• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

new Total Recall trailer

You realize, I'm sure, this movie is more closely tied to the original short-story than it is the Schwarzenegger movie, right? (And IIRC the original story didn't have much to do, if anything, with Mars.)

But very few people have even heard of the original story. When the Total Recal title is mentioned people think of the Arnie movie with the extreme violence and funny one liners.

If they are going to use the original story why didn't they use the original book title?
 
You realize, I'm sure, this movie is more closely tied to the original short-story than it is the Schwarzenegger movie, right? (And IIRC the original story didn't have much to do, if anything, with Mars.)

I've never read the original story.

Few have, really. But the way you were talking here it seemed you were unaware that this movie was more of a new take on the story than it was a remake of the movie.
 
Few have, really. But the way you were talking here it seemed you were unaware that this movie was more of a new take on the story than it was a remake of the movie.
I've read the story and seen the 1990 movie, and this trailer looks *much* more like a remake of that movie than a new adaptation of the short story. I don't remember a three-breasted hooker in the short story... ;)
 
You realize, I'm sure, this movie is more closely tied to the original short-story than it is the Schwarzenegger movie, right? (And IIRC the original story didn't have much to do, if anything, with Mars.)
But very few people have even heard of the original story. When the Total Recal title is mentioned people think of the Arnie movie with the extreme violence and funny one liners.

If they are going to use the original story why didn't they use the original book title?
Simple: marketing.

But after watching that trailer, it's clear that this new movie will be more of a remake than I'd originally thought. Probably a blend of the original short story and the Schwarzenegger movie.
 
You realize, I'm sure, this movie is more closely tied to the original short-story than it is the Schwarzenegger movie, right? (And IIRC the original story didn't have much to do, if anything, with Mars.)

I've never read the original story.

Few have, really. But the way you were talking here it seemed you were unaware that this movie was more of a new take on the story than it was a remake of the movie.
That is what was originally said, but, that Trailer, makes it appear to be an almost exact remake of the Arnold movie, if you simply take away the Mars element. Lines and scenes lifted directly from the Arnold movie
 
The original film was perfect... that's the main reason this film will have problems
Verhoeven's Total Recall isn't the worst Philip K. Dick film ever, but it was pretty mediocre (and lacked the great ending of the short story). Really the only appealing thing about it is the idea that the tiresome action cheese that drives the picture just the fantasy of a brain frying itself in a chair.

This looks like it might be pretty good, but again, not holding my breath (would rather see I don't know a movie out of Ubik by let's say Linklater but you can't always have what you want).
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top