysterious bar patron or traveler, haunted video camera or MP3 player, or even a JFK silver dollar sitting inexplicably on edge. There wasn't even a prologue in the opening narration noting how all qualifications for the presidency had been impulsively repealed without thought to the consequences. Nothing. The venue was essentially the equivalent of our world in which more impossible things happened than even Mary Poppins could handle.

Clearly, this was supposed to be a satire of President The Donald-- but at this it failed badly. While the genuine article gained traction by exploiting the base vulgarity of one ideology and the moral abdication of the other, this kid won over the country across the board with love and puppies. What the hell kind of satire is that? The Donald is only childish in the sense that he's mentally retarded-- wouldn't an escapee from an asylum or a psychotic sniper be a better surrogate? Why make the theme that power corrupts when your source material is about how corruption is power? And how are we to parse the campaign manager, who had regrets and died for them? What is the message here, folks?

Next week: An outer-space adventure. Perhaps it will be a stinging indictment of mesothelioma.
 
This week’s was better though at 53 minutes it was too long. It could’ve been half an hour easily. The twist was pretty obvious though but I only guessed it half right.
 
I haven't watched any of these yet, and after reading what you guys have been saying about the episodes not sure if I'm going to, I've got a lot of other better recieved things to watch. I still haven't checked out Black Mirror yet, and that seems to have gotten a much better reception.
My first thought when I heard about the kid president episode was the DC comics Prez. There are two versions of the comic, one from 1973/4 about a teenage boy is elected President after a new amendment to the Constitution is passed allowing teens to hold office. The other version is from 2015 and follows a teenage girl who is elected via Twitter.
 
"6 degrees of freedom" was really good. I always love space travel so I loved the themes of this episode. It was tense with some nice character moments. The scene with the guy freaking out about it all being a simulation was well done. The ending was good too.
 
"6 degrees of freedom" was OK. This will be my last TZ episode for a while as I have cancelled my CBS AA subscription. I see the rest when I come back for Picard.
 
So was it real and the aliens were just watching or was it a simulation run by the aliens? I am thinking the latter since the guy who said it was simulation and opened the hatch to the void of space would have died if it was real but he was alive at the end. So it was a simulation just not run by humans to test them for survival but run by aliens to test them for first contact. Right?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top